"Did not call first, you first the car you forth move " " he does not help within someone " .
On July 16, the 4 annulus austral Beijing happen one case small passenger car chases after end forklift and the traffic accident of on fire spontaneous combustion, cause death of the two people inside the passenger car. A paragraph of video presentation that the network circulates, after traffic accident happening, forklift driver calls to rescue them not actively however all the time.
After traffic accident happening, it is to help a person first, still call the police first? The practice of forklift driver causes heat to discuss.
One
16 days of before dawn 3 when make, south 4 annulus advocate the car on the road comes the car is gone to. In lean right on the 2nd driveway, the car head telescope of car of a white rear of forklift of a yellow, be squashed to be out of shape, side appears before billow smother. One is wearing light color short sleeve, the man station of brunet knickers calls in roadside.
A transient driver is very anxious, the station takes another side to film at the same time in segregation video, persuade a driver to save a person to matter at the same time. "You your car forth move, want flee in terrorfry in deep fat or oil! ... you get the person first! " the mobile phone that the driver drops ear limit, answered, "A moment ago I move. "A moment ago I move..
Between conversation, white car upblaze, many passerby takes fire extinguisher to go gush, but when be late already. "Save not know clearly, such. The person had been done not have. " in ablaze flaming car, have a driver and a passenger.
The video presentation of one bell grows when the net is passed, although spectator is persuaded with all possible means, take out the fire extinguisher inside him car to help put out a fire even, but forklift driver whole journey appears not anxious, be in all the time call call the police.
Graph / video check scheme
On July 18, bulletin of @ Beijing policeman says, on July 16, 2019 3 when 30 minutes, outer shroud of the 4 annulus austral in relief area of hold office at court advocate road the bridge austral 18 lis of inn on the west side, relative is such-and-such (male, 22 years old) drive not to allow to be in urban road advocate the card do not have date of road travel annulus car of machinery of type proper motion, be in south 4 annulus advocate road by on the west eastwards travel, comfortable small passenger car of a white is the same as direction by Qi Mou sail after some car come, forehead of small passenger car and annulus rear of car of machinery of type proper motion produces collision, on fire of small passenger car burns after, cause the Zhang Mou inside small passenger car (female, 31 years old) with Bai Mou some (female, 34 years old) two people die, two cars damage.
Current, relative is such-and-such because be suspected of error causing person death pain already by public security mechanism lawfully criminal is detained, the case is in further investigation.
2
"Two lives were done not have so, very distressed. " deeply regret of a lot of netizens while not without anger, think forklift driver inhospitality is selfish, be in intended and protracted time.
The person that oppugn thinks, after traffic accident happens, no matter be whose responsibility, helping a person is the first important or urgent business. Although forklift driver expresses him himself,move passes a car, but the eye looks at fume of small passenger car, at least should strand two females inside the car to procrastinate come out.
But the way that also the netizen expresses to understand forklift driver. Above all, the car is burning, if go up right now move car, car happening exploded, is oneself life safe who will assure? The emergency treatment knowledge that there is major in case cause harm 2 times? In addition, if destroyed the site, after the policeman reachs the spot, deciding is his responsibility, how to cast aside thoroughly to moment?
Help a person first, still call the police first? For a short while, the netizen is vexed.
Chinese news weekly initiated to poll in official small gain: "After traffic accident happens, should help a person first or call the police first? " share 5067 people to participate in at present voting, among them the netizen of 71.2% chose " help a person first " . Below this small gain, top praise answer is: "Save support of the people to call the police not to conflict, that male is to call time is too long! That male is to call time is too long!!
Law also sets, want to help a person. " law of road transportation safety " regulation, traffic accident produces on road, car drives the person ought to stop working instantly, protect the spot; Cause person casualties, car drives person ought to instantly rescue gets hurt personnel, the pointsman that rapid report is on duty or management department of transportation of public security mechanism. Because rescue gets hurt,personnel changes of the spot, ought to indicate the position. The person that take a car, vehicular traffic drives person, pedestrian traffic ought to give assistance.
Guangxi is wide Lei Jiamao of solicitor of big attorney office accepts Chinese news weekly to interview express, "The circumstance should be inspected to take a picture to help a person again first below the case that has personal casualty, perhaps save a person to take a picture again first, after be being saved moreover, indicate instantly, and helping a person while call the police even quickly. And helping a person while call the police even quickly..
Lei Jiamao expresses, if be the person that cause because of the wrong rescuing action of the person that rescue them really,hurt what affection accentuates or cause death, form error to send a person to weigh blame, error to cause person death pain likely, assuming criminal responsibility while still need to assume corresponding civil liability to pay compensation.
Beijing balance (Changsha) Liu Jing becomes attorney office solicitor to also tell Chinese news weekly publication, affirmation calling the police after accident happening is no problem, but if can rescueing them, should save for certain, cannot ignore life.
3
According to the bulletin, because be suspected of error causing person death pain,forklift driver is by public security mechanism lawfully criminal is detained.
Liu Jing is become think, this is after be based on traffic accident happening, forklift driver has factitive obligation, "Should be and not be, the person of the car after looking helplessly is burned, the personal casualty of the car after be opposite is responsible " .
Why be blame of traffic cause trouble? Lei Jiamao is analysed to Chinese news weekly, at present the cause of death of two deads in this case still hangs in the balance, the two people in fixing a car not finally namely are to die at traffic accident, still die at fire. Police may be a basis video and spot are preliminary judgement, forklift driver does not bear full main perhaps responsibility to the happening of traffic accident, think he is not suspected of blame of traffic cause trouble so. And, the two people in car of may preliminary judgement perhaps have police at least one person is because of what cause fire dies.
"Police maintains forklift driver to be suspected of error causing person death pain, such way is to compare reliable, more objective. " Lei Jiamao expresses, pass video to be able to see forklift driver also took deliverance step, call namely call the police, take fire extinguisher put out a fire to wait, the deliverance step that just takes cannot avoid the happening of dead result quite.
In addition, the information that discloses up to now, without evidence proof forklift driver is opposite dead result hold is gone after actively or the subjective manner of indulge.
Criminal law of Cai Yaji of law doctor @ also makes public a response to say in the light of this matter, cannot undertake the cognizance of fault form with postmortem eye, and should with the society when behavior the footing of average person undertakes judging: Object what appear as a result dying, it is error causes person death pain. Unless can find out forklift driver really,the fault mentality of indulge is had when the accident.
Face traffic accident, how is department handled correctly by personnel, lei Jiamao suggests, "Concerned branch can be in draw the accident deliverance headings in an account book with the corresponding setting in taking an examination of, corresponding perhaps deliverance trains, and be in undertake grooming accordingly to already acquiring the driver of the driver's license regularly. " he thinks, besides advocate outside abiding by traffic law laws and regulations, awe-stricken life and law, should fill go up to be driven actively what traffic accident training answers in studying test system is vacant, if send unripe postaccident how to distinguish,the circumstance undertakes handling, the person that how be opposite undertakes deliverance wait.
"What everybody enrages is forklift driver too chill! " have netizen analysis, this matter causes the reason that public opinion pays close attention to to depend on, it " concern law, more concern human nature " . The people thinks generally, before life and death, not should various balance advantages and disadvantages, and should life is consummate.
The near future is in Gansu Province Lanzhou, a taxi driver encounters other vehicle to produce traffic accident, be being issued by abuse circumstance by misunderstanding, still choose help a person for a short while. "Just began to feel to be subdued a bit, but thinking or save a person to matter. " after the event of driver ox master expresses. And in make clear after the fact, the person that be saved also to bovine master through media apology, appreciate his kindness that help.
