If with Han Tangding Cheng Jiquan force hits out, beat northward nomadic political power to consult, the alliance of Chan deep is a treaty signed under coercion of course. With man says later with true ancestor if saying, say, it is a treaty signed under coercion, of age shame, be dishonour really. Even still a lot of person hold tight are worn now this are not put, think Northen Song Dynasty gives distant the state year old money, it is humiliate the nation and forfeit its sovereignty. Actually may not.
The first, from at that time the very actual strength of both sides of distant of the Song Dynasty contrasts for, northen Song Dynasty can not beat the assurance of distant country thoroughly, distant state also holds without what beat Northen Song Dynasty thoroughly, begin from initial stage of Northen Song Dynasty so, both sides of distant of the Song Dynasty undertook long-term be locked in a seesaw struggle, when the alliance to Chan deep is signed, the war had lasted 40 old, both sides is tired out, need rest and build up strength. In this kind general and balanced situation falls, reach agreement of a peace, reduce the burden of country and common people, do not calculate impolitic.
The 2nd, group of respect of Northen Song Dynasty goes what country of distant of be sent on a diplomatic mission undertakes negotiating is Cao is used, true a given bottom line it is million be equal to 2, but distant country also wants to come to an agreement rapidly very much actually, arms of early leave early, dare not want high price so, finally is with 100 thousand two reached agreements. This price of course not only far under true ancestor anticipate, 300 thousand what also anticipate under Kou Zhun even. Bilateral later course relapses for many times and be locked in a seesaw struggle, ability stability was in 300 thousand 2.
The 3rd, although according to the agreement, northen Song Dynasty needs to give distant country every year 100 thousand Qian Bo of two at first, increased 300 thousand again later 2, but with Northen Song Dynasty the economy at that time grows a standard for, this bit of property is a drop in the sea only, not worth to be carried. And, after reaching peaceful agreement, both sides begins to have peaceful trade, the goods and materials that Northen Song Dynasty can sell distant the country compares what distant country can sell Northen Song Dynasty to want of course great, the profit that so Northen Song Dynasty gets from inside commerce gives distant the amount of year old of money of the country more than far.
The 4th, the evening in the course of Central Plains area of period of Northen Song Dynasty the Tang Dynasty the extended chaos caused by war to the Five Dynasties, need rehabilitate will restore and develop, and south got more sufficient progress however in contemporaneity, for instance Jiangxi, Fujian, Zhejiang is in evening the Tang Dynasty arrives the Five Dynasties 10 countries the development rate of period is very rapid, what so Northen Song Dynasty holds is the agricultural area that is helpful for development quite, want to enter peacetime only, start peaceful race, the development speed of Northen Song Dynasty can exceed distant country far.
The 5th, although come from finance,say, do not calculate too heavy finance burden to Northen Song Dynasty to year old of money of distant country, and the government spending of a huge sum that avoided to have a battle with distant country, but at the same time have to approbatory is, although both sides reached peaceful agreement, but bilateral each other letter is existence problem from beginning to end, so Northen Song Dynasty needs to be in border area hoard for speculation is many and military, will assure oneself safety. Because do not have the country landform of swallow cloud area but endowment use, can do tactics of sea of faces only, northen Song Dynasty works hard in Heibei area old, just formed the defense line with a high price, three people are reached when legionary dimensions is most, this burden is very heavy.
The 6th, namely outdated looks from short-term effect, after the alliance in Chan deep is reached, official of gentleman of Northen Song Dynasty grew at a heat, entered the environment that compares peace relatively, although the chancellery of a few integrity returns the preparation that urging an emperor to want to do undergo self-imposed hardships so as to strengthen one's resolve to do sth all the time, still want recover swallow cloud later, begin to do the business that seals buddhist and auspicious sign and so on after Dan Zhenzong, did not put idea completely on serious issue. To benevolence period, passed peace of 339 years, war of the Western Xia regime together, lift face to astonish, even flat proposal abandons somebody Tong closes with on the west, or Sichuan of move the capital to another place, the peace that lasts it is thus clear that is right of official of gentleman of Northen Song Dynasty corrode degree.
