"The flesh of the mussel was clipped by the mouth of the bird, the mussel clipped the mouth of the bird instead with housing again, so, how does the mouth talk them? " read 5 grade Huang Shengkai to raise this question in elementary school of grade of culture of mat river county at present, the problem plum beautiful that faces a nephew has some of not know what to do unexpectedly.
Then, she saw the textbook of nephew carefully, "Be on the west division edition on 5 grade book a text. " be clear about to give nephew the explanation, li Juan also was checked textual. "I use Baidu 100 divisions were checked, this is " plan of the Warring States " an article inside, of nephew study is the colloquial article of this article. Of nephew study is the colloquial article of this article..
Li Juan tells him, " sandpiper mussel conflicting " choose from " Yan Ce of · of plan of the Warring States " , of account is argue person be locked in a stalemate meets Ming Zhaoyan to bring damage to two national capital for the allegorical old practice that Su Dai uses folk to circulate, prevented Zhao Guogong to make swallow state thereby.
To Huang Shengkai's problem, liu Li of teacher of Chinese of elementary school of Chongqing Ba Shu grand say, "Want the critically spirit to the child and distrustful attitude above all, and truer to knowledge spirit nods assist. " Mr. Liu Li grand says, since the child raised question, so we serve as the parent, as the teacher, be about to follow this doubt to find the solution.
"For instance, we can try together with the child, close the mouth, also can sound actually, it is very clear only. It is very clear only..
Besides find the solution through the experiment, still can guide the child, "This is an allegorical story, of the key is the reason that should understand the place in the story is conveyed. Here, the author was to use personification technique for, if fruit is true truer, sandpiper and mussel are a species far from, there won't be a conversation between them. There won't be a conversation between them..
Liu of agency of component of education of foundation of press of southwest Normal University Mr. Jiang Hua expresses when accepting a reporter to interview " the doubt of this student is very good, the story in textbook is from " plan of the Warring States " in those who come out, ancient prose is so of account, we won't change teaching material temporarily. We won't change teaching material temporarily..
Netizen comment
The netizen thinks: Doubt is good, but should oppugn drop to go up, for instance allegorical story, premise is allegorical, this is very clear, going to this oppugning is itself what understanding is allegorical. Like be just like fairy tale, why to change to crystal at 24 o'clock shoe went back, is there scientific basis? Be done not have of course, because this is fairy tale ah
Still the netizen expresses: The child has doubt, this itself is no problem. No matter be the parent or teacher, should guide correctly. The teacher replies also be no problem, the key should pay close attention to the truth in allegorical story. The child of this age, accepting new thing, give right way and concept, make we must want to do.
Also the netizen speaks: Present child was taken harder and harder!
Outspread read: Person teaching company responds to 8 years old of boys to oppugn Yi She 9 days
On June 14, 2019, fuzhou because boy small Feng of 8 years old oppugns Chinese text " Yi shoots 9 days " make mistake went up to heat up search.
The small Feng Di of on 2 grade goes out, before the text is medium one paragraph just is mentioned " the water in Jiang He was done by evaporate " , below one paragraph is mentioned again " his Zuo crosses ninety-nine great river, come to the side of the East China Sea " , "Since insolation, is Na Houyi how of Zuo ? Did the text make mistake? Did the text make mistake??
Small Mr. Feng Xiang and mother put questions, did not get making clear the answer. Subsequently, this problem was gone to by hair of mother Ms. He friend group seeks help, also caused the discussion of broad netizen.
One participates in textbook editorial Mr Lin says, this is a myth, also be new edition teaching material, the whole nation already had many places to reflect this problem, current, he also does not have a law to affirm pair of faults, should submit to to write group, ask more professional expert or writer judgement, next year in September, here text may be edited, can have can understand more, more reasonable, more compact version.
On June 14, @ people teachs response of press small gain to say, the text is referenced " fairy tale is made up newly " wait for a book to adapt. Contact context, " Zuo " the word is used impertinently really. Teaching material is written group studying seriously, can revise appropriately to teaching material, this problem solved the teaching material that issues an edition. Still praised the spirit that Xiaofeng dares to oppugn at the same time.
