Data chart
Curtilage base access breaks up a graph
Huang Zhimei of Wang Ya of our newspaper reporter's reporter
In Chun An countryside some not famous village edge, be not worth 20 square metre together curtilage base hides at the corner, weed of the overgrow on its, see this ground " bedraggled " some year.
It is however so do not use for person place together curtilage base, not long ago became the central issue that two other peoples pay close attention to Wang Jiaji's brother and periphery however --
"I change with sty curtilage base, what right does he have to make over others? What right does he have to make over others??
"The mother says this ground lets me, will you contend for what meaning is there? Will you contend for what meaning is there??
In place of judicatory of big villa of bureau of judicatory of Chun An county, two each other do not let brother, brawl rises. The old gave this ground displacement curtilage the neighbour of base right builds a house, the second made over the access of this ground again curtilage the neighbour of base left makes a garage. This " one female 2 marry " curtilage base, who to belong to after all?
Incident focusing
One ground 2 change, 17.9 square metre
curtilage who does base belong to?
Honest installs a county some village, old Wang Jiasi's brother comes a few years amiable all the time, but recently, two family make the old and second very unpleasant however. Its origin is together small curtilage base.
Original, the mother in the home died last year, left a 17.9 square metre curtilage base. This curtilage base is already obsolete a lot of year, all the time nobody is done. Because everybody is used, the family also had not produced contradiction in this respect, the relation between brother all the time very harmonious. But as in last few years villager standard of living rises, the periphery of this ground is built had bridal chamber.
The area that this other people considers a kitchen when building a house enlarges right a bit, but those who discover oneself curtilage base area is insufficient, found the eldest child, the vegetable plot that wants to use oneself and old undertake displacement. The sty that oneself use before the old thinks this ground is a lot of years is changed, oneself have deal with authority. Make it empty wear with its, be inferior to doing individual affection to change neighbour, agree to have trade with neighbour then.
And this curtilage the neighbour of base left has bit of stricture because of the road before the door, jockey not quite convenient, also thought of this ground. Found the second then, want to buy this next land, transform, widen road surface, convenient car pass in and out, incidentally stationary point position comes out, the parking space that serves as oneself is used. The second remembers the mother is in make old premise pass, this ground says give him, so he has this land of course authority is done advocate, although know the old exchanged this land others before, return what signed use with left neighbour to make over an agreement.
Together promise gave two families, how can be this divided? For brother of this matter Home Laowang two be troubled by so that cannot leave hand in, return photograph of foot of fist of within an inch of to.
Later, remove issue to solve this as soon as possible, second of Home Wang old one everybody child the person will to place of big villa judicatory ask to undertake intercessory. The number that involves because of the case is more, judicatory place instantly put together of along with town is treated do, the counsel that be stationed in a village, village two appoint established combination to reconcile a panel, begin the mediate of this second dispute quickly.
Peacemaker go into battle
Stick to one's argument each other is uncompromising provoke dispute
That day, adjustment group besides looked for the old and second, still old 3 and old 4 also called together intercessory spot, confront each other on the spot, manage clear case concerns. Although adjustment group made a lot of preparation, but feasibility condition did not imagine medium so simple, what mediate and did not anticipate is successful.
"I exchange this land with sty, you look, evidence is in this! " the agreement that the ground changes with neighbour before the old took out a lot of years immediately, prove this ground belongs to him. The land is exchanged on the agreement in those days that other people also was gone to please the spot, but he this year already nonagenarian, also fail to give out in the spot strong testimony.
The second sees this agreement, discovered incorrect interest immediately. "Changing what write on ground agreement is father's name, do not have your name at all, if at that time is change with you, why to keep your name, keep father's name however? " the second is refuted, "Mother these year be my provide for, this ground behoove is me, also had said to give me this ground before besides mother, I here money of the other side had closed, you contend for this ground with me even, what meaning be? What meaning be??
Both sides meets, consider oneself made a noise oneself to rise, the wife of the old still cried a few degrees, intercessory occasion is immersed in a disorder.
Consider each mood is very excited, and stick to one's argument, adjustment group thinks to solve a problem or should part charge for the making of sth. is made. Then, adjustment group decides to adopt back-to-back means to undertake intercessory, the think of a way that allows old second is OK expression of more intuitionistic and comprehensive ground comes out, solve a problem straight from the shoulder thereby.
Conversion of back back of a chair thinks obtain forgive
Adjustment group from law feeling to old home two respects undertook an analysis. In the light of the agreement exchanging the land that old boss gives, the lawyer Wang Fang of adjustment group informs him: "The basis has book card, do not have method to prove this curtilage base belongs to you namely, you also saw the case of testimony of a witness, it is not clear that he himself also is conveyed. When besides handles land card in those days, this curtilage base also is to register the under one's name in your father, come ten this years the right that you did not hold yourself, say this however now curtilage base belongs to you, apparent and other a few frat have veiled word. Apparent and other a few frat have veiled word..
Explain legal principle, king lawyer plays emotional card to the old again, "Your brother concerns originally harmonious, be troubled by together for this now so deadlocked, worth while? Is the family mixed and unlike what is beautiful beauty strong? Is the family mixed and unlike what is beautiful beauty strong??
With the old after a confide in sb, adjustment group changes the thought that goes making second home to the job again. King lawyer Xiao Zhi in order to manage, move with affection.
The second puts forward, now this curtilage base access had been made over, still signed make over an agreement, money also was received, when making over also consult old 3 and old the opinion of 4, they express to agree to make over. "The old jumps out to say this ground is him now, is this intended embarrassing I? " the second was full of complaint to the old, "Retreat 10 thousand paces to tell, calculate this ground to have the share of the old, neighbour and I am signed when making over an agreement, not be clear about to there is issue inside this, he does not have responsibility, we take out the share that belongs to the old namely at most money comes, but let me cancel to make over an agreement, be impossible! Be impossible!!
See this kind of response of the second, king lawyer began to have a way to his general: Have this only curtilage the attributive controversy of base is solved thoroughly, the cession of use just can not have trouble back at home, if one flavour solid is held oneself see, contradiction is impossible to solve, hope so everybody concede one pace, remove one condition unrestrained and far -ranging.
Adjustment group still is mediated to be being participated in together but to curtilage base is attributive what did not advocate is old 3 old 4 dozens had emotional card, let them help together persuade old second, full brother does peacemaker in two worlds, old second looks at the face of family, also can quieter ground discusses, after all the family is harmonious it is the happiest thing.
After this, it is under mediate of neat go to the fields of adjustment group multibarrel, 4 brother reach unanimous opinion eventually.
Fall ahead of schedule in what the sister expresses clearly to abandon, this curtilage the bequest that base regards a mother as, according to " inheritance act of People's Republic of China " thirteenth " same and ordinal heir accedes the portion of bequest, general ought to equal " concerned regulation, curtilage 4 brother break up the access of base on average, old 3 and old 4 transfer share the second of one's own accord, the portion proper motion of the old deals with, come so, besides let the old and second remove barrier, had been attributed to again, also the requirement that just satisfied two or so neighbour to build Fang Xiulu severally, can saying is with one action is gotten more.
From this, one origin curtilage the brotherly dispute that base causes drew satisfactory full stop so, the family is new open the new page that kisses affection with the United States.
Peacemaker has a word to say
Mediation needs to reveal affection glamour
This case is successive dispute when be broken up by bequest and cause, acceding is to allocate reasonably originally already died parental belongings, but the touchstone that because a variety of reasons became test however,kisses affection and morality. In this case, two people of old second brother are former feeling is harmonious, however for such together small curtilage photograph of foot of fist of base within an inch of to. Face this kind of issue, adjuster should protect the legitimate rights and interests of party from legal angle not just, more want from reason angle balance, make mediation can remove barrier between brother afterwards, be deeply attached to each other, revealed people to mediate case bear thing thereby, close emotive is special glamour. In the meantime, when mediation, invite professional lawyer to be participated in together, can offer legal opinion for party better, let people mediate working reason law to have both.
