Li Zhijun prepares to sue this bank
This year 3, April, do card twice to encounter unsuccessful hind in the bank one after another, in Chengdu massage inn of a blind works 90 hind groups of the blind person is young Li Zhijun told the bank the court directly. Those who become defendant is hind a bank. This year on April 20, li Zhijun of 26 years old will be located in a bank near road of peaceful of day of new and high area conduct calorie of business. Li Zhijun says, sufferred the rejection of the bank however in process handling card, "Reason is I have eyesight obstacle to cannot undertake writing, if want to open an account, need unit opens recommendation, take registered permanent residence to be accompanied by family originally. Take registered permanent residence to be accompanied by family originally..
Li Zhijun thinks, he sufferred the distinction of the bank is treated, got discriminate against. Later, he sued the bank the court. 28 days morning, former defendant is bilateral in Chengdu the evidence before new and high court had formal open a court session is exchanged, both sides also was done on front courtyard elaborate accordingly. This case will at next month formal open a court session.
/ do card to meet with refus /
Inspect groups barrier is small to say " be treated by distinction " sue bank claim for compensation 1 yuan
Li Zhijun of 26 years old comes to Chengdu a few years ago, because of eyesight obstacle, in a blind at present massage inn works. On April 20, in go out together with the friend when travel, transient be located in the site of a bank near Tian Tailu of new and high area, decide to deal with a piece of bank to get stuck temporarily.
The staff member recieved Li Zhijun, did not give him to deal with nevertheless. "Reason is I have eyesight obstacle to cannot undertake writing, if want to open an account, need unit opens recommendation, take registered permanent residence to be accompanied by family originally. " Li Zhijun says, "I am not Chengdu person, family is impossible that from a great distance comes over to do Zhang Ka to help me. " Li Zhijun says, although the bank explained,be to stem from safe consideration, but still feel oneself " was treated by distinction " .
Li Zhijun decides, will uphold the right for oneself through lawsuit. On indictment, li Zhijun puts forward lawsuit to request, requirement bank deals with finance to serve business for its equality, make an apology on the newspaper that Chengdu publishs publicly, at the same time to solatium of spirit of bank claim for compensation 1 yuan.
Be not this by refus first. Li Zhijun says, be in this year when March, oneself ever reached the designated position to deal with a bank to get stuck at another bank near road of division China north, same by refus.
"I feel, we should be not distinguished to treat. " Li Zhijun says, actually oneself also can use a smartphone at ordinary times, can get online shop, also can use computer, besides give the inconvenience of travel, actually a lot of things like the ordinary person, oneself are not the person that does not have civil action competence.
/ the bank responds to /
Stem from protective client to undertake the risk hints and rather than refuses
On August 27 afternoon, chengdu business signs up for a reporter to come to this bank site, bank clerk expresses, li Zhijun has done a bank to get stuck to the site really, because had entered proceeding at present, need and province branch undertake contacting.
27 days afternoon 5 when make, the reporter received the telephone call that square relevant controller makes the bank. This chief says, li Zhijun runs calorie of course in, bank site staff member is not reject to conduct calorie of business for its, undertake normal risk hints however. This controller expresses, examine the monitoring that Li Zhijun conducts business that day to discover, several people accompany Li Zhijun to come over to conduct business together, because accompany the whole blame relative that Li Zhijun comes over, just undertook to him corresponding risk hints so
"Bank interior has relevant operation flow, not particular demand has family to accompany, but in view of what accompany him at that time not be family, we think to have certain risk hidden trouble, undertook clew so. " this controller then expresses, "Because serve as the blind, this has some of risk actually, the blind needs to install a password, (but) he himself cannot see, accompanying what he comes is not his relative, if by someone else witting use, it is the risk of a very big capital field. It is the risk of a very big capital field..
This chief says, after the risk hints, li Zhijun again also have not offers application, chose to sue however. "We also are not to refuse, he has the right that handles card, we just say, it he may use which kinds of means is a bit better that he may use which kinds of means. It he may use which kinds of means is a bit better that he may use which kinds of means..
/ judicial spot /
Accuser: The bank is objective on caused discrimination
The accused: Subjective it is well-meaning risk clew
28 days morning, li Zhijun accuses one case is in the bank Chengdu is new and high 26 courts have the court evidential exchange.
Acting lawyer Deng Hao weighs Li Zhijun, cannot say this bank clerk is subjective really on the existence discrimination to the blind, but the angle from the blind, the clause of the setting is objective went up to cause discrimination to them however. Deng Hao expresses, in be based on blind eye below the circumstance of obstacle of vision of invisible, existence, bank of hardware establishment respect or have involve, but relevant flow still lacks same consideration however. "Original eye is no-go, still ask to bring family instead, still need recommendation, more troublesome. More troublesome..
The accused agent says, the bank has the recording kinescope when Li Zhijun conducts business, the communication time that mirrors instead from recording kinescope is very short, have 6 minutes only, and the staff member is enquiring the process is medium, to a few information existence doubt is discussed.
"Do the authenticity of card to accuser, the staff member is stemmed from be on guard the consideration of safety of risk protection capital, after just asking accuser provides relevant auxiliary proof data, provide calorie of service for its again. " agent says, the service that anybody sex changes is to want to be premise in order to make sure the client's capital is safe, in the meantime, since 2014, the Central Bank for many times dispatch, ask each commercial bank raises risk canal to control capacity, rise examine obligation, "We admit give priority to watching is kindness, objective the regulation that also is executive superior branch, without any language characters that discriminate against affront and behavior.
Expert in all word
If where,father control fund safety and offer convenient the balance searchs between the service
Well-known, the property of the bank decided it must strict accuse capital safety, so, be convenient after all is the people more serious? It is more important to still protect capital security?
Standard of economy of Chinese people university teachs Shi Jichun: About the contradiction between advantage and safety, some moment cannot mediate. Stem from the regulation that safety first considers, to very much specific individual, think no-go. But below the condition that did not remove in safe doubt, unfavorable and first consideration is convenience. If appear individual situation, want individual analysis, cannot use a case to deny tight control of whole is spent.
Clear of Su Jie of associate professor of place of law of banking of university of Chinese politics and law: This mirrorred a bank charge the conflict between capital safety and its service tenet, very it's hard to say which facet is more important. The individual thinks, the bank is OK will set more refine, list the processing kind of exceptional case, is not from overall one knife is cut. This is the problem of a concept actually, encounter law to regulate a bank without rigid when the behavior of some respect, its regard a service as course of study, also answer to take certain step actively, alleviate thereby the contradiction between bank and client.
