"Supervisor " was troubled by incident of business affairs cabin to have newest progress again greatly.
On July 15 morning, in headquarters of Beijing country boat, include a country Wu of undersecretary of department of general manager of department of boat vice-president, product, propaganda, law inside 5 high levels see well-known screenwriter Li Yaling about, at this point before expose to the sun go abroad " boat supervisor " incident is communicated further.
Announce according to Li YalingSmall gainInformation shows, country boat cannot check at present include to become thing woman inside the madman continues to board the plane. Li Yaling is responded to say, cannot agree with a country boat answer, will continue to strive for rights and interests through legal approach.
" China runs a newspaper " reporter for a short while Xiang Guohang respect seeks testimony, boat customer service represents the state, the madman basically is to point to mental disabled, it is to point to a year of above not heal, existence acknowledge, affection and behavior obstacle affect the disabled that daily life and activity participate in, if coming on period inside can undertake applying for to board the plane, want to allow in order to apply for eventuate nevertheless. As to how to check a passenger whether madman, this customer service expresses, this must not conceal the illness of oneself with respect to need passenger. And the Niu Mou in this incident whether madman, this customer service expresses, niu Mou is the country that recuperates because of body reason boat employee, specific with the governmentSmall gainThe reply is accurate.
On July 15 afternoon 14 when 39 minutes, boat delivers the state formallySmall gainUndertake the government is responded to, on July 12, boat CA4107 airliner is in the country take off glide level, because have passenger use mobile phone,another passenger checks and produce issue. There is a passenger to call the police after the plane descends, subsequently 3 passengers and 4 unit staff head for airport public security bureau to cooperate police investigation and intercessory processing. Via checking, passenger of dispute one party is a country the employee that boat recuperates because of body reason, because of,be an individual this illicit piece row, be not a country boat supervisor. "We will strengthen cabin order management further according to relevant provision, ceaseless promotion serves a level, improve a passenger to give an experience. The care since all circles of boat acknowledgment society is long-term mixes the country support. The care since all circles of boat acknowledgment society is long-term mixes the country support..
The lawyer expresses to the reporter, prevent mental person to board the plane to do not have legal basis really, mental person can be taken plane, train, public transportation wait for vehicle. Also to the proper limitation of the madman the law can be depended on, both does not conflict.
Both sides was not reached reconcile
After communication end, li Yaling is released againSmall gainAnnounce with the country the communication result of boat. The information that discloses according to Li Yaling shows, country ship side expresses to its, already made a thorough investigation of relevant circumstance, li Yaling is inSmall gainThe issue that states on is belonged to solid, to the passenger excuse that is affected by this incident. This the female passenger on the airliner calls when glide belong to violate compasses act, but shut a mobile phone after broadcast reminds, according to customary processing means, this matter comes here end. And unusual display of Niu Yuhong, fasten mental disease fit. Lack experience when airline group staff, fail to realize this is mental disease fit, undertake assorted in the property that complains normally according to its however, this caused undesirable effect to other passenger.
As to bring about a passenger to be stayed in 7 hours accept gate of the Ministry of Public Security investigation, because Niu Yuhong calls the police,be later, public security body must produce lawfully alarm, hand-in-hand travel is interrogatory. That day besides when thing passenger, include arrogant oneself and 4 unit staff need to do note, delayed so full 7 hours.
Nevertheless Li Yaling doubt thinks, regard state-operated as airline, although cannot dismiss,have ill stuff, but also cannot allow to often take aerostat by its, disturb from time to time aviation of public order, harm is safe. And cost nearly 5000 yuan fast the price of a ticket as a result of the individual, did not enjoy due the service still is insulted to annoy by ill will, follow-up processing also holds him many time energy, so Xiang Guohang has claim for compensation.
Li Yaling still thinks, beijing flew to the airliner of Chengdu to go up on July 8, niu Yuhong has had similar action, before boat flies this, the country has mastered his to be put in mental obstacle, the likelihood is safe to engine room order and flight cause potential menace, should take certain step.
To this, according to Li YalingSmall gainShow, country ship side expresses to its, the madman that makes Niu Yuhong inside without attributive continues to board the plane, and Niu Yuhong's behavior has not arrived endanger the situation of aviation safety, if have the force action that endangers security really, safe member can undertake checking. Ship side still represents the state, this is the dispute between common passenger, had handled by door of the Ministry of Public Security, reject pair of Li Yaling inside undertake compensatory when thing passenger.
Into special case
Zhao Zhanling of lawyer of place of law of Beijing annals continuous heavy rain expresses to the reporter, according to law, airline also should not board the plane because of allowing mental person and assume liability to pay compensation, because cannot be judged beforehand whether mental person, also cannot let everybody offer a proof before ordering a ticket. Prevent mental person to board the plane to do not have legal basis really, mental person can be taken plane, train, public transportation wait for vehicle. This thing, country boat is put in particular problem really on management, did not have in time for instance effect checks brawl, this belongs to an user to experience a problem, do not form the tort to the passenger.
Zhao Zhanling expresses to the reporter further, to Niu Yuhong, " administration sanctions a method " the 25th regulation: Mental person is in cannot identify or incontrollable him behavior violates act from time to tome, do not grant administrative punishment, instruct guardian to father add guard and cure. The mental patient of intermittence violates act from time to tome normally in spirit, ought to give administration punishment. Whether does time grow too as to the processing of public security, whether to have a problem bad to say, likely also public security undertakes with respect to this matter itself needs to spend more time investigating.
Nevertheless Zhao Zhanling still thinks, the special place of this second incident consists the staff member of boat of country of department of bovine eaves rainbow, and boat is opposite the country Niu Mou's illness is know the inside story.
Civil aviaton expert expresses, basis " regulations of railroad passenger transportation " thirtieth 3, accompany the special fare such as passenger of children, ill incomplete, pregnant woman, blind, deaf person or convict without the adult, agree beforehand via carrier below the condition that accords with carrier regulation only and be in make arrangement when necessary rear grant carry. Contagion patient, madman or healthy circumstance may endanger oneself or affect the passenger of other fare safety, carrier does not grant acceptance of consignment.
Net of official of China International aviation announces " home carries summer condition " the 7.1.4th specific also provision, "Your spirit or body state, include you to suffer the effect of alcohol or medicaments, make you may right you oneself, staff of passenger, unit or belongings create risk or endanger " , boat has the state authority refuses fare of acceptance of consignment.
Chronological table of Zhang Xin of solicitor of office of attorney of Beijing Beijing division is shown, below this kind of circumstance, boat still allows the country to its seize the opportunity and send sick condition to fall to deal with not in time in its the behaviour that causes other fare to stop has fault. Accordingly its ought to according to " civil aviation law " the 132nd regulation, to its because of nonfeasance (know perfectly well Niu Mou to have mental disease to prohibit not in time however its seize the opportunity) and the passenger loss that cause assumes liability to pay compensation.
Piece New Year emphasizes, although according to " mental sanitation standard " regulation, the person that must not confine a madman illegally is free, but carry this one special territory to aviation, also to the proper limitation of the madman the law can be depended on, both does not conflict. Country ship company seizes the opportunity with cannot restricting Niu Mou for of evade responsibility say decline, be have not a leg to stand on.
1F
