On March 8, talk about doorway of urban tumour hospital. New capital signs up for reporter Fu Ziyang to photograph
The motion picture that showed last year " I am not medical god " , will buy on sb's behalf Indian copy pharmacy is cancer patient " add life " affection law predicament, took public opinion line of vision. Observe reality instead, this kind of predicament exists as before, but obtain with happy event of brave of film intermediate range " exemption from prosecution " what ending differs is, actual edition " Liu Yong " people the destiny is some more uncertainty.
On March 19, problem of new capital newspaper is " talk about a city " false medicine " Luo Sheng door: It is medicine incorrect disease, be still requite kindness with enmity? " report, presented a few people by " false medicine " (Indian copy pharmacy " card rich replaces the Buddhist nun " ) the lot that drives destiny eddy.
According to the report, on Feburary 25, 2019, shandong defends inspect a name to be " talk about a city: Chairman doctor opens false medicine actually " program, "Exposure " talk about Chen Zongxiang of doctor of director of urban tumour hospital to be cancer patient Wang Da father was recommended " card rich replaces the Buddhist nun " treat a disease, after the patient dies, blueness of jade of family member king because dissatisfaction treats the effect and hospital,produce dispute be related. Once this matter explodes piece, cause a mighty uproar on the net.
The follow-up of incident is: After the thing ferments, doctor Chen Zongxiang first by hospital punish, urban Wei Jian chats after appoint time-out hold course of study 1 year, and the line segment on the Jinan that can get this medicaments is true (alias) , the king Qing Weijun that gives Wang Yuqing resell of medicaments of provide for oneself by punishment arrest. This lets a few party be pounded, place still has patient at death's door to because this is forced,stop drug however; At first dimension authority accuses seeking a central issue is " medicine is incorrect disease " Wang Yuqing, became " doctor good intention recommends new drug, be sufferred from by disease however the family member is bitten instead " the requite kindness with enmity in the story person, suffer a phone for long abuse.
Advance party sloughy, be with " false medicine " concomitant affection law dispute
This ending, it is sigh letting a person really: The Wang Yuqing as family member of the person that die innocently at going uncover that " false medicine " current chain, she begins not to know " false medicine " it is copy pharmacy, thinking is " composition is a holiday " bad medicine, choose to accuse and be informed against so, just consider report " medicine is incorrect disease " , the first piece when overturned a domino however; Be inspected the Chen Zongxiang of doctor of tumor emperor hand, conscience, because recommend " false medicine " meet with punish, but from with all possible means the view looks, he resembles is to stem from the good intention that helps a person, the purpose that and rather than seeks profit from which; Duan Zhen, Wang Qingwei it is cancer patient family member, contract cancer because of the family member and bring into contact with " card rich replaces the Buddhist nun " , they " false medicine " give Wang Yuqing, its purpose basically also is " help " and rather than earns a large sum of, because be suspected of,sell false drug crime finally to meet with however punishment arrest.
So, someone says this is black edition " I am not medical god " , someone says this is actual edition " farmer and snake " . But no matter be which kinds, not be the wind up of everyone is happy: The person such as Chen Zongxiang, Duan Zhen, Wang Qingwei, although was acted " false medicine " the important role on current chain, but a pressing need that saw patient of a lot of cancer; What Wang Yuqing indicates is not " false medicine " however " medicine is incorrect disease " , crooked building of trend of uncontrollable however incident and public opinion, so that she also feels to subdue -- " we just are victims, my father had false medicine to die, we need dimension power, why people scolds me even? " ... but they are victims actually.
To public opinion character, to here the face is with the judge of blame, also need not float morality changes: Father opened the Wang Yuqing that Chen Zongxiang gives a body to contract cystic cancer and lung cancer " card rich replaces the Buddhist nun " , apply to disease after all treat, those who need medical level grind sentence; Duan Zhen, Wang Qingwei it is edition talking about a city " medical god " , but its action is faced with law really possibly to examine; The king jade that thought fors the time being is green, "Making crooked move " ground nip off " false medicine " current chain while, also snuff partial patient hope, but undesigned.
Advance them " be defeated in all with all possible means " sloughy, be with copy pharmacy type " false medicine " concomitant affection law dispute. "Card rich replaces the Buddhist nun " the wide chart anticarcinogen that is dot of many kinds of target, the target that be called to the middle of medicine " a balm for treating headaches " , in clinical trial get used to disease to include cancer of lung cancer of cellule of caruncle of cancer of the liver, parenchyma, blame, prostate cancer, breast cancer, ovarian cancer, bowel to wait, it still follows AZD9291 (Ao Xi replaces the Buddhist nun) be called to help by a lot of lung cancer patients medicine of two great minds (reason Chen Zongxiang is recommended to have the Wang Yuqing's father of lung cancer " card rich replaces the Buddhist nun " may not is to open medicine in disorder) ; According to popular science, the target of cystic cancer to medicine basically be sheet fights Atezhu (Atezolizumab) . These are not bad medicine, it is so called however " false medicine " , although effective, but prohibit to have legal place.
If not be so called " false medicine " current still be in black region, chen Zongxiang and the issue of doctors and patients with king blue jade, completely OK the dispute of doctors and patients of park convention is solved below harmonious processing mechanism, and need not be troubled by execute the law the condition that the branch intervenes; Duan Zhen, Wang Qingwei also need not by embroil, wang Yuqing can be avoided discuss unfavorable situation at the area that is flooded by moral saliva -- be in yesterday, " China business signs up for " still reported " 29 years old ' medical god ' be suspected of selling the liver that treat second ' false medicine ' by punishment arrest: Want to look for the patient that buy drug to write letter begging for leniency for oneself " , this " medical god " also be to get blame accordingly.
On March 8, after incident ferments, the dentistry clinic of Home Wang Yuqing is exposed to the sun to be suspected of illegal practise medicine, their the same night picks a brand. New capital signs up for reporter Fu Ziyang to photograph
Anticarcinogen depreciates protect get effective more quickly for the mechanism, this kind " affection law dispute " less
Look from public feelings, the public hopes legal layer faces Chen Zongxiang and those generally " medical god " people " give the wrongdoer a way out " , procuratorate of city of river of Yuan of the Hunan after be being caught like Liu Yong requested to recall to the court in January 2015 sue that kind, before also resembling before long two Chongqing edition " medical god " be sentenced in first instance probation, the 5th court of justice of Chongqing town 2 careful are avoided to 2 people punish at criminal in that way. Edition of Chongqing of no less than " medical god " case undertake judge Lu Junlian says, "Juridical result ought to seek substantial justice of law actively, this applies freedom to reduce quantity advantageous position with respect to need judge, inside the range that can forecast, make the reasonable, lawful, judgment accord with social ethics to the case. Make the reasonable, lawful, judgment accord with social ethics to the case..
In fact, talk about a city in this case, it is to talk about a city no matter before public security bureau of Dong Changfu area is fermenting with " the clue is remarkable and slight " for, do not grant put on record, or by arrest Wang Qingwei of 11 days by await trial of be bailed out, released trifling judicatory kindness.
Compared with case juridic is light from wide, more important the more primary also train of thought that solve a problem still depends on -- include through be opposite " copy pharmacy " of the series policy that superintends inside adjust, will carry on those incurable disease patients borrow " copy pharmacy " of add life clear appeal to beg.
In this respect, country already frequency is close release system kindness: Rose in April 2018, the State Council is clear, the decision carries out 0 custom duty to importing anticarcinogen and encourage innovation medicine import, accelerate already appeared on the market outside the condition new drug is examined and approve, fulfil anticarcinogen to depreciate medicine of shortage of measure, aggrandizement supplies safeguard. Will rise on May 1, entrance anticarcinogen 0 custom duty already " start " . July, premier Li Kejiang with respect to the film " I am not medical god " cause heat to discuss make written instructions, the requirement is accelerated about the branch fulfil anticarcinogen to depreciate protect for waiting for relevant measure, special written instructions wants " urgent masses place is urgent " , drive these arrange to bring to bear on to fall quickly to real point. Jiao Gong of director of bureau of national medicine inspect also expresses that month, will encouraging while medicines and chemical reagents innovates, incentive medicines and chemical reagents is modelled on.
These " assorted fist " hit, it is undoubtedly solved a lot of cancer patients from fountainhead " be short of medicine " predicament, bring to copy pharmacy " affection law dispute " had take a drastic measure to deal with a situation. Next, also hope these politics of be apt to can get effective more quickly, let cancer patient can put the hope in anticarcinogen to depreciate protect go up for the mechanism, is not to send look at each district " medical god " .
Say so, to talking about a city " false medicine " Luo Sheng door, the most important is to face up to already some " affection law dispute " , and rather than is worn urgently brandish moral big stick-means of intimidation. Depreciate when anticarcinogen protect the Puhui that offers a mechanism effect is more extensive, more intense, adhere to in " medical god " the situation of reason be in a dilemma on the case, just disappear quickly.
□ She Zongming (media person)
Edit Chen Jing to proofread Liu Jun
