Became 30 old editors, experience is the most difficult is selection of subject of a book again good, authorial level is again high, oversight bagatelle ruins sth possibly. What want to say today is about " Chinese graving graph is recorded " the thing of plate respect. State above all, " Chinese graving graph is recorded " (the following abbreviation " the graph is recorded " ) be up to now the collection of graph of an ancient books with academic top level, this are unassailable. So I why one and again again and the carries it defect of 3? Consider a proof namely, the more famous, the work with academic high value, oversight a few look seem not large issue, give an issue more easily, and very regrettablly.
I had written an article a few years ago, point out " the graph is recorded " plate is cut into parts to had been cut for the most part, lost ancient books former appearance, cut cut away into parts even a few collect books imprint and preface and postscript; What should nag today is, " the graph is recorded " optional sex is stronger when choosing plate, have the quality of caustic Yu Quanshu. I think, when collection of ancient books graph chooses plate should first selection coils one, unless coil originally,be short of break. If other of an end article the look is better, or more seal wait, can choose of course, but coil to still have to go up. " the graph is recorded " be being done in this respect is not very reach the designated position, several are lifted only below.
1, " the graph is recorded " " the Tang Dynasty " what use edition (66) department " Tang Shu " 101, " desolate biographies " the 26th, top right corner of plate board casing is misshapen. If have handwriting of two archiveses paper because of this plate and if using, still have archives handwriting more so more apparent can choose.
This world of 02 Tang Shusong Europe repair Song Qi to wait for the carry on that write the Song Dynasty to promote the Wang Yong that think of a brook from engrave Song Yuan to give printed books of long archives paper to coil one
2, " the graph is recorded " " market of The Book of Rites says " what use plate (one) the department coils 4, without seal, coil to be mixed a lot of otherer roll roll end all has seal.
Market of 03 The Book of Rites says to coil 4 without seal plate 102
Market of 04 The Book of Rites says to coil to have seal
Market of 05 The Book of Rites says to coil 146 also have seal
3, " the graph is recorded " " anthology " what use plate (just a little 2) the department coils 8, roll one seal is more.
Afore-mentioned circumstances still have many, do not list one by one.
06 anthology coil 8 plate just a little 2
07 anthology coil one
Bigger question is, song Chunxi block-printed edition of Xiang of county of hill of 2 years of " ins and outs of issue of the age that know object lesson " , " the graph is recorded " a chosen 2 end of blade (plate one) , half leaf 14, say with abstract place 13 not agree with. Via checking, whole book coils only 2 leaves are every half leaf 14, other all 13, just bumps to muzzle. Go alone for He Teli as to this leaf, I am discursive still, hope tall person shows just a little.
Ins and outs of issue of age of 08 ancient bronze mirror coils two leaves 14
Ins and outs of issue of age of 09 ancient bronze mirror coils half Xie Shisan goes
The biggest question is, " the graph is recorded " block-printed edition of Tang Zhai of alley of Zuo of city of state of Wu of the Song Dynasty " Zhou Li " the fault on plate (plate 88, 89) . National library hides alley of Zuo of city of state of Wu of two the Song Dynasty Tang Zhai block-printed edition " Zhou Li " , book number of an all alone 7922, book number of another all alone 8634. Family name of that 7922 department poplar " 4 Jian 4 Shi Zhi Zuo " old other people (roll Xie Qian has etc of one end of blade " 4 Jian 4 Shi Zhi Zuo " imprint) , with " the graph records " abstract place narrates positive accord with: "Kuang Gao 19 · 6 centimeters, 13 · of a centimeter. 13, row 25 words differ to 27 words. Note article Zuo travel, row 35 words, 36 words differ. White mouth, control Zuo Zuo . Ning of 4 Shi Zhi Zuo hide 4 Jian one of 4 Jian of Song Ben " . " the graph is recorded " the plate on the fault 8634 " Zhou Li " , put an in part only originally, roll 7 to 12 match block-printed edition of another the Song Dynasty to add commentate text. Actually an one end of blade of 8634 also 6 collect books imprint, do not know " the graph is recorded " why should use those who do not have seal to coil 2.
Block-printed edition of Tang Zhai of alley of door of city of state of Wu of the Song Dynasty of 10 weeks of ceremonies coils 8634 2 plate 88
Block-printed edition of Tang Zhai of alley of door of city of state of Wu of the Song Dynasty of 11 weeks of ceremonies coils 3 leaves remaining part 8634 plate 89
Block-printed edition of Tang Zhai of alley of door of city of state of Wu of the Song Dynasty of 12 weeks of ceremonies coils to have seal 8634
13 weeks of ceremonies block-printed edition of Tang Zhai of alley of door of city of state of Wu of 12 the Song Dynasty coils one Yang " 4 Jian 4 Shi Zhi Zuo " old other people 7922
Block-printed edition of Tang Zhai of alley of door of city of state of Wu of the Song Dynasty of 14 weeks of ceremonies coils 3 leaves remaining part Yang " 4 Jian 4 Shi Zhi Zuo " old other people 7922
According to my old editor experience, " the graph is recorded " the author that occurrence problem most is a book is busier, wait for attached drawing data sex " bagatelle " give assistant goes doing, "Big " turn when assistant is busy also give " small " assistant. Notice, the educational level of assistant and the comprehension to this book often are slippery. And these " bagatelle " the problem that create actually not small. Take care of everything oneself still is sometimes must.
Look from the angle of the press, responsibility edits final to a book quality, can have very big effect. An eligible responsibility editor wants to be in charge of seriously above all, close besides the character good main body, content closes, quotation of even serious examine and verify and attached drawing, prevent accident. An outstanding editor, can have the effect of half author sometimes. Encounter such editor, the author is have good fortune. Alleged " editor pleasant is made for other marry clothes " , pointing to is this.
