Recently, tsinghua university go up again heat up search
Because sue many " Tsinghua nursery school "
↓ ↓
8 days, response of nursery school of Tsinghua of one the accused says
"Tsinghua " period of 2 words the Eastern Jin dynasty has
The practice of Tsinghua university is too overbearing
On May 8 morning, tsinghua university accuses Jiangxi visits nursery school of Tsinghua of city of another name for Jiangxi Province " dispute of enroach on trademark one case " sessional cognizance. It is reported, tsinghua university because of brand tort, already mentioned in Jiangxi many lawsuit.
Sign up for a report according to new legal system, because be contained in nursery school name " Tsinghua " 2 words, tsinghua university saves nursery school of Tsinghua of county of city of a unit of dry measure for grain of city of another name for Jiangxi Province to mention to Jiangxi civil suit. According to the report, nursery school of Tsinghua of stone wall county held water in August 1998, its scope of business is child preschool education, it is a nursery school of run by the local people of Pu Hui sex.
The civil indictment of Tsinghua university shows, its predecessor fastens the Tsinghua school that established 1911, via approve of national brand bureau, accuser obtained the 1225974th on November 21, 1998 " clear Qu " trade mark right, obtained the 4724561st on January 28, 2009 " clear Qu university " trade mark right, scope of application all is the 41st kind " the school (education) , groom " wait for a service.
On October 16, 2006, national brand bureau will " Tsinghua university (Tsinghua) " maintain for well-known logo. On December 6, 2006, beijing is advanced people court is maintained in the 1481st civil judgment " clear Qu " for well-known logo.
Accordingly, tsinghua university thinks, registration book of nursery school of Tsinghua of stone wall county was used " Tsinghua " garden name, as well-known as Tsinghua university logo and school name " Tsinghua " form approximate, and cause easily promiscuous, disturbed market order, make unfair competition. Tsinghua university undertakes prosecution to nursery school of Tsinghua of stone wall county accordingly, ask its suspend tort action, and apologize in the newspaper a month, compensatory pecuniary loss and relevant charge 500 thousand yuan.
Nursery school of Tsinghua of one the accused is responded to
"Ask besides a thousand li the small nursery school of a be totally unrelated compensate 500 thousand, because the name is as same as its, it is overbearing actually, be be worthy of the name ' learn bully ' . " in the front courtyard careful on May 8, nursery school of Tsinghua of county of wall of stone of the accused Jiangxi is right of accuser Tsinghua university sue undertook rejoining.
On the court, the accused puts forward Tsinghua two words are element of Chinese traditional culture, have in moment of the Eastern Jin dynasty, its meaning is rich, the air with beauty, if scenery is comely Qing Yihua beauty, fresh article... " go up from this meaning for, tsinghua university is not had ' Tsinghua ' the copyright of 2 words, nonexistent also exclusive authority. " the accused counsel for the defence says, and nursery school of Tsinghua of stone wall county began recruit students in August 1998, antedate of Tsinghua university " clear Qu " brand, enjoy " Tsinghua " the prior use of 2 words.
The accused earlies childhood, "Tsinghua " 2 words are used extensively on China earth, if the Tsinghua of Jiangxi Wu source is pressed down, the Tsinghua highway of stone wall county is waited a moment, tsinghua nursery school names do not have any correlation with Tsinghua university. The accused expresses, tsinghua university " associate power is too substantial " , ask the Tsinghua nursery school besides a thousand li is compensated for, because the name is as same as its, the practice is too overbearing, be be worthy of the name " learn bully " .
In addition, the accused thinks, this case is brand tort and case of unfair competition issue, but main body of former defendant both sides makes brand tort and shocking tort conduct impossibly. Tsinghua university and Tsinghua nursery school all were not engaged in be the commercial act of the purpose in order to seek profits, because this does not talk to go up,trade issue competes, also do not talk to go up disturbed market order.
Additional, the reporter checks search discovery from weather eye, the whole nation " Tsinghua nursery school " amount to about a hundred.
For " Tsinghua " claim for compensation
Be not Tsinghua university first
The reporter understands, have on the hot water engine that because Fosan gets together,limited company of in relief new energy produced 2014 " Tsinghua ace " , " Tsinghua enterprise " wait for model of written characters or mark, tsinghua university ever told this company the court. Guangdong saves senior people court 2 careful maintain tort, sentence your Fosan to get together limited company of in relief new energy compensates for 500 thousand yuan.
November 2018, beijing court rules the website announced Tsinghua university to accuse science and technology of Beijing Tsinghua colleague is finite the first instance judgment of desk of issue of liability company unfair competition, tsinghua colleague science and technology is finite liability company is sentenced to make stop to be used in its company name " Tsinghua " model of written characters.
In addition, because think to collect interpret to amount to international to translate a company without the license, the website in its operation " center of family education of Tsinghua Beijing University " use in the name " Tsinghua " model of written characters forms tort, tsinghua university still tells this company to the court.
Once this matter reports
Netizens spit groove in succession
Beside " bear renown school name oneself " the school
↓ ↓ ↓
Nevertheless, also the netizen expresses doubt
If place has Tsinghua main street
Cannot name a word with place name
How do you look?
