Recently, happen in Jiangsu the Huaihe River to install campus one case in to be killed instead case cause social attention. This school 3 21 years old of students beat up 19 years old alumnus, among them two people are turned over to kill.
Be hit at the same time when a case " campus ride roughshod over " , " self-defence " when two label, hard to avoid causes social discussion. Kill instead in this in the case, whether can be 19 years old of students that are beaten up maintained to be " is defense become too " ? The campus ride roughshod over that is paid close attention to by social height in recent years, how should defeat solution again?
Experience thing learns field officer net
3 students beat up a classmate to be killed instead by
Recently, the video that circulates on a nets causes a netizen to pay close attention to.
Video presentation, on May 12, jiangsu the Huaihe River is installed, 3 students beat up an alumnus, among them two people are turned over to kill. The classmate says, a few people before this have contradiction early.
According to the report, li Yun of this school student (alias) say, lou Dongwu of accident institute dormitory abandons 6 buildings, jiang Mou fastens preparatory class student, "Controlled 11:50 in the evening, there is very big noise hum outside the dormitory, lasted 3 minutes or so, the police came later, take Jiang Mou to the outside of the dormitory inquiry. Take Jiang Mou to the outside of the dormitory inquiry..
Li Yun says, the ambulance arrives subsequently, carry a few casualties, dormitory front door is blocked, student can from side door pass in and out. According to the video presentation that Li Yun films, arm of left hand of a man of white short sleeve has bloodstain to stand outside dormitory building door, a liveried man is speaking with him.
According to the report, experience thing average per capita is the student of institute of technology of profession of Jiangsu finance and economics. The staff member reveals fair room of this school office, batsman of a few hit is a senior. At present school student attends class normally, was not affected.
13 days, the Huaihe River installs substation of development of technology of economy of city public security bureau to be reported through Guan Wei, the Huaihe River brings one institute 3 students beat up one student, kill instead by send 2 dead 1 injury, guilty suspect already was seized, the case is doing in detect in.
According to the bulletin, on May 12 23 when make 55 minutes, the Huaihe River installs city technology development to produce great criminal details of a case one case. Via be being checked first, zou Mou (male, 21 years old) , Qiu Mou (male, 21 years old) , Feng Mou (male, 21 years old) because bagatelle dispute beats up Jiang Mou,wait for a person (male, 19 years old of) , jiang Mou hurts Zou Mou, Qiu Mou, Feng Mou with dagger disclose (experience thing average per capita is some colleger) . Zou Mou, Feng Mou disables to die unfortunately via rescue after, qiu Mou gets flesh wound. Jiang Mou already was seized.
Current, local police is doing good case detect actively to do, cooperate relevant section to do the work such as good deal with problems arising from an accident.
Controversy: Calculate do not calculate self-defence?
After this incident is exposed to the sun to go out, many netizens expressed his opinion.
Among them, the netizen thinks, the person such as Zou Mou, Qiu Mou, Feng Mou with big bully small, with much bully little, bring about Jiang Mou to be able to choose revolt only, ought to maintain for self-defence.
Small gain cut pursues
But at the same time, also the netizen says, jiang Mou holds dagger, already exceeded the limit of self-defence, should belong to defense to be become too.
Small gain cut pursues
Be aimed at the netizen's misgive, the reporter interviewed the legal expert of relevant domain at this point.
Zhao Qingxia of solicitor of office of attorney of Tianjin Chen extensive region thinks, the evidence that because be announced at present,gives is more finite, jiang Mou's practice whether form self-defence to need a consideration the following a variety of case, and the dagger that Jiang Mou uses, the key that also can make a case one annulus.
Zhao Qingxia is analysed, because the origin of dagger did not allude in police bulletin, if dagger is someone else is carried, jiang Mou is in after be being come over by the loot in enroach on process, someone else still continues to have inroad to its, jiang Mou to ensure oneself safety, when brandish dagger someone else accidentally injure, it is to be able to maintain those who be self-defence.
But if Jiang Mou loot arrives after dagger, had made other a few people feel fear and stop enroach on, but Jiang Mou holds a knife to have inroad to someone else conversely, had exceeded necessary limit, belong to defense to be become too.
In the meantime, zhao Qingxia returns an analysis, because the classmate has mentioned a few people between have contradiction early, if this dagger is Jiang Mou,sedulous belt is on the body, borrow opportunity is right other applying enroach on of a few people, may form intended harm.
"The subjective motive of party is different, may reach different conclusion, see the evidence of police control finally even. " Zhao Qingxia says.
Data chart: Zhengzhou is special alarm deduce self-defence skill. Liu Tao is photographed
How does difficult problem of campus ride roughshod over defeat solution?
Send episode of campus ride roughshod over more in recent years, affecting the nerve of student and parent for long, also by focusing of height of social public opinion.
According to the State Council educational superintend and director guides the bulletin of council office, 2018 4 to the incident of 80 students ride roughshod over that network media will report in December in, the victim of 91.2% appeals not actively, ride roughshod over of above of half the number person know without clarity to oneself behavior, middle and primary school is born to still be put in inadequacy to the acknowledge of campus ride roughshod over.
And in legal level, campus ride roughshod over faces predicament likewise.
"In China's current jurisprudence, undertake limitting without special legal standard to campus ride roughshod over. " Zhao Qingxia says, legislative branch can consider to wait for means to make more specific provision to this with legislation or judicatory explanation, from proceed with of perfect legal system, solve this kind of problem.
An Xiang of director of office of Beijing De Xiang's attorney thinks, in domain of campus ride roughshod over, the law that although have a lot of,has is OK and applicable, but the characteristic that legislative branch can be based on campus and minor characteristic, legal laws and regulations undertakes refining further related consideration general.
In the meantime, an Xiang still expresses, answer the episode of campus ride roughshod over that sends more in recent years, need school, judiciary, society and family are hit " assorted fist " .
He explains further say, the tall hair that minor can have an illegal criminality period, their intelligence is not quite mature and stable, what also can sentence a thing beforehand not quite is sequential, this needs the school the angle from education, judiciary the angle from law, domestic society is built from psychology wait for many sided proceed with, help minor can spend this paragraph of illegal crime with immature, diseased psychology smoothly to be sent high period.
