Privately swarm picks Yang Mei dropping to die
It is too good to be cultivated quite conversely climb, doesn't scene area have risk clew?
This news caused netizen heat to discuss recently
The comment is as high as 200 thousand with card number!
The thing is such:
Wu Mou of nearly 60 years old,
Was in Guangzhou last year in May area of some village scene,
Mount the red bayberry tree by wadi to pick Yang Mei.
Because branch is withered sodden rupture,
Wu Mou declines from the tree,
Via sending hospital cure invalid death.
Subsequently the family member runs scene division square village appoint can tell a court,
Claim for compensation 60 beyond.
The family member's reason:
The tree is too good climb, scene area did not hint risk
This scene area regards national 3A class as travel scene area, the dike both sides of its core area has the Yang Mei of not less than 50 individual plant to cultivate. Because place of engraft of red bayberry tree is inferior, climb extremely easily climb, during every mature to Yang Mei, personnel of many view scene climbs the Yang Mei that climbs red bayberry tree, picked tree to go up, undertake fooling grabbing even, scene area never adopts safe dredge or the safe risk such as management is on guard measure.
It is reported, these arbutus of river side are cultivated,
Belong to local villager committee all,
Not to the villager or tourist
Offer activity of free picked arbutus.
Controversy focus:
Should be scene area carried duty? How much to carry?
● court thinks, wu Mou serves as adult, cultivate picked Yang Mei without agreeing with privately to go up, its ought to expect dangerous sex, its itself ought to be opposite reason oneself is damaged assume responsibility.
● is in this case, itself of red bayberry tree does not have safe hidden trouble, it is Wu Mou disregarded the tree on oneself age privately to bring about dangerous generation.
● village appoint the controller of the everybody that can cultivate as Yang Mei and scene area, did not climb the dangerous sex that climbs red bayberry tree to make certain caution inform to plucking Yang Mei is reached, put in certain fault.
● basis " mode of travel of People's Republic of China " reach " of grade of quality of travel scene area delimit dispenses assess " regulation, sudden incident perhaps travels after safe accident happens, travel operator should be adopted instantly necessary deliverance and deal with measure. Wu Mou falls from red bayberry tree fall after getting hurt, personnel already came off work related infirmary, and the accused did not establish necessary sudden incident to handle beforehand case, bring about Wu Mou to cannot get medical treatment deliverance in time, put in certain fault to harm amplification.
Final, the court is so sentence!
Take into consideration the circumstances maintains scene area to assume the responsibility of 5% ,
Yongxian008: This is accused, does the face return otherwise?
Fire: It is him old person obviously quality is low bring about oneself to perish, shift responsibility to others however.
Zhong Shao does not hold you: This responsibility of 5% decides, also be indulgent blackguardly behavior. The tiger is not let off, also did not let off even motionless tree now! ! !
Xiehaosz: This kind belongs to act shamelessly, belong to dead where bluff which masterpiece.
Also a lot of netizens feel the responsibility of 5% does not have scene area illness:
Qiu Daxian: Family member shameless puts in shameless 's charge, the court sentences do not have illness.
LeffWalker: The responsibility of 5% is chased after duty also be fair and reasonable, after all scene area did not bear a caution responsibility.
Motomimost: Public governor has controller responsibility, this because be accuser oneself fault,be main responsibility, so controller responsibility is reduced.
Block of green unlined upper garment does not live: Do not calculate a try to mediate differences at the sacrifice of principle, the fact is clear, logic is clear, rational has according to. Should say to be opposite when thing both sides very fair.
The netizen thinks cannot abet " unjustifiable claim for compensation " wind:
I am your aunt: later should every tree register a trademark? Every car speed limit 20 kilometers are horary, the thing of sex of this kind of common sense, adult is judged somewhat with respect to this originally and discriminate, this kind of responsibility decides is a try to mediate differences at the sacrifice of principle.
Dance water laughs: Set upright a brand! "Spray pesticide ～ poison absolutelies refuse to compensate! " however true somebody kill with poison! The court still sentences compensate!
This amuses than: Meet such person, even if be the preventive measure that has mark card, he also should climb euqally, fall dead to also want to declare scene area euqally. Scene area stems from humanitarian to still also want compensate a few.
Still the netizen says, the ground that can declare by this train of thought is very much:
Princess of A Yi ground beetle: The tree is too good climb, claim for compensation looking for a tree
Bojieke mark: Tell the world next time, turn ceaseless all the time for what, shake old people came down? ? ? ?
Amcat_ : Ask scene area to become estranged in order to destroy caustic of tree of claim for compensation of family member of public property requirement upkeep cost.
Shfax99: The park should accuse the death of the old person to bring negative effect to the park, bring about tourist quantity to drop, give economy to compensate for ^_^
Way is good: This adjudicates the individual thinks to do not have illness, old person anxious to get things on the cheap is right, but just have field tell the obligation such as caution, behoove negative should manage responsibility. The Euramerican country with sound legal system adjudicates so much went.
Pchou: Red bayberry drops underground, walk to slip to get hurt; Red bayberry drops the ground, crouch one case collected too much second, lumbar flesh gets hurt; Look up see Yang Mei did not notice the foot leaves a way, trip bumps to get hurt. Need too much reminder.
How do you look?
No matter whether the tree is good,climb,
Take without allowing to go... what to calculate? !
Companionate to this people what wants to say? !
?
