Architect misestimate; of fire prevention situation and security personnel from discovery on fire arrives branch of announcement fire control wants to be wasted for nothing 6 minutes unexpectedly...
According to the United States " new York Times " and the report of media of French much home, world-famous Parisian goddess courtyard meets France suffer so serious damage in the fire recently, having close relationship with the huge hole of system of goddess courtyard fire prevention.
(The graph is " new York Times " report)
Among them, ever came 2000 the architect that project of system of goddess courtyard fire prevention is in charge of between 2013 Benjamin Mu red (Benjamin Mouton) thinks the old oak capable person that goddess courtyard attic has 800 years of histories is qualitative for a time won't burn very quickly after on fire, meet only slow combustion, this meeting goes to the time with enough firemen put out a fire.
So, encounter when goddess courtyard merciless conflagration is gobbled up violently this hind, mu Tong expresses him when accepting French media to interview also very " amazed " .
He says: "I by these goddess courtyards speed of those oak place flaming were stupefied thoroughly. So old oak stuff can be burned impossibly so quickly like match, this makes a person incomprehensible too " .
(The graph is what Mu Tong accepts French media to interview, among them the oak lumber that he expresses to these have 800 old histories ought not to be burned so quickly character)
To this, " new York Times " a fire control expert of Australia that interview thinks, mu Tong may be an oak the time of complete burn down, the incident that diffuses with igneous situation gives confused: Although oak may be burned very slow, but the oak wood that igneous affection accumulates in such bedding face is qualitative in diffuse rising is very fast.
And besides this miscarriage of justice of one, the fire alarm system of goddess courtyard itself also is a problem heavily.
" new York Times " say, after the fire alarm of goddess courtyard is knocked noisy, this system can not inform fire control of automatically the branch, igneous condition is inspected on the stair that needs security personnel to climb at least 6 minutes first however in attic, call the police next again by security personnel...
This newspaper returns scale a piece of sketch map, revealed this " climb stairs 6 minutes " process...
(The picture comes from " new York Times " , the part of color of the orange in the graph needs to climb for security personnel that paragraph at least 6 minutes of right-and-left stair)
Nevertheless, " new York Times " also point out, with the United States system of fire alarm of very much important architectural can inform fire control the branch is different automatically, fire alarm system of France won't inform fire control of automatically the branch originally.
French Paris fire department says, this is to avoid to sign up for by accident, so ability can let security personnel affirm on fire first, will call the police again.
Can come so, arrive at goddess courtyard to firemen since fire alarm noise and taking squirt to enter attic, had among this probably defer of 20 minutes. "20 minutes can be a huge incur loss through delay, I am done do not understand for what they can be made give a so big delay " , " new York Times " that fire control expert of Australia that interview says.
(Check scheme comes from the report of new York Times)
Finally, basis " new York Times " view, these huge hole that the fire prevention of Parisian goddess courtyard can appear in the design, also not be the responsibility that designs staff, because plan of this fire prevention is to pass French government layer upon layer examine and approve, pass French culture ministry even finally.
In the meantime, this newspaper still points out the budget is not the cause that causes these flaw to appear, the budget that actually French government gives goddess courtyard to make fire prevention system is very enough.
In light of the view when the person such as Dan Congmu red accepts French media to interview, the problem may be to result from " repair old as usual " on concept of ancient building protection, namely for complete save the oak attic with goddess ancient courtyard, design personnel did not install the fire prevention measure such as device of automatic put out a fire and firewall again.
Accordingly, " new York Times " a few experts that interview think, the ancient architectural that if design a group to be able to be in at that time,safeguards 850 years is primitive a few sacrifice are made on scene, the consideration is contemporary and sensitive a more eclectic protection is taken after intricate fire state of affairs plan, this conflagration is a lot of mediumer nowadays the place that is marred badly, can avoid or be better stop caustic...
(Check scheme comes from the report of new York Times)
