A few days ago, court of the first intermediate people makes Beijing ruling, "Do not grant to accept Gong Niu vitaminic beverage (Thailand) content pharmacy accuses limited company, Yingtesheng the compulsive liquidation of limited company of vitaminic to Gong Niu beverage applies for a limited company. " content applies for Tai Gongniu, Yingtesheng to liquidate Chinese Gong Niu compulsively one case is rejected by court of Beijing specific responsibility, the about market of Chinese function beverage contention between Fang Zhi of the difference outside meaning Chinese red ox and condition, moving toward stage by stage the whole thing comes to light.
According to media coverage, the court of Chinese churchyard started the difference outside Chinese red ox and condition recently the many lawsuit between Fang Zhi, relevant case is entering cognizance order thick and fast. On May 29, 2019, open a court session of court of issue of trade of international of top people court heard the first case since this court is established, namely content partner qualification affirms Chinese red ox and Thailand China Bin, Yingtesheng issue desk. This case made public cognizance to cause close attention, global media had extensive story to this court and this case.
The reporter learns from company of Shenzhen red cattle, at the beginning of 2019, chinese red ox sues health care of medicine of Thailand day silk in Shenzhen court Inc. of the grand in company of industry of food of limited company, Tai Gongniu, China, Shenzhen, the requirement builds the charter sex text version of jointly owned company to what signed 1995 with all possible means, namely " (50 years) agreement " undertake affirming and fulfil obligation. A few days ago, tai Tiansi, Tai Gongniu raises jurisdictional objection, on May 13, 2019, demur is sufferred case court is rejected.
Legal personage expresses to the reporter, on May 30, 2019, chinese red ox and trade mark right of peaceful day silk counterpoise belong to dispute one case, in Beijing senior people court had qualitative card.
A personage of familiar China red ox tells a reporter,
Chinese red ox and difference of the company outside the condition procrastinated for a long time, square multinomial lawsuit or did not enter the difference outside the condition program, or did not win judicatory support, for this, the other side of condition foreign minister holds a board of directors to be reason with Tai Gongniu, of hope and Chinese red ox advocate thing support of the people solves a negotiation. On May 15, 2019, both sides undertook osculatory in Thailand, the ground offerred peaceful square trial 3 reconcile plan, did not get Chinese red ox answer, the control person Yan Bin that Tai Fangxi looks at Chinese red ox can negotiate to Thailand personally. This personage tells a reporter, chinese red ox promises to will expedite a group to go to Thailand in June 2019.
Because this personage is not staff member of interior of Chinese red ox, detailed to both sides program not know the inside story, but this personage judgement, the possibility that both sides reconciles is not large, the difference outside because China is red arrogant condition just is in comprehensive and adverse position in lawsuit, chinese red ox already controlled situation, production to manage the stable, premise that is in pattern of lawsuit of overall dominant position to fall in the round in course of study, short-term reach reconcile agreement, stop lawsuit to give up the possibility of make peace is very little.
Reporter flounder finds the procuratorial Sichuan that liquidates red ox of one case China compulsively Zhang Zhechuan of office of true path attorney's lawyer, rejected the argument that clears one case to undertake interviewing with respect to the court. Zhang Lv division shows,
The applicant is in mention when liquidation requests, qualification of its main body looks from judicatory level, put in controversy, that is to say, without forensic become effective the court decision undertakes affirming, partner status of the applicant fails to be affirmed, the compulsive liquidation that puts forward because of this applicant applies for to won't obtain a court to support.
Liu of substation of Chongqing of office of still general attorney is the member of legal service group of Chinese red ox, Beijing faithful lawyer expresses to the reporter,
"The applicant that Chinese red ox clears one case compulsively liquidates be related with managing deadline to expire to was not organized for, the requirement liquidates Chinese red ox compulsively, its are true the purpose is: Effective control person of Tai Gongniu, after agreement of basis charter sex takes total deduct a percentage from a sum of money, to build the new management main body that can share out bonus, after generation co-worker dies, agreement of abandoning charter sex, initiate many lawsuit, result oneself is in adverse pattern instead, charter sex agreement admits really and fulfill one case however for block, the initiated operation that destroys corresponding lawsuit principal part, the applicant does not have management sex capital fund in Chinese home itself, abode ground is outside the condition, inevitable the social stability of seat of won't red to China ox and economic progress assume any responsibility. Be in as relevant lawsuit accordingly adverse, the applicant abandons national interest completely (pay taxes) , public happiness and benefit (obtain employment) at disregarding, make Chinese red cattle total industrial catenary 420 more than obtain employment person be immersed in extremely urgent unemployment in the risk. This kind clinging act at gain profit and disregarding the lawsuit of public interest completely, get judicatory supports very hard. Get judicatory supports very hard..
Chinese red ox liquidates one case compulsively to be not accepted, will make square litigant structure comes the difference outside Chinese red ox and condition gradually clear, the reporter will continue to hold attention.
