The conflict of two kinds of ideas and western the talent prediction of a person's luck in a given year of the college
Author | Cai Ning
Recently, the speech video of a schoolgirl was caused extensiveAttention. There is a catchword in the schoolgirl's speech: "This this world inequity, the travel before trying hard only " .
Undoubted, this catchword of the schoolgirl is correct. Between person and person, resource and aptitude are very different. But, want to try hard conscientiously to have get one's own back only, so regular system is benign still, normal.
This schoolgirl is namely below benign regular system education gave proper 3 view.
But, be in a lot of western or northeast college, the circumstance differs somewhat however. In these colleges, existence compares the conflict of two kinds of clear ideas.
A kind of idea, advocate to try hard conscientiously. Everybody is equal before ability, ability is sincerely convinced as the person.
Additionally one kind of idea, show opposite one side however.
Heart of a lot of people is very inimical to scientific research activity, do not wish to do scientific research, but, value very to all sorts of interests however. These person numbers are numerous, its idea can hold the mainstream.
Understand two kinds of concepts, a variety of phenomena in the school can find an explanation.
It is with title problem exemple.
In the college, the title is most affect interest distributive major issue.
Some western area college began to judge advanced title oneself 2017, the title that this college makes declares a condition in, academic respect is such requirements: Paper condition -- publish 2 conferences paper with the first author; Project condition -- before the rank 3 participate in national level project, or obtain approve 2 practical and new-style patent.
Other still have the hard thick line with a lot of education and student job firm respect.
Such title condition is apparent unreasonable: The person that does not have achievement of what scientific research can be judged on professor; And even if learning talent is judged go up outstanding blueness, the likelihood still teachs a condition not quite.
So this title condition was carried out 2018 merely, be revised considerably, rolled out the second edition.
Condition of title of the second edition amended Bug apparently, tend reasonable: Paper condition approbates periodical paper only; Project condition cannot take practical and new-style patent to fold touch; Lowered education and student government index, and paper of the person that scientific research is highlighted and project achieve certain condition to be able to bypass these bar bar promote to a high office directly.
I feel new to edition title condition reflected rationality, just sex originally, it is a thing that is fond of old general to run quickly. Who knows, have a lot of people actually not only grouchy, heavy-hearted instead, object strongly even!
Their reason is: According to new edition condition, the title was judged hard a lot of. In this one instant, I understood a few reasons suddenly.
I understood, the acerb conflict of two kinds of ideas cannot avoid!
I understood why total somebody likes to be on the conference with " do scientific research to affect teacher and student necessarily " for activity of generously attack scientific research, understood why somebody conveys a few right ideas to be able to be censured however in open circumstance " do not know the way of the world " " personality is too strong " . . . . . .
Difficult? The standard that is academic respect only becomes strict. Difficult, fathered, but consistent to everybody, what concerns?
In fact, they just hope not to do scientific research to also can become a professor just.
Additional, they also are not willing to see the professor is learning talent. Because if learning talent occupies dominant, can cause evaluation system farther apt scientific research.
Why can they generate this kind of idea? Because long-term since such, already be accustomed to sth.
As to why large quantities of people feel disgusted so to scientific research, would rather objecting idea flower on scientific research, do not wish to throw energy on scientific research, I understand its state of mind hard up to now.
Condition of title of the first edition is unreasonable, locate with the school and do not have a relation. The school is located in surely " education " , also have to tell learning.
Even if is in education university, pure because scientific research is outstanding and rising tall also be appropriate, teaching much not to do scientific research also is ill-considered.
Recognize this phenomenon, other a few look be like " strange " phenomenon, explained not hard also.
For instance, the requirement that criticizes graduate student adviser is " publish 5 papers, give a monograph / teaching material " , the teacher that publishs 4 SCI as a result is not judged on large guides, and the teacher that publishs 5 provinces publication can be judged however on.
Be like again, learning SCI of very outstanding, paper cites the professor of 4000+ , already judged on rich guides 3 years however because of winning recruit students quota never had coached doctoral student.
The conflict of two kinds of ideas affected just sex, affected academic modes of life and relation to their environment, be introduced to the talent and foster, the negative effect that builds the job to course is clearly.
The college was narrated why to amend title requirement quickly before, at a draught comprehensive rationalize? Because manage a layer to begin to review the matter of talent prediction of a person's luck in a given year deeply!
This is a favour. Reflected Things will develop in the opposite direction when they become extreme. , lose the effectiveness of feedback mechanism.
Link an address: Http://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-1213429-1189817.html
Cooperative matters concerned: Market@stimes.cn
Contribute matters concerned: Tougao@stimes.cn
