On September 1, according to the bulletin of police of elder brother hill, times get attention " case of elder brother hill " had a result eventually: Guilty suspect Yuhaiming will hold a knife to throw the action that dragon of his bang of the injured party kills, belong to self-defence.
Affording general satisfaction of this one conclusion, think this is justice call. A lot of masses cheer caper, praise redress the scales of mechanism of public security, procuratorial work, safeguard justice.
But also individual netizen thinks, this is the victory of public opinion, public security, judiciary is the action that holds Yuhaiming by force of the pressure of public opinion it is self-defence; Otherwise, be maintained very likely to be defense to be become too, it is intended harm even.
Because of similar case, in Chinese great majority it is to be maintained to be intended harm to perhaps had defended when, the circumstance of cognizance self-defence is few.
According to " Jiangsu procuratorial work is online " report, an inquisitor was analysed " net of Chinese judge copy clerk " on 100 with " self-defence " for the 2 careful that requirement classics sentences (final judgment) criminal judgment, only 4 are maintained to be self-defence by the court, other 20 are become to had defended, 76 are intended harm blame.
The author thinks, "Case of elder brother hill " in the behavior of cognizance Yuhaiming is " self-defence " , of social public opinion it is admittedly important to supervise, but the progress that those who have decision effect is law, the force of social justice, and mechanism of public security, procuratorial work handles a case of the level rise.
Bulletin of police of elder brother hill says, plain road Yu Haiming delivered shock of city of elder brother hill on August 27, 2018 case of bang dragon death, public security mechanism is investigated through careful, and business asks procuratorial work mechanism to intervene ahead of schedule.
We report consequence of course of medium case origin, case, case to be able to see from police, public security mechanism is right " case of elder brother hill " passed careful to investigate, knew the whole process of the case and detail in detail.
For example, bang dragon place holds chopper, classics appraisal, this knife is pointed horn double-faced edge, full-length 59 centimeters, among them knife height 43 centimeters, 5 centimeters wide, fasten control cutting tool.
Be like again, bang dragon uses knife stroke Yu Haiming continuously ministry of cervical, waist, leg. The chopper in stroke is swung, yu Haiming grabs chopper, prick bang dragon abdomen, hip in the disclose in contention, chop attack right bosom, left shoulder, left ancon, thorn chops a process to last 7 seconds.
Look please: Bang dragon place holds cutting tool to be taboo control cutting tool, long, broad measure is specific; At the sea bright thorn chops a process to last 7 seconds, time is exact, the process is detailed.
In the meantime, public security mechanism returns business to ask procuratorial work mechanism to intervene ahead of schedule, strict according to " self-defence " establish a condition, serious analysis, joint research, guide obtain evidence, fill minute of argue, allow to be maintained truly, let be convinced of person profess to convinced.
Handling a case in the process, still made full use of method of science and technology, pass monitoring kinescope, mathematical calculation gives Yu Haiming thorn to chop a process to last 7 seconds. Pass appraisal of legal medical expert, clear harm degree and dead reason, have stronger persuasion.
So, the behavior of cognizance Yuhaiming is self-defence, it is the progress of law, just force, it is mechanism of public security, procuratorial work handles a case more of the level rise.
Before long, the case case that people reports to public security, judiciary is being dealt with to news media has veiled word quite, think news " staking " judicatory, affected a judiciary authority of independent exercise procuratorial work, jurisdiction and investigation authority, cause hold case of deal with according to law is unfair.
Undeniable, of news media intervene, meet those who affect public security, judiciary more or less handle a case behavior; But, of news media intervene, also be pair of public security, judiciary handles a case at the same time of the process supervise. Influence issues ability in sunshine only correct exercise, just generate corruption not easily. Public security, judiciary has what accept news media self-consciously to supervise only, ability assures justice, reduce unjust verdict.
More important is, law makes clear a regulation, authority of procuratorial work of judiciary independence exercise, jurisdiction, do not suffer the interference of any mechanism, organization and individual.
Accordingly, public security, judiciary ought to according to " it is a basis with the fact, it is criterion with law " principle, strictly observe discipline, justice executes the law, handle a case lawfully, eliminate to disturb, independent exercise powers and authorities of office, do not suffer the interference of any mechanism, organization and individual, should not be left and right sides of news media place more, ensure people feels fair justice in each case.
(note: The picture originates network)
Police bulletin
Plain road Yu Haiming delivered shock of city of elder brother hill on August 27, 2018 case of bang dragon death, get attention of social public opinion fully. Public security mechanism is investigated through careful, and business asks procuratorial work mechanism to intervene ahead of schedule, handle a circumstance to give with respect to this case investigation now bulletin.
One, the case is basic circumstance
On August 27, 2018 21 when make 30 minutes, bang dragon drives BMW car is in city of elder brother hill westing of shake plain road comes crossing of suitable sail road, produce conflict with the Yuhaiming that is the same as Xiang Qi bicycle. Bang dragon takes out a chopper from inside the car successive stroke Yu Haiming, be turned over to grab chopper by Yuhaiming after and disclose thorn, chop the knife that hit number, bang dragon experience is weighed, classics rescue is invalid die.
2, investigate cognizance fact
Receive after calling the police, public security bureau of city of elder brother hill goes out instantly alarm deal with and put on record is investigated. In view of this case society attention is spent tall, public security bureau of city of Jiangsu province Public Security Department, Suzhou expedite force to go to elder brother hill to coach case detect does the work for a short while. Classics spot perambulate, visit investigation, inquiry to interrogatory, video is investigated and examine the job such as appraisal, case fact has made a thorough investigation of.
(one) circumstance of experience case personnel
Bang dragon, male, 36 years old, the Gansu Province presses down former county person, shack home of land of city of elder brother hill presses down some village, before case hair in Liu Jiazhen of city of elder brother hill some company works.
Yu Haiming, male, 41 years old, shaanxi saves person of peaceful strong county, shack village of in relief Lu Mou of blueness of city of elder brother hill, city of elder brother hill is in before case hair department of some hotel project works.
The Liu when case hair is such-and-such (male) , Liu Mou (female) , Tang Mou some (female) be the same as a car with bang dragon. Some participates in Liu Mou beat up Yuhaiming, by lawfully administration detains 10 days; Liu Mou, Tang Mou some gets off help sb to get over his worries, did not participate in a case. Yuan of personnel of Yu Haiming's person of the same trade is such-and-such, did not participate in a case.
(2) hold main fact
1. Case origin. Case hair that evening, bang dragon drunk wine drives car of Anhui AP9G57 BMW (via detecting, 87mg/100ml of haemal alcohol content) , carry Liu such-and-such, Liu Mou, Tang Mou plain road westing reachs shake of city of hill of some edge elder brother when crossing of suitable sail road, enter blame motor-driven driveway forcibly right, with the Yuhaiming that rides a bicycle normally nearly is touched brush, both sides produces conflict then.
2. Case course. Liu is such-and-such get off first produce conflict with Yuhaiming, when returning vehicle via help sb to get over his worries of personnel of person of the same trade, bang dragon gets off suddenly, before going up, push, kick dozen of Yuhaiming. Although classics mediate, bang dragon still is chased after continuously dozen, BMW car is returned to take out a chopper after (classics appraisal, this knife is pointed horn double-faced edge, full-length 59 centimeters, among them knife height 43 centimeters, 5 centimeters wide, department control cutting tool) , yu Haiming of the successive stroke that use a knife ministry of cervical, waist, leg. The chopper in stroke is swung, yu Haiming grabs chopper, prick bang dragon abdomen, hip in the disclose in contention, chop attack right bosom, left shoulder, left ancon, thorn chops a process to last 7 seconds. Car of BMW of the run to after bang dragon gets hurt, at Hai Mingji add is chased after in all chopping 2 knives, among them 1 knife is chopped in car (classics perambulate, the edge below the window after the car is left has mark of 7 centimeters long knife) . Side of northeast of car of BMW of bang dragon run to, yu Haiming returns BMW car, take out mobile phone of dragon of the bang inside the car put him bag. After the policeman reachs the spot, yu Haiming gives mobile phone and chopper actively place alarm policeman (Yuhaiming says, taking away bang dragon mobile phone is to prevent the other side to call call together personnel to make reprisals) .
3. Case consequence. After bang dragon escapes, be in be apart from BMW car northeast inside the greenbelt that side is in more than meters 30, via sending medical service rescue disables to die that day after. Appraisal of classics legal medical expert combines video monitoring to maintain, inside 7 seconds time, bang dragon is pricked to chop 5 knives continuously, among them, the 1st knife pricks stamp injury for left abdomen, cause rupture of canal of abdominal vena cava, bowel, mesentery; The others 4 knives are ordinal cause left hip, right bust ministry of right the upper arm, left shoulder, left elbow in all 5 place open sexual cut and 3 place fracture, cause of death is exsanguine sex shock.
Yu Haiming is checked via person, see left cervical a form contusion 1 place, ministry of costal region of left bosom season form contusion 1 place.
3, the case is qualitative reach ground
The basis investigates the fact that find out, listen to opinion of procuratorial work mechanism and proposal, according to " criminal law of People's Republic of China " the 20th the 3rd " to having do violence, murder, rob, the violent crime that rape, kidnap endangers person security badly with etc, take defensive action, cause casualties of person of illegal enroach on, do not belong to defense to be become too, responsibility of not negative criminal " regulation, yu Haiming's behavior belongs to self-defence, do not bear criminal responsibility, public security mechanism lawfully case of cancel Yu Haiming. Prime cause is as follows:
(one) the behavior of bang dragon belongs to criminal law meaning to go up " do violence " . Basis " criminal law " the 20th the 3rd section provision, judgement " do violence " core depends on endangering person security whether badly. In judicatory practice, think to whether be belonged to " do violence " , cannot make excessive demands defensive person reacts in lash-up circumstance dirty gives rational judgement, cannot be premise in order to defend the person suffers real harm more, and should according to the spot specific scene reachs a society the cognitive level of average person undertakes judging. In this case, bang dragon is bare-handed attack first, then holds a knife successive stroke, its behavior endangers security of Yu Haiming person already badly, its are illegal enroach on should be maintained for " do violence " .
(2) the illegal enroach on of bang dragon is a persistent process. Review this record, below the personnel that be the same as a car and the circumstance that Yu Haiming conflict appeases basically, affray of bang dragon drunk wine, it is to get off first to the sea bright cuff and kick, return again after chopper is taken out inside the car, to Hai Minglian add counts second stroke, illegal enroach on upgrades ceaselessly. Bang dragon chopper is swung after falling in the ground, the knife is grabbed before going up again. After bang dragon is sent, still did not abandon the evidence of enroach on. Person safety of Yu Haiming lies all the time in the violent menace of bang dragon.
(3) Yuhaiming's behavior stems from defensive end. In this case, after Yu Haiming seizes a knife, the 5 knives of dragon of the thorn of the disclose inside 7 seconds, bang in chopping, with when chasing, swing attack, chop the two knives that attack (did not hit) , although there is removed, space to go up on time,have a space, but this is a successive behavior. Additional, yu Haiming stops to pursue and attack, returning BMW car to seek the end of bang dragon mobile phone is the person safety that prevents retaliation of personnel of get together of the other side, him protection, accord with the intent of self-defence.
4, other and pertinent question
(one) passing bang a surname about the net is " the day brings a company " the circumstance of the member that check. Affirm via investigating, bang dragon and " the day brings a company " did not concern; Did not discover " the day brings a company " there has been an activity in city of elder brother hill.
(2) pass bang a surname about the net likelihood the investigation state of affairs with black experience. Bang dragon Lai Kunshan worked in August 2006, the home is hired to press down some village with cummer before case hair the apartment of 49.1 square metre. During elder brother hill, because beat up,mar the illegal criminality such as property, intended harm other, intentionally, be in 1 times the set term of imprisonment that administration is detained and 3 times nine month differs to 3 years, public security mechanism did not discover bang dragon has experience at present black criminality.
(3) drive about bang dragon place BMW car condition. Affirm via investigation, the BMW car that dragon of the bang when case hair drives registers a car advocate for Zhejiang some rents company Hefei branch, tie name of cummer of bang Long Yiji, from Shanghai in June 2018 market of some two handcart is bought with loan means, head pay 127 thousand yuan, loan 327 thousand yuan. After case hair, via spot perambulate, other contraband did not discover inside the car.
(4) pass bang dragon to obtain about the net be ready to help others for a just cause honorary certificate circumstance. This circumstance is belonged to solid. In March 2018, because bang dragon provides important clue, assistance arrests the suspect that peddle poison, city of elder brother hill is ready to help others for a just cause foundation is depended on compasses issue for its be ready to help others for a just cause honorary certificate rewards 500 yuan. On August 29, city of elder brother hill is ready to help others for a just cause foundation already made a response to this.
Above details of a case and investigation handle a circumstance to be reported hereby. Thank broad netizen and social all circles to care support to what public security of elder brother hill works!
Public security bureau of city of elder brother hill
On September 1, 2018
Sweet clew:
Legal impression
Focusing law heat
Discuss legal issue
Promote law culture
