? Han Chunyu and group were in associate professor of college of Heibei science and technology 2016 " natural - biology technology " dispatch, allege invented a kind of new gene to edit technical NgAgo-gDNA, suit to edit in group of the gene in human cell, oppugn after, many labs say that he cannot repeat its test result, dan Hanchun rain firm say to already many labs repeat its test. 2017, group of Han rain during springtime announces to remove draft.
Editor's note
Late on August 31, net of official of university of Heibei science and technology is published " the investigation that the school announces group of Han rain during springtime to remove draft paper and processing result " , say to check Han Chunyu to was published in 2015 seriously " natural - biology technology " the data of all and primitive test that the paper involves, entrust key laboratory of tripartite state to begin repeat test of test and verify, think the paper that remove draft already had the base that publishs afresh no longer, did not discover group of Han rain during springtime has the subjective case that make a holiday. The comment that this print publishs the Li Han of senior media person that pays close attention to policy of science and technology for a long time to put on the ice here.
The reader leaves a message or mail reachs greeting everybody Editor@zhishifenzi.com, announce investigation and processing result to publish a comment with respect to university of Heibei science and technology.
Write civil | Li Han is put on the ice (news analyst of this print engage by special arrangement)
Editor-in-charge | Li Xiaoming
● of of ● ●
The incident of long Han rain during springtime that procrastinated two years, had a findings eventually, university of Heibei science and technology was announced on August 31 " the investigation that the school announces group of Han rain during springtime to remove draft paper and processing result " (the following abbreviation " investigation and processing result " ) , the finite information that leaks among them makes clear, in investigating a process they " followed international rule " , introduced tripartite orgnaization to do repeat a test, although choose to be released in the late night, but than rising a few keep silent for a long time " ostrich " the school, it is a progress after all.
But, see the message of this hundreds of words carefully can discover, it is unexpectedly such " investigate " result, its core meaning with respect to a word: Did not discover group of Han rain during springtime has the subjective case that make a holiday!
? On August 31, 2018 late night, net of official of university of Heibei science and technology announces group of Han rain during springtime to remove the investigation of draft paper and processing result.
" investigation and processing result " say: Committee of this school learning establishs board of inquiry, act on " depend on compasses, rigorous standard, be practical and realistic, objective justice lawfully " principle, checked the data of all and primitive test that this paper involves seriously, entrust key laboratory of tripartite state to begin repeat test of test and verify, think the paper that remove draft already had the base that publishs afresh no longer, did not discover group of Han rain during springtime has the subjective case that make a holiday.
" investigation and processing result " say: On May 2, 2016, han Chunyu is in as newsletter writer " technology of natural · biology " published " NgAgo-gDNA edits a technology for oriented gene " paper. On August 3, 2017, group of Han rain during springtime recalls actively this paper. Learn to proofread this incident height to take seriously, according to learning, administration two lines undertook be checkinged in the round.
Handling a result is: In investigating a process, award of the scientific research project that Han Chunyu asks go back is based on institute of the paper that remove draft to obtain actively, performance, honorary title, society holds a post etc. Concerned respect already cancelled the honorary title that Han Chunyu wins according to the regulation, the scientific research project that ended group of Han rain during springtime to assume called in scientific research funds, called in place of group of Han rain during springtime wins award of performance of school scientific research. Individual society holds a post to be being dealt with by legal process.
" investigation and processing result " still express: During investigation, han Chunyu and its group cooperate actively, thanks to the attention of scholar of person of the same trade and social community, published the misdirect that causes to express regret to the paper. University of Heibei science and technology grasps hold " start line of business responsible " school example, support and encourage broad teachers and students to explore the people's livelihood of society of scientific and sealed, service. The school will be chance with this, promote scientific spirit further, hold to pair of academic dishonourable behavior " 0 patient " .
"Did not discover group of Han rain during springtime has the subjective case that make a holiday " -- are you believed?
Perhaps somebody is believed, somebody is not believed. After all we do not know this officer how " follow international rule " this investigation conclusion that make, and announce those who come out is a pole of it may be said uses up pallet findings.
From the point of the findings that announce, no less than " NEJM medicine forward position " (" magazine of new england medicine " Chinese edition) subeditor Zhao Jian flies to what what put forward, at least problem of 3 big core did not reply:
One, group of Han rain during springtime distorts or falsify experimental data?
2, does group of Han rain during springtime have record of experiment of destroy by melting or burning and stuff?
3, when Han Chunyu is accepting media to interview, why to have the view of a lot of antilogy? If be media clerical error, university of Heibei science and technology or whether should party sue reporter or media enroach on its reputation?
What common saying says is good: Hill changes hard, the gender moves hard. Since incident of rain during springtime seeing Han happens, him Han Chunyu is mixed the consistent performance of university of Heibei science and technology.
See Han Chunyu above all --
After July 2016, face one billow to pass the doubt of domestic and international person of the same trade of one billow high, profess " be willing to respond to doubt according to normal academic standard " Han Chunyu, contradict oneself, self-contradictory:
He for many times firm say " the test has repeated by the requirement before the paper is published, after the paper is published, also had repeated " , do not be willing to publish primitive data again at the same time, from card innocence: "Why do I want from card innocence, are oneself sick? " ;
He thinks cannot reduplicative lab " 80% because the experiment is polluted,be, the operation technology that those who remain is experimenter closes nevertheless " , but do not be willing to go again other lab is directive, think " not quite actual " ;
He says to already much home lab repeats the experimental result that gives him for many times, but the name of underground lab;
He is first when accepting media to interview, allege, "If they are willing real name comes out, the person real name that we let repeat an experiment to succeed comes out " , but when 13 scientists such as Wei Wensheng real name is made public " cannot repeat " hind, he says again: The list of the person that unjust cloth claims to be able to repeat is " protect them to also protect them " -- they became pitiful victim!
Even if is from " natural, biology technology " remove draft, han Chunyu not only do not think of oneself over- , still remove draft accusing at " the experimental program that scientific research bound cannot offer according to our paper all the time reappears again the crucial result that paper graph shows 4 times " .
He still continues to claim: "We can continue to investigate this research to lack but the reason of repeatability, in order to offer an optimized experimental program. In order to offer an optimized experimental program..
"Fail to keep faith, do not know its but " -- Han Chunyu frequently contradict oneself, was his word board of inquiry checked, what is true, what is crammer? Investigate conclusion and did not give out these crucial information.
Will watch college of Heibei science and technology again.
Face from arrive under the counter open, from arrive individually organization, from home abroad the doubt that science and technology travels together, entirely of university of Heibei science and technology turn a blind eye to, they are so do --
On July 7, 2016, university of Heibei science and technology is released fair show, plan to recommend Han Chunyu to be 2016 year " scholar of the Yangtse River rewards a plan " person selected candidate.
On August 18, han Chunyu is recommended to obtain by this school judge " beautiful Heibei · is the most beautiful teacher " honorary title.
On September 6, suffer fully in Han Chunyu many more domestic and international in the tremendous controversy voice that the lab cannot duplicate its test result, university of Heibei science and technology not only did not cash before a month " open test and verify " result, president Sun Hexu still is Han Chunyu to nod assist on new student opening celebration: "(the school) have a batch to be on education the serious and responsible, teacher team that is brave in to innovate on scientific research, especially a batch of young teachers like Han Chunyu. Especially a batch of young teachers like Han Chunyu..
On September 30, university of Heibei science and technology recommends Han Chunyu to be " 10 thousand people plan " " in innovation of young science and technology gets a soldier just " ...
See not hard, to the doubt of domestic and international scientific person of the same trade, university of Heibei science and technology not only did not launch investigation to the paper of Han Chunyu group, continue to bind the NgAgo project that gets doubt fully surely instead, strive for investment of funds of ranking scientific research, accelerate advance " the construction of the school and development " .
If the doubt that inspects the public and colleague of bound of science and technology is thinking without content, have one's mind stuffed with " the construction of the school and development " university of Heibei science and technology, their " investigate " are as a result you believed?
Especially: Already became in Han Chunyu and university of Heibei science and technology " caustic of all of flourish of one flourish all, one caustic " " interest community " below the circumstance, is latter true can " depend on compasses, rigorous standard, be practical and realistic, objective justice lawfully " ?
Below this kind of circumstance, it is be practical and realistic, bottom, according to compasses punish severely, or practice fraud, hold a group in the arms to warm oneself, fumble, deceive pass a barrier, reduce the loss to lowermost rate?
To Han Chunyu's experiment research undertakes " academic appraise sth through discussion " , result nothing more than two kinds: Err involuntarily and subjective make a holiday, both property is disparate, the result of processing also has great difference. If be subjective,make a holiday, prep according to Japan " small Baofangqingzi " , can knowing is -- not only Han Chunyu's lab can be shut, he himself is met by " lifelong ban contest " ; The relevant leader of university of Heibei science and technology, should also write a self-criticism at least?
If be " did not discover group of Han rain during springtime has the subjective case that make a holiday " ?
See the processing of university of Heibei science and technology: Concerned respect already cancelled the honorary title that Han Chunyu wins according to the regulation, the scientific research project that ended group of Han rain during springtime to assume called in scientific research funds, called in place of group of Han rain during springtime wins award of performance of school scientific research. In other words, with before publishing a paper, compare, han Chunyu as hair not caustic, whole body and retreat!
And Where is university of Heibei science and technology? Do they obtain Heibei province hair to change from this appoint why to invest 200 million much project funds to disappear explain?
Perhaps to university of Heibei science and technology, investigation ended at this point. What they are investigating is final claim to want " support and encourage broad teachers and students to explore the people's livelihood of society of scientific and sealed, service. The school will be chance with this, promote scientific spirit further, hold to pair of academic dishonourable behavior ' 0 patient ' . Hold to pair of academic dishonourable behavior ' 0 patient ' ..
If incident of Han rain during springtime winds up the matter hastily so, can the colleague of bound of science and technology that are those holding tremendous hope, costly in the arms to repeat test of Han rain during springtime painfully agree? Several with 1 million plan will be brainpower made why impressions? General office of general office of Central Committee of Communist Party of China, the State Council this year first half of the year of print and distribute " strengthen scientific research further does sincere letter build a certain number of opinions " affection why can?
Literally says, incident of Han rain during springtime is to examine two do " strengthen scientific research further sincere letter builds a certain number of opinions " whether the touchstone that fulfil, it is to measure extent of Chinese science and technology whether a surveyor's staff that maintains scientific dignity, it is the one side mirror of modes of life and relation to their environment of learning of shine upon China.
Want to know, university of Heibei science and technology announces " investigation and processing result " be not end, give the decisive word, and should be bound of science and technology of truth of broad public pursuit, China to academic dishonourable " 0 patient " , the beginning of the fight of defend science dignity --
One, the personnel list of the board of inquiry that asks university of Heibei science and technology to announce committee of this school learning to hold water;
2, ask board of inquiry to announce " the data of all and primitive test that this paper involves " , give out reach " did not discover Han Chunyu group has the subjective case that make a holiday " the detailed evidence of this one conclusion;
3, announce precatory of university of Heibei science and technology please " key laboratory of tripartite state " lab name and the personnel list that join check of aggravating second-round exam.
No less than goes to what the United States teachs to did not come 2017 Xu Chen of winner of science large award is in relief place character: The individual phenomenon that make a holiday is not terrible, terrible is small to be suspected of building the important matter of the holiday to change, it is the trample of pair of scientific dignity and academic principle. True the lifeline that is scientific research, sincere letter is the cornerstone that builds innovation nation, if a country connects principle of normative to basic science, learning careless, lack esteem and awe-stricken, if affect incident of such big Han rain during springtime with respect to such deceive pass a barrier, does He Tan build power of world science and technology?
Plate making edits | Leather skin fish
Copyright@zhishifenzi.com
Business affairs collaboration asks connection
Business@zhishifenzi.com
