On September 1, police of elder brother hill " elder brother hill throws person case " issue a bulletin, say to cycle the behavior of man Yu Haiming belongs to self-defence, do not bear criminal responsibility, public security mechanism lawfully case of cancel Yu Haiming. [more reviewing] in be informed after the case is qualitative, say 3 at Hai Minglian " acknowledgment " , meanwhile, the more detail when case hair also gradually by reductive.
Bang dragon companion: See Yu Haiming carrying a sword, I am scared
On August 27 21 when make 30 minutes, bang dragon drives BMW car is in city of elder brother hill westing of shake plain road comes crossing of suitable sail road, produce conflict with the Yuhaiming that is the same as Xiang Qi bicycle.
There are taking 4 people on BMW car at that time, bang dragon, Liu Jiang strong, their female friend of two people. Liu Jiang says by force, after bang dragon sails blame motor vehicle, think hit a car, quarrel with Yuhaiming in the car.
Bang dragon immediately makes Liu Jiang strong get off, look to hit a car, strong strong response says Liu to did not hit a car. Liu Jiang says by force, the female friend that takes in BMW car back row at that time also got off, help rise proper motion frame of Yuhaiming, put on driveway edge.
Liu Jiang is strong: I ask that the individual has a thing, he says to do not have a thing, do not have a thing I say you go.
Mix by force in Liu Jiang when female friend leaves, bang dragon rushed from cab, to the sea bright cuff and kick.
This one simple fist foot conflicts, take out to grow about 50 centimeters from cab as bang dragon, wide the double-faced edge cutting tool that restricts 5 centimeters, incident begins to upgrade.
Liu Jiang says by force, bang dragon bears down on Yuhaiming, all over the body that chop is blood when, he prepares to pulled bang dragon to go in the past, but Yuhaiming is when seeing this taking a knife, he is scared.
Liu Jiang is strong: See him (bang dragon) bled on arm, here bled.
Reporter: Do you see which bleed?
Liu Jiang is strong: On arm, wind bled, then the individual is pointing to me later, drive out is worn I. Bang dragon lets me run, I see that individual carrying knife drive out I, I ran.
Yu Haiming works in the same place: The driver comes out to come up dozen of person
This one act, colleague Xiaoke of Yu Haiming (alias) it is eyewitness. At that time, he is in from Yuhaiming the traffic light such as ten meters of far places. Small whole journey stalking or branch witnessed whole process, try to check the conflict of whole episode upgrades all the time.
Xiaoke says, the bang dragon that comes out from cab sees Yuhaiming begins to hit him. When bang dragon is being chased after at the back of Yu Haiming, did not chop him.
Xiaoke: Chased after him to was not chopped.
Reporter: Did not chop is was being pulled by you?
Xiaoke: He (Yuhaiming) run over toward that alley at that time, I am below that tree, he was not chased after. Next I hit a phone to call the police, after calling the police, I think the police comes quickly only.
After be informed a result, say 3 at Hai Minglian " acknowledgment "
After case hair, police of elder brother hill is harmed intentionally with be suspected of, adopted criminal coercive measures to Haiming. 1 day, public security bureau of city of elder brother hill decides, because guilty fact does not hold water, yuhaiming is suspected of cancel harming one case intentionally.
Zhang Gang of deputy director general of public security bureau of city of elder brother hill is accepted when interviewing, express, deal with relevant formalities instantly, remove to the sea bright criminal coercive measures, release instantly.
After be informed this one result, yu Haiming is choking with sobs to say 3 repeatedly " acknowledgment " : "Thank a country! Thank people government! Thank people police! To me, the judgment that made justice to this thing! To me, the judgment that made justice to this thing!!
At Home Haiming person: Present result fairness is just
After police of elder brother hill issues a bulletin, reporter of new capital newspaper contacted Yuhaiming the elder brother of the native place in Yuan Zaihan, its express to had said not to come out with joy word. He says, oneself also are to pass a network to was informed a message to acquire connection with sister-in-law, sister-in-law expresses very busy also now, hanged a phone.
"This thing got a fair justice (result) , plan the issue in good home next, want to saw him in the past. I feel this thing little brother is right all the time. " Yuhaiming's brother says.
According to at elder brother memory, the message that Yuhaiming has an accident at that time is to pass the phone of sister-in-law to be informed, specific also do not know what thing. See video later, family feels very astonish.
Introduce according to its, yu Haiming is a honest person as a child, the life is in a country, meet with the family member at ordinary times time is little, on holidays just returns old home, meet a thing to just be contacted, now and then call the newspaper is restful.
Some closer year, the little brother meets many jobs, domestic life disease also spent a lot of money, economy " very nervous " . "Period of time returns my mother to received the past to play period of time there before, just came back to do not have a few days he had an accident. Just came back to do not have a few days he had an accident..
Lawyer: Hope this case rises to explain for judicatory
To the processing result of this case, shaanxi lawyer Duan Mojin expresses, this is authority of self-defence of a citizen patulous mark sex case.
Duan Mojin thinks, this case most the problem of core is Yuhaiming grabs bang dragon chopper instead and disclose thorn chops the knife that hit number, cause bang dragon death, how is this one clue maintained?
A lot of people may think, after Yu Haiming grabs a knife, bang dragon has not been had continue to harm at ability, meanwhile stabs Liu Yi to be suspected of be being harmed intentionally with the knife. More stab bang dragon at Haimingdi what is more,the rather that hind, liu more do not have continue to harm at ability, and Yuhaiming continues to chase after chop, the suspicion that harms intentionally is bigger.
Duan Mojin expresses, this kind of idea looks be like reasonable, but overmeasure the sober and accurate defensive capability when average person be in danger. "The person is not a machine after all, be in exceeding danger in scared fluster when, making such conduct is understandable. This judiciary is very bold to Hai Mingzheng should be maintained defensively, it is patulous in practice the citizen's self-defence counterpoises. It is patulous in practice the citizen's self-defence counterpoises..
Duan Mojin thinks, yu Haiming is maintained finally to be the victory of self-defence since law, also be the need that franchise expands further, he hopes this case can rise to explain for judicatory, perhaps give when modification criminal law consideration, the case that allows this rises for law, become the consensus of legal group.
