Of communal bathroom store is installation of content ark area photographed reasonable like the head

To enhance security, people can be accepted already generally in public installation monitoring, but of corridor, communal to the dormitory bathroom store for the content ark area semi-overt place that privacy divulges a risk, whether should install monitoring to often arouse controversy easily.

Recently, have a tourist in Yang Shuo some drifts of scene area female bathroom store when change clothes of content ark area, personnel of the clean that be protected informs this area to be photographed of 3 like the head, its think him privacy is encroached, scene division says is for guard against theft. For a short while this news mounts hot search, photograph to installation reasonable like the head opinions vary.

Privacy bodyguard team is initiated to this voting, data shows, nearly 6 think to be in into the netizen of communal bathroom store installation of content ark area is photographed unreasonable like the head, nearly 9 into netizen hope further legislative control is photographed like the head. The expert points out, be aimed at at present can deny in the bathroom store content ark area installs monitoring and do not have specific provision, but in actual condition, should the balance that public safety and privacy protect give attention to two or morethings.

Scene area bathroom store monitoring of outfit of content ark area is oppugned to violate privacy

On July 22, according to media coverage, the tourist king lady of Beijing and friend are after area of scene of float of river of neck of dragon of Xingping of Guangxi in relief new moon is seaborne, come to change clothes of female bathroom shower. Protect clean personnel to remind her right now, there are 3 to photograph inside the bathroom like the head, 2 to store content ark area, 1 to the entrance between shower, OK and clear see the inside case between shower.

Be in directly as a result of the metropolis after shower of a lot of tourists store change clothes before content ark, this daughter tourist thinks, scene area is photographed in the installation inside female bathroom be suspected of violating privacy like the head, and the spot also did not make clear clew.

Subsequently, 16 attendant female tourists find scene division chief thought fors the time being, the requirement is demolished photograph like the head, delete video, undertake compensatory according to standard of 5 times entrance ticket.

But scene area is oral apology only, did not agree to compensate for a requirement. Scene division chief thinks, in store installation of content ark area is photographed resembling a head is for guard against theft, from tourist belongings safety angle considers, photograph cannot demolish like the head.

Subsequently, female tourists choose to call the police processing. The police station that promote level ground expresses " although original intention is guard against theft, but the privacy that cannot violate a tourist " , and label of female bathroom of this scene area is unidentified, store content ark area contains monitoring but without clew, put in neglectful problem. Through police station mediation, 10 when had not left female tourists won 8400 yuan of compensation in all.

This news, obtained on small gain eighty-seven million six hundred and forty-seven thousand read a quantity, netizens express an opinion in succession. Can see from inside netizen comment, everybody arrives to can be being patted of shower area photograph resembling a head is put an end to stoutly, but be in to installation store of content ark area photograph opinion resembling a head differ.

The netizen thinks, store content ark area is not the place that change clothes originally, can go changing between shower, so sensitivity is done not have so strong. Also a lot of netizens think " be in commonly store content cabinet department changes clothes, install here (photograph like the head) not be joking " .

To afore-mentioned different opinions, netizen @ chirp and 3 fish express " difference of north and south, do not beg self-identity, but esteem " .

Nearly 6 think into the netizen store monitoring of outfit of content ark area is unreasonable

In communal bathroom store is installation of content ark area photographed like the head after all reasonable?

To this, south combination of privacy bodyguard team group of battle of station of NDX lab heat is initiated voting, up to on July 26 10 when, in participating in 2240 voting netizens, 56.9% think to be in of communal bathroom store installation of content ark area is photographed unreasonable like the head, "Change clothes no-go " ; The rest thinks 43.1% times reasonable, express " can help catch thief " .

Supportive outfit photographs the netizen that resembles a head to think, if it were not for is patted secretly and be the circumstance that has hinted clearly only, in communal bathroom store installation of content ark area is photographed resembling a head is normal. And in scene area this kind of stream of people estimates very great place, it is OK like the head that installation is photographed help guard against theft.

Antagonistic netizen thinks, habit of a lot of people is in store content ark area changes clothes, and of general and communal bathroom store content ark metropolis lock, need not fear the thing will be missing, still be privacy the possibility that is encroached is a few larger. The netizen expresses, "Whether to change clothes here no matter, but always feel to be installed here photograph gutty like the head sacrifice too much for small probability incident the suspicion of privacy... " .

According to heat the data of station stand in line shows, the netizen that has 28.6% ever had been encountered in communal bathroom store installation of content ark area photographs the circumstance that resembles a head, however nearly 7 mention those who have apparent designation into the netizen not much, "Often be to have photograph like the head, but without clew. But without clew..

In addition, many netizens early childhood, dormitory corridor, inside the room of beauty parlour, massage house, and the similar semi-overt place such as infantile natatorium, also should not install photograph like the head.

Supervisory equipment setting ought to be abided by " least, enough with " principle

The Ministry of Public Security drafted in November 2016 " regulation of system of information of image of communal and safe video (ask for an opinion to stalk of grain) " in allude, the likelihood such as hotel guest room, dormitory and communal bathroom, bathhouse, toilet divulges the place of other privacy, place, prohibit installing video image to gather facility.

From inside asking for an opinion to stalk of grain, limit hard it seems that store whether does content ark area belong to afore-mentioned categories. And the habit according to different place, some person habits change clothes in shower occasional bathhouse, also the habit is in somebody store change clothes before content ark.

The lawyer tells privacy bodyguard group, the regulation of this article belongs to generality to list, as long as circumstance and the spatial property that allude are similar, also can include inside. For instance dormitory is not close space of pure individual illicit, have certain semi-overt sex, with communal bathroom store quality of content ark area is same, so it belongs to the condition that article sets.

Office of Zhejiang cultivate fourth attorney combines father hemp plan to also express, if somebody is to be in store if changing clothes before content ark, be equal here at bathhouse. Because stipulated bathhouse prohibits installing in article,photograph like the head, be in so store before content ark not OK also.

Although half-and-half makes public a place to install monitoring to whether encroach what privacy counterpoises,be limitted and do not have final conclusion, but law of Chinese Internet association is versed in appoint Hu Gang ever told deputy secretary-general privacy bodyguard group, supervisory equipment setting ought to be abided by " least, enough with " principle, accomplish apparently outstanding with inform adequately, slam the door " monitor adores " or " monitoring is all-purpose " wrong viewpoint, maintain maintain the proper balance between public safety and individual privacy, privacy of protective citizen legal counterpoises.

In addition, in the semi-overt place such as dormitory corridor installation photographs the question that resembles a head to ever also had caused a lot of controversy. Before this, privacy bodyguard team ever had reported Henan learns to install monitoring in schoolgirl dormitory corridor only in some, be demolished by police finally. Additional, learn in the many colleges such as institute of dancing of Liaoning university, peaceful wave university, Nanchang university, Beijing and part, because dormitory corridor installs monitoring,ever caused controversy and see Zhu Baoduan.

And, in recent years, pinhole is photographed send incident frequency hair secretly like the head, try the garment, bank of hotel room, self-help, women's lavatory is become pat incident to send the ground high secretly. Pat incident to bring great mind harm to the victim secretly, the public also is anxious very to this problem.

In poll, the netizen that is as high as 92.9% holds with further legislative control to photograph like the head. Privacy bodyguard team understands from website of the State Council, general office of the State Council was released in May this year " the announcement that about the State Council of print and distribute legislative 2019 job plans " , " regulation of system of information of image of communal and safe video " already was included among them.

Civil / south Li Huiqi of researcher of research center of individual information protection