According to new capital newspaper, the film " fragrant China " offend went up tort lawsuit, accuser is like a gentleman to think this film borroweds oneself play " of blue Mu gal save atone for " , just reach film copyright director Feng Xiaogang to accuse forensic claim for compensation more than yuan 300. The agent of the 4 the accused in front courtyard careful expresses, the film already with former novel " fragrant China " author Yan Geling signs an agreement, lawful origin asks to reject sue.
" fragrant China " showed 2017, playwrite is Yan Geling, those who tell about is the story of song and dance ensemble, as to " of blue Mu gal save atone for " , it is the student studying abroad's story, want the word that breaks really forcedly, be to have two leading role probably? Be still to be below warlike setting? If if so if saying, that " of blue Mu gal save atone for " did not borrowed famous " does fetch break La Qiao " ? Be also warlike setting? Be also two leading role? So say the word that is tort, that also too was pulled? Is basic electrify shadow two leading role? The film that said to be setting with the war again became much went, why to sue Feng Xiaogang alone alone?
Next, the clue of a film, it is the problem of playwrite, feng Xiaogang also is the copyright that buys legally over Yan Geling, should be like a gentleman to want to sue be to sue Yan Geling? because of Feng Xiaogang money touchs porcelain? This is to be in make a person incomprehensible. The motive that must let person suspicion be like a gentleman is undesirable.
Speak of the problem that tort borroweds, not only renown director Feng Xiaogang is deep-set among them, zhang Yi is sought also do not have method to request these topics, 18 years of films " shadow " with respect to tort of dub in background music be prosecutioned, dong Ying of the teacher that is central music institute obviously, composer is amounted to for film dub in background music, did not sign however finally, and the film used extremely similar dub in background music, then the teachers and students of central music institute seeks Zhang Yi tell a court.
" a thousand li walks along Chan Qi " it is Zhang Yi is sought film a film 2005, zhang Yi is sought in this in the treatment that to install having the " of more than 600 years of histories suitable play " had art is changed and engraft, the exorcise that will install suitable play successfully to be changed into Chinese Yunnan Li Jiang makes fun of. To this, how does Guizhou Province arrange bureau of city culture sports to sue Zhang Yi to seek, the film " a thousand li walks along Chan Qi " when filming, how to arrange 8 ground play actors to answer of the accused before inviting, go to Li Jiang, performed " how to make fun of suitably " in traditional a list of plays " Zhan Tong closes " and " a thousand li walks along Chan Qi " . But film says however for " Yunnan mask makes fun of " . An Shunwen changes sports bureau to think, the film will install suitable play misdirect to make fun of into Yunnan mask, encroached accuser sign authority.
But should not sue finally hold water, one quadrangle final judgment adjudges Beijing, the court thinks to bring suitable show is type of drama, not be work, do not get copyright law protection. The court rejects appeal, maintain first instance original judgement.
? To renown director, its influence is tremendous, still should treat tort borrowed carefully incident had better.
