Beijing reduces exposure of book of death sentence of cure Sun Wenbin: An account in one's own word

On April 3 morning, the execution of make known to lower levels of top magic art commands comply with, 3 quadrangle are opposite Beijing " civil aviaton hospital fights cure proposal " convict Sun Wenbin is executed.

On December 24, 2019, because an examine doctor Yang Wen to the mother is malcontent, he is in a hospital rescue of emergency call division is indoor take the advantage of its unprepared, hold dagger to relapse of cut poplar article cervical, send its to disable via rescue death.

On January 16, 2020, 3 quadrangle first instance is opposite Beijing Sun Wenbin sentences capital punishment, privative politics right is lifelong. After adjudging, sun Wenbin mentions appeal, beijing tall courtyard rejects appeal, maintain original judgement.

Recently, net of Chinese judge copy clerk published first instance report of Sun Wenbin. Judgment shows, case hair before a week, sun Wenbin ever looked for Doctor Yang to had said, its mother cured row, if treat worse more, the life of Doctor Yang puts aside this, his life also puts aside this.

When case hair, sun Wenbin protects personnel before numerous patient and family member and cure, hold dagger to relapse of cut poplar article cervical, his an account in one's own words is afraid that one knife is plunged into not dead, took a knife to delimit again Yang Wen neck a few, yang Wen shed paralysis of a lot of blood to fall on the ground, he looks at Yang Wen to enrage, crouch again, took a knife to prick two knives according to her neck.

Attendant nurse says, sun Wenbin still cries greatly: "Be aimed at her only, she treats bad word, let her one life touchs one order " . Before case hair, the dialog of Doctor Yang and Sun Wenbin is very smooth, did not hear Doctor Yang to had said to provoke Sun Wenbin's word.

Sun Wenbin, male, 55 years old (was born on December 23, 1964) , birthplace Beijing, the Han nationality, culture of junior high school, without course of study, area of rising sun of Beijing of census register seat, heibei of dwelling place of of short duration saves developing zone of outskirt of swallow of 3 rivers city. Because be suspected of making intended homicide was detained on December 24, 2019, be detained by criminal with day, of the same age will be arrested on December 27; Show detain to be in Beijing the first detention house.

Indictment of the 3rd branch department accuses Beijing procuratorate: Sun Wenbin because its mother Sun Mou 1 (95 years old) cannot take food normally in the home, send its mother to the × × hospital that is located in area of Beijing rising sun at passing car of 999 emergency treatment together with family on December 4, 2019. During go to a doctor of family of this hospital emergency call, sun Wenbin does not cooperate and reject a hospital to give examination and treatment to its mother according to the illness for many times, be opposite an examine doctor Yang Mou 1 (female, die 51 years old year) feel discontented, prepare dagger then and carry, the intent carries out killing behavior.

Sun Wenbin on December 24, 2019 6 when make, in rescue of division of this hospital emergency call indoor, take the advantage of the Yang Mou that is on duty 1 unprepared, hold dagger to relapse cut Yang Mou 1 cervical, send its to disable via rescue death. Classics appraisal, yang Mou 1 accord with the acute that be used by other implement cut neck ministry for many times repeatedly, injury and neck marrow, bilateral the neck is moved, vein and nerve, muscle, thyroid, tracheal, esophagus, the marrow that extend a neck is traverse and amalgamative shock of traumatic and exsanguine sex dies.

After Sun Wenbin commits the crime, public security mechanism seizes his in the spot.

Public prosecution mechanism thinks, sun Wenbin strips illegally intentionally other life, cause person death, ought to investigate criminal duty with intended homicide.

The fact that Sun Wenbin accuses to its commit intended homicide to public prosecution mechanism and accusation not dissent, but to the case origin, problem demur that waits to be concerned with the fact to case course.

The apologetic opinion of Sun Wenbin paraclete is: The first, after Sun Wenbin commits the crime 3 minutes, dial namely 110 call the police phone, and on record sends the spot to await, after bringing to justice, admit to criminality, accord with surrender relevant provision. The 2nd, what Sun Wenbin investigates level is interrogatory note show its admit his guilt admit punish, and department first offence. The 3rd, sun Wenbin and its mother love are deep, the illness relapses during its mother be in hospital and Sun Wenbin thinks the hospital did not ask to have diagnosis and treatment by its, above reason causes Sun Wenbin mood to fluctuate, lose reason to carry out experience record behavior then, request court is punished lightly to its.

Find out via cognizance: Mother Sun Mou of Sun Wenbin 1 (95 years old) because contract the severe disease such as dead sequela of stalk of heart disease, head in November 2019 hospitalization, meantime, hospital ever make known to lower levels is sick into death get a severe disease advice note. On December 4, sun Wenbin and its relative because Sun Mou 1 cannot take food normally in the home, through car of 999 emergency treatment Sun Mou 1 send to the × × hospital that is located in area of Beijing rising sun, make a diagnosis and give treatment of classics emergency call did not see improve, satisfy observation leaving a courtyard. Sun Mou of Sun Wenbin flatter oneself the illness of 1 did not improve with doctor Yang Mou 1 (female, die 51 years old year) make a diagnosis and give treatment concerns an examine, because of this pair of Yang Mou 1 have resentment, reject this courtyard for many times to Sun Mou the examination of 1 is mixed cure, in still returning home of dwelling place of of short duration, take sharp knife and carry, for many times threaten should retaliate Yang Mou 1.

On December 24 6 when make, yang Mou 1 in room of rescue of division of hospital emergency call indrawn Sun Wenbin introduces Sun Mou when the illness of 1, sun Wenbin pulls out suddenly dagger, protect personnel before numerous patient and family member and cure, relapse cut Yang Mou 1 cervical, send Yang Mou 1 fall down, other block the way is disregarded again after, be opposite again Yang Mou 1 undertake plunging into thorn, send Yang Mou 1 by acute implement cut neck ministry for many times repeatedly, injury and neck marrow, bilateral the neck is moved, vein and nerve, muscle, thyroid, tracheal, esophagus, the marrow that extend a neck is traverse and amalgamative shock of traumatic and exsanguine sex dies. A criminal give himself up to the police calls the police after Sun Wenbin commits the crime, be seized by public security mechanism, commit the crime with tool dagger by on the spot capture.

Afore-mentioned facts have quote of careful of classics front courtyard, qualitative card, the following evidence after this academy examine and verify affirms gives confirm:

The kinescope of monitoring of room of rescue of division of hospital emergency call that police attune takes and job show a proof: On December 24, 2019 6 when make 3 minutes, sun Wenbin takes out dagger from the waist, left hand holds a knife, the right hand presses Yang Mou 1 head begins violent, cut repeatedly, delimit Yang Mou 1 cervical, time is as long as 24 seconds; A male nurse tries to pull open Sun Wenbin not if really; Yang Mou 1 fall down pedal leg struggles, double leg unbend faces upward to fall down not to have any movements again after a few seconds; A male security personnel tries to pull open Sun Wenbin not if really; Sun Wenbin is vociferant to spot everybody, left hand holds knife brandish. 6 when make 4 minutes, sun Wenbin holds knife Fu body to face Yang Mou 1, 1 have Yang Mou reflex of pedal leg nerve, right now Bin of department grandson article is opposite again Yang Mou 1 undertake filling knife; Sun Wenbin leaves Yang Mou again 1 labour, vociferant to the everybody such as spot security personnel, left hand holds knife brandish, return sickbed around. 6 when make 5 minutes, sun Wenbin dials a mobile telephone. 6 when make 6 minutes, yang Mou of the rescue before cure protects personnel to go up 1. 6 when make 23 minutes, the policeman arrives at the spot to seize Sun Wenbin. Public security mechanism points out monitoring time is slower than Beijing time 10 seconds.

Bai Mou proves nurse of division of emergency call of × × hospital: On December 24, 2019 4 when make, its and Yang Mou 1 doctor is on duty in room of rescue of emergency call of × × hospital, a man comes in say his mother breath is hurried, yang Mou 1 say to wait a little while to see patient Sun Mou 1, she looks for doctor of relevant specialized subject first to Sun Mou 1 have consultation, next the man leaves. Hind Yang Mou 1 Sun Mou is headed for again after calling specialized subject doctor consultation the bed of 1 undertakes examining, look for cure to protect personnel general Sun Mou the bed of 1 was increased. 5 when make 40 minutes, the man goes again, to Yang Mou 1 inquiry why didn't its mother patient's condition improve, still ask to examine a gramophone record, yang Mou 1 Sun Mou the film of 1 looks to this man, weigh a patient for this man explanation the age is older now, have disease of a lot of foundations, and the matter with pressing breath. Right now, its see the man will put the knife in Yang Mou of 1 on the right side of neck place, its go out call a person, its hear the man inside house to cry: "You go calling the police. " its look for a person to call the police rapidly, see 1 neck is in Yang Mou to risking blood, in rescue when its still hear a man crying " one life touchs one order " the word of and so on.

Ma Mou of nurse of division of emergency call of × × hospital proves: On December 24, 2019 4 when make, yang Mou 1 doctor carry on, a man comes over to ask Yang Mou the illness of 1 his mother, yang Mou 1 say the patient has cerebral block, pneumonic, block, the medicine that the man says to be defeated now accentuated the patient's circumstance, let a doctor look, yang Mou 1 say to wait a little while to go a bit. 4 when 30 minutes or so, yang Mou 1 go ward examines patient case, its went together accordingly, yang Mou 1 let its shake the head of a bed of 8 beds patient rise, after this returns a nurse to stand together. 4 when 45 minutes or so, this man comes again nurse station looks for Yang Mou 1, yang Mou 1 say the bed the patient shakes now rose, the circumstance of asthma should can have alleviate, does the man ask Yang Mou 1 his mother can cure, yang Mou the 1 word that if come home,says, the effect that did not treat in the hospital for certain is good. 5 when make 30 minutes, this man looks for Yang Mou again the 1 mother that asks him is treated bad, poplar this man of some 1 answer is unwarrantable can cure. Its hear Yang Mou later 1 " ah " , its hurry to a man behind hold him in arms and in the future was dragged, its just see there is a knife in his hand, yang Mou has a lot of blood on the neck of 1. This man cries aloud " be aimed at her only, she treats bad word, let her one life touchs one order " . Yang Mou the 1 dialog with this man is very smooth, its did not hear Yang Mou the 1 word that has said to upset this man.

Yang Mou of doctor of family of emergency call of × × hospital 4 prooves: On December 4, 2019, one man accompanies his mother Sun Mou 1 be admitted to hospital cure, an examine doctor at that time it is Yang Mou 1. When be admitted to hospital, this man asks to make some of nutrition juice only, at that time Sun Mou 1 unconsciousness, cannot take food, yang Mou 1 left to wake to the patient the head is static the Ao Meila Zun with protective stomach, but because old person age is too old, and the family member does not let make an inspection, so old person illness has disappeared to turn. This man thinks the hospital uses drug later undeserved, once the old person appears asthma, afflictive, illness accentuation circumstance, this man searchs be on duty the doctor is academic, he has said " your hospital is no good, the disease that how treats " the word of and so on, still threaten cure protects personnel to say: "If treat the disease of bad mother, not was over with you. " this man is aimed at Yang Mou because,the reason that 1 doctor carries out force is Yang Mou an examine doctor that 1 doctor is his mother, he thinks responsibility is from head examine doctor begins, but division of hospital emergency call does not have special doctor in charge of a case to every patient, who is on duty who is responsible. To Sun Mou the illness of 1, doctors were done to her fight infection processing, support of perfect and relevant examination, nutrition and next ureter. The doctor does cure to be able to be asked for so that the family member agrees every time, and it is the decision that diagnoses tegether by the group, but disease of old person foundation is too much, the illness relapses, the doctors that include its inside so had said with the family member the old person has life risk.

Zhou Mou of vice director of division of emergency call of × × hospital 1 proof: During cure, because of Sun Mou 1 family member does not cooperate a hospital to Sun Mou 1 examination reachs cure, ever suggested they turn so courtyard cure, but they reject to turn courtyard. Sun Wenbin the result that to Yang Mou 1 doctor gives him maternal treatment is dissatisfactory, he thinks Yang Mou 1 in him the mother comes a hospital the first day when, wake to what his mother is defeated the head is static with Ao Meila Zun these two kinds of medicaments cause Sun Mou 1 illness is aggravating. For this, sun Wenbin often rejects cure to protect personnel to Sun Mou the behavior of normal medical treatment of 1, and often say × × hospital Sun Mou 1 be treated bad. After be admitted to hospital, sun Wenbin denies its mother Sun Mou all the time 1 contract a disease, do not admit its mother is anile, think Sun Mou 1 healthy, without any diseases.

The attestation of Peng Mou of vice director of division of emergency call of × × hospital proves: On December 16, 2019, its ever gave Sun Mou 1 had done bout to check, she has function of purulent poisonous disease, kidney damage of not complete, cardiac muscle, hidebound, head straightens dead to wait for a disease. Because patient age is exorbitant, and contract afore-mentioned diseases, so its tell a family member, the patient dies likely, the family member should do good psychology to prepare. Sun Wenbin thinks, the body is very good before the old lady comes to a hospital, inform he gets a severe disease now, he cannot be accepted. Sun Wenbin's elder brother expresses, an ancient name for the planet Jupiter of understandable old lady counts big, disease to die more, possibly, but he feels Sun Mou 1 did not improve in the illness after the hospital is treated, feel the doctor's cure has a problem. Its ever said to explanation of patient family member, if the family member thinks cure has a problem, can walk along judicatory program seek redress, perhaps turn to better hospital treatment, after the family member listens, express not to turn courtyard.

3 elder sister of Sun Wenbin express: Before December 4, 2019, its mother as a child village hospital (Beijing × × combines a hospital) after leaving hospital, live in all the time secondly elder brother grandson some 3 are medium. On December 4 in the morning, sun Wenbin calls to its say, should receive the mother go he there live, its went. Sun Wenbin sends the mother to × × hospital first through calling an ambulance, in division of this courtyard emergency call the doctor of surname poplar comes round to enquire a circumstance, its and Sun Wenbin state to its the mother is defeated by bag nutrition fluid to leave hospital. When be defeated by fluid to prepare to go out, discover maternal head slouch, do not regain consciousness to also do not talk, return room of emergency call rescue, ask how the doctor returns a responsibility. Doctor Yang says, its mother is not sober, ask its the mother surnames what to call not to reply, was defeated to its mother so bag wake the head is static. Its and Sun Wenbin feel, be defeated namely wake the head is static cerebral issue. Later, its mother continues hospitalization, the result treats a disease more more. Its and Sun Wenbin ask Doctor Yang how this is treated, still can have a meal previously, now not only the meal did not have, unconscious still. Doctor Yang says, its mother age is old, went with respect to this to age. Its and Sun Wenbin are very angry, make a noise with her rise. Case hair before a week, sun Wenbin ever looked for Doctor Yang to had said, its mother cured row, if treat worse more, the life of Doctor Yang puts aside this, his life also puts aside this. On December 24, 2019 6 when make, when its are accompanying a bed, hear a scream, see Sun Wenbin use Doctor Yang downstage in rescue room knife disclose was hurt, security personnel comes in to surround him later. In process of its mother be in hospital, sun Wenbin is in all the time, just one day, he says to rent a house the thing having a place there, must go back.

Beijing Wei Jian appoint the proof such as issued consultation circumstance: After case hair, × × hospital puts forward a request other expert of 3 class hospital grinds sentence patient Sun Mou 1 illness. Consultation of much home hospital thinks: One, 1. Process of early days make a diagnosis and give treatment is normative, remedial program is sound, patient condition relatively be admitted to hospital to improve certainly from time to tome, but according to anamnesis account, the family member rejects examination and cure to cause difficulty of diagnosis and treatment for many times; 2. Continue to fight infection to support treatment; 3. Magnetism of nucleus of compensatory examination electroencephalogram, head and waist are worn; 4. Tone takes a patient to be gone to already record seeing a doctor and examination result; 5. Illness change follows examine. 2, the patient is senile, be admitted to hospital to make clear kidney function from time to tome not complete, high make water is acerbity, consideration existence affects a likelihood, do not eliminate make water of lung infection, secrete to fasten infection, there all is result of check of clear lung CT, make water after; Already granted to refuse infection treatment on cure. 3, already gave fighting fungus remedy is possible; Additional and OK fluid of alkalify make water is handled to disease. 4, patient consciousness obstacle does not eliminate to wait for metabolization sex element mussily with systematization infection or electrolyte relevant, without the evidence that affects inside skull.

Of Sun Wenbin for narrating with reach police work to show a proof apologetically:

On December 4, 2019, because the mother does not have a meal, its produce brawl with 2 elder brother, the decision reachs maternal area swallow outskirt life after. Its did not make a car through a lot of means, emergency treatment phone is dialed to appeal after, via talking things over, emergency treatment car takes its mother to head for × × hospital, thirdly elder sister is accompanied, emergency treatment car brings its mother room of emergency call of × × hospital to make treatment directly.

1 doctor gives Yang Mou its mother treatment, its follow Yang Mou 1 say its mother does not have illness, it is 9 days did not have a meal only, hope hospital can give bit of nutrition fluid. Yang Mou 1 to its the mother opened medicine, after was defeated by fluid, its took its mother to leave. Its had asked others later, be informed Yang Mou 1 what to its the mother leaves is not nutrient fluid. Its take its mother to arrive at the door emergency call of × × hospital with 3 elder sister, its mother is insensible, its push wheelchair to bring back its mother emergency call room again, thirdly elder sister looks at its mother in emergency call room, its go to a hospital seeking their guidance, its find chairman of week of emergency call room, he plans therapy at the same time to its mother examination at the same time. Its mother checks an a lot of disease during be in hospital of × × hospital, it is its are being taken care of with 3 elder sister during, treated probably a chapel, among them one day, introduced from the northern and western nationalities or from abroad doctor comes make the rounds of the wards, discover the hands or feet on the right side of its mother is moved not know clearly, the right hand does not have consciousness, its follow introduced from the northern and western nationalities or from abroad doctor urgent, shouted to him a few, he does not have Yan Sheng, also did not make a noise at that time rise. Its are particularly angry that day, express to Director Zhou, if its mother was treated to die, its also did not live, its are taking away Yang Mou one case 1.

Its returned the rental room of pieces of Yan Jiao is small each village to take a knife, had wrapped with polybag, insert in front of chatelaine the side in trousers, did not do any staying, return a hospital immediately. After reaching a hospital, its still are normally nurse mother, the knife is being taken all the time. Through cure, maternal illness also has disappeared. On December 23 Yang Mou 1 value evening shift, that day in the evening, its mother is unconscious, still breathe heavily badly, every time when its mother breathes heavily badly, its look for Yang Mou 1.

On December 24 5 when make, its look at maternal infusion, yang Mou 1 computer looks to handle official bussiness in room of emergency call rescue, its ask CT result of the mother before its go up, yang Mou 1 open computer, the CT that takes its mother looks to its, and tell say: "Your Mom is maintained so now, be no good was over. " its are listening to Yang Mou the word of 1, its mother did not save the means of understanding, its consider as Yang Mou 1 killed a mother. Be in at that time room of emergency call rescue, one house is patient and family member completely, yang Mou on the side of the 1 table that takes in rescue room, still have a nurse.

Its stand in Yang Mou of 1 right rear, yang Mou 1 talking with its later right, its listen to Yang Mou after the word of 1 urgent, wanted to kill Yang Mou 1. Its are direct from the knife that gets ready ahead of schedule is taken out between the waist, left hand holds a knife, the right hand is pressing Yang Mou 1 left, taking a knife to go to poplar left disclose of some 1 neck in the past, its are afraid that one knife is plunged into not dead, took a knife to delimit again Yang Mou 1 neck a few, yang Mou 1 shed paralysis of a lot of blood to fall on the ground; Its look at Yang Mou 1 will enrage, crouch again, left hand takes a knife according to Yang Mou the neck of 1 pricked two knives. Its are left-hander, its left hand is holding a knife at that time, specific cut a few knives to write down not clear, but affirmation is more than one knife.

There are a few doctors to perhaps ensure public security all round toward the collect before its body, a security personnel wants a knife with its, its are taking a knife to say with the person all round: "Everybody does not come over, have nothing to do with with you. " later, its left, return the bedside of its mother, expert machine calls the police, yang Mou 1 send rescue. After the police comes, its give the knife police.

Before its with Yang Mou 1 did not contradict, also had not produced conflict. The knife that its take from dwelling place of swallow outskirt of short duration, full-length 30 centimeter left and right sides, edge grows 20 centimeter left and right sides, chan Ren, brown Mu Bing, do not take scabbard, where a thing can be put to best use is wide 3 centimeter left and right sides, the belt is pointed, cook in the home at ordinary times with, it is its what toward in relief area a roadside buys is in when selling watermelon 2014.

Be carried on the court about Sun Wenbin relevant and exculpatory reach its paraclete place raises relevant and apologetic opinion, the court is integrated judge is as follows:

Above all, about what Sun Wenbin carries Yang Mou an examine uses 1 pair of Sun Mou plan of diagnosis and treatment of medical improper, hospital is unreasonable wait for a problem. Via checking, sun Mou 1 to the front of inflict of emergency call of × × hospital, contract a variety of severe diseases personally and make a diagnosis and give treatment has had in other hospital. Opinion of consultation of referenced and relevant expert, combine a hospital to Sun Mou the process of later period diagnosis and treatment of 1, classics this academy is examined, on record evidence is indemonstrable Yang Mou 1 be in a program of diagnosis and treatment that according to Sun Mou the illness of 1 uses medical improper, hospital in examine is unreasonable. What Sun Wenbin carries this to explain, do not grant to adopt.

Next, stress Sun Wenbin and its mother feeling about Sun Wenbin and its paraclete deep, because its mother patient's condition relapses, cause wave motion of Sun Wenbin mood to lose reason to wait to explain and defend then opinion. This academy thinks, danger of 1 department advanced age weighs Sun Mou patient, sun Wenbin cannot treat the reality that its mother becomes seriously ill correctly, flatter oneself head examine uses medical improper and generation is hated, plot beforehand carried out revengeful behavior, and the Sun Mou when crime is carried out in Sun Wenbin 1 still be in make a diagnosis and give treatment, place of Bin of reason grandson article carries afore-mentioned explaining to cannot become its killing Yang Mou the reason of 1 doctor. The reachs its paraclete apologetically apologetic opinion to Sun Wenbin, this academy does not grant to adopt.

Again, what confess his crime about what Sun Wenbin and its paraclete carry Sun Wenbin's behavior to form is exculpatory with apologetic opinion. Via checking, a criminal give himself up to the police calls the police after Sun Wenbin commits the crime, crime can commit for stating place according to the facts after bringing to justice, should maintain to confess one's crime. The reachs its paraclete apologetically apologetic opinion of reason Sun Wenbin, this academy gives adopt.

This academy thinks, sun Wenbin strips illegally intentionally other life, cause person death, already formed intended homicide, crime is extremely serious, should grant to penalize lawfully.

The basis shows the fact that already found out, sun Wenbin is right Yang Mou 1 doctor head examine is not agreed with with medicine, generate resentment thereby, produce killing intent then, plot beforehand and precondition tool, it serves to show its are subjective and extremely malign deep; When committing the crime, sun Wenbin holds dagger to relapse cut Yang Mou 1 cervical, send Yang Mou 1 fall down, hind in Yang Mou the 1 circumstance that does not have any mutinous ability falls, disregard other block the way, be opposite again Yang Mou 1 plunge into thorn, it serves to show sex of its person danger is great; Sun Wenbin faces numerous patient and family member and cure to protect personnel in room of hospital emergency call, the barefaced do violence that hold a knife and the method is particularly cruel, protect personnel to cause great panic to patient and family member and cure, the society of its behavior endangers it serves to show the gender is great, guilty property is extremely abominable. Although Sun Wenbin is had confess one's crime clue, but the fact that combines its to commit a crime, guilty property, clue reachs the harm level to the society, still can't punish lightly.

Accordingly the court decision is as follows: Sun Wenbin commits intended homicide, sentence capital punishment, privative politics right is lifelong.