Heibei division makes mystery of Han Chunyu incident round deepen greatly: Uncertain learning dishonourable, but doubt is like processing
On August 31, university of Heibei science and technology is low-key announce " the investigation that Han Chunyu group removes draft paper and processing result " (next weighing " " investigation and processing result " " ) , the doubt that tries to whether build a holiday in order to be not worth the end of a conclusion of 600 words to be as long as more than 2 years about Han Chunyu.
What is the conclusion of incident of Han rain during springtime after all? This still is at present " unsettled case " , university of Heibei science and technology is right in conclusion Han Chunyu whether " academic dishonourable " did not maintain clearly. than below, another college Wuhan university responded to group of this school Li Gongliang to be informed against on January 29 when learning makes a holiday, think directly Li Gongliang " nonexistent learning makes false conduct " . Nevertheless, li Gongliang learning builds false incident instantly still open to question.
Insurgent news (Www.thepaper.cn) discovers in investigation, school just be opposite Han Chunyu whether " academic dishonourable " did not do maintain clearly, but relevant " stop or the scientific research project related cancel, cancel learning award, honorary title " , it is actually according to " precaution of colleges and universities and method of behavior of processing learning dishonourable " processing of the 5th chapter is opposite partly one of processing that person of responsibility of academic dishonourable behavior makes.
Insurgent news tries to obtain the detailed content about investigation from department of university of science and technology of Heibei of investigation main body, but Hu Yongqi of chairman of committee of members of standing committee of Party committee of university of Heibei science and technology, learning and academic committee secretariat all for many times refus is not received hear a telephone call. Additional, on net of Heibei division magnifico already list of committee member of committee of this school learning all Qing Dynasty is empty, relevant webpage is clicked go in to retain title only and do not have list content.
Be in in view of Han Chunyu international periodical of top class learning " natural - biology technology " (Nature Biotechnology) removes draft paper " NgAgo-gDNA edits a technology for oriented gene " the gene editor domain in big heat ever caused tremendous sensation, emphasize repeatedly in Han Chunyu " can repeat " below the circumstance, ground of funds of force of time-consuming, bad news, bad news is about a hundred lab this test and verify, " investigation and processing result " actually already no longer only the increase that the issue passes Han Chunyu and school oneself and reputation, findings more the effect that the issue closes pair of academias.
"The individual feels the purpose of investigation just wants to look for a view to deal with the past, experimental mistake can exist subjective and objective, but build a holiday to make a holiday namely, without subjective and objective cent. " Zhejiang university studies direction includes CRISPR gene to edit a technology to reform the professor with application is accepting insurgent news (when Www.thepaper.cn) is interviewed, express so. This also is at present academia is opposite the general view of incident of Han rain during springtime.
In addition, ceng Yu in October 2016, will participate in real name to oppugn shunt-wound name in November compose article " Questions About NgAgo " (" the doubt about NgaAgo " ) a researcher disclosed to insurgent news recently, national nature fund appoint special organization expert has opened a hearing, han Chunyu attended this second hearing. Nevertheless, this hearing is not wide inside academic circle and those who accuse. Insurgent news mail contacts relevant expert, also did not get a response.
Current, this processing that is aimed at Han Chunyu lets the outside feel him Han Chunyu is the condition before returning a paper to publish merely, "A hair nondestructive " . The personage inside course of study expresses to insurgent news, "If be learning,make a holiday, such processing is then apparent cannot be justified or explained away, if not be learning,make a holiday, that is good news to Han Chunyu and school, also do not have the truth of unjust cloth. Also do not have the truth of unjust cloth..
Investigate process underground, school refus talks
According to " precaution of colleges and universities and method of behavior of processing learning dishonourable " , colleges and universities is the main body of precaution of academic dishonourable behavior and processing. And according to " rules of commission of learning of colleges and universities " , colleges and universities ought to establish academic committee lawfully, serve as with academic committee inside school highest learning orgnaization, as a whole of exercise learning general affairs decision-making, discuss, assess and seek advice wait for powers and authorities of office.
Net of official of university of Heibei science and technology shows, committee of learning of university of Heibei science and technology is the school highest learning orgnaization, "Plan as a whole below frame of Cheng of the constitution of an association of school learning committee member of general affairs of learning of exercise my school decision-making, discuss, assess and seek advice wait for powers and authorities of office, stand fast academic major is judged, scrupulously abide by academic morality.
According to insurgent news (Www.thepaper.cn) understanding, chairman of committee of learning of university of Heibei science and technology is held the position of by Hu Yongqi of members of standing committee of school Party committee, this post nominates by the president, committee vote arises. Committee of learning of university of Heibei science and technology by president appoint to a position.
According to university of Heibei science and technology website of independent institute technical institute introduces, hu Yongqi was graduated from project of chemistry of Heibei chemical college to fasten in July 1983, graduation hind leaves school Ren Sai to think political job counsellor, turn after to hold the post of class teacher. Obtained work of engineering of chemistry of Beijing chemical college to learn master's degree in June 1988, obtained work of engineering of Tsinghua university chemistry to learn a doctor's degree in June 1998, went to department of project of science of the sources of energy of university of Japanese name ancient house to do postdoctoral research work in October 1998.
2002, hu Yongqi enters college of Heibei science and technology, dean of graduate school of college of science and technology of prexy of project of chemistry of university of science and technology of Ceng Renhe north and pharmacy, Heibei. In scientific research respect, main research domain of Hu Yongqi is catalytic reaction process and craft.
Message personage expresses to insurgent news, establish board of inquiry except school learning committee besides, "Hu Yongqi still is in charge of organizing the investigation of tripartite. " nevertheless, be in school in the verdict that just issues, the basic detail that in waiting for these is in to handle a result, number of academic committee board of inquiry and personnel composition, tripartite knows regular meeting to be announced external is current all have no way is informed.
To try reductive investigation technological process, insurgent news on September 5 for many times the phone contacts Hu Yongqi, but the other side all was not received listen. Same refus does not receive the audition academic committee secretariat that still net of official of university of Heibei science and technology is offerred to contact means.
Notable is, insurgent news is when list of committee member of committee of learning of inquiry of net of official of university of Heibei science and technology, the page below this caption is not put in list, show blank however.
Additional, insurgent news is contrasting " rules of commission of learning of colleges and universities " (Ministry of Education of People's Republic of China makes the 35th) and " rules of commission of learning of university of Heibei science and technology " when arrive alertly, running a system paragraphic in, " rules of commission of learning of university of Heibei science and technology " regulation, "Every school learning needs confidential content certainly on committee meeting, the committee member must keep secret, be carried out and safeguard the consideration of academic committee or result of appraise sth through discussion. " and " rules of commission of learning of colleges and universities " in set without this.
In the meantime, the moving system of two afore-mentioned files is paragraphic all set, "Academic committee made decision ought to give fair show, install demur period. If disagree,be in inside demur period, committee member of classics 1/3 above agrees, can hold a plenary session to reconsider. It is end conclusion via reconsidering the decision that carry. It is end conclusion via reconsidering the decision that carry..
But university of Heibei science and technology is in about the make decision of incident of Han rain during springtime its official net is apparent beforehand have not is fair show, the personage inside the school that occupies insurgent news bring into contact with expresses, "What also had not seen any hereon things inside the school is fair show " . And in " precaution of colleges and universities and method of behavior of processing learning dishonourable " (Ministry of Education of People's Republic of China makes the 40th) in also set, if have those who make clear the person that inform against, processing is returned as a result must in hand of the person that service is informed against, the demur that withholds 10 days or appeal period.
By the primitive data that the requirement publishs
Basis " precaution of colleges and universities and method of behavior of processing learning dishonourable " , board of inquiry ought to be in make a thorough investigation of findings report is formed on factual foundation. Findings report ought to include person of responsibility of academic dishonourable behavior to admit really, investigation process, fact is maintained reach conclusion of reason, investigation to wait.
This inadequacy that at present university of Heibei science and technology gives out of 600 words " investigation and processing result " , contrast afore-mentioned findings report requirements lack a lot of element apparently.
What can see from the verdict that announce is, the test that to the scientist before this the appeal should publish is primitive data, board of inquiry said to check this paper to involve seriously " data of all and primitive test " . Actually, these primitive data ever were emphasized asking to be made public external by the scientists of doubt NgAgo technology.
Be in early on July 21, 2016, the gene of Australian state-maintaineding university learns a Gai Tan Boer anxious (Gaetan Burgio) is being pushed go up especially release long article " my NgAgo is experienced " , ask Han Chunyu makes public all and primitive data and experimental condition namely.
On October 10, 2016, 13 Chinese biologists such as Wei Wensheng of professor of college of science of Beijing University life go up jointly to phonate publicly in media, they cannot repeat this test result, express consistently to hope Han Chunyu can publish all and primitive data at the same time, etc of university of science and technology of Heibei of place of Han rain during springtime is relevant unit (be like: Committee of national science foundation) investigation of the learning that start.
Dan Hanchun rain did not publish primitive data from beginning to end, when those firm say " can use what can give a response through academic periodical " .
Outside dividing primitive data, the outside pays close attention to most " but repeatability " , processing conclusion is mentioned only entrust tripartite to begin repeat test of test and verify, explain the result that test and verify experiments not clearly. The language that uses in conclusion is, "Think the paper that remove draft already had the base that publishs afresh no longer, did not discover group of Han rain during springtime has the subjective case that make a holiday " .
So, "Have the base that publishs afresh no longer " what be? "Subjective make a holiday " what be? Nonexistent subjective make a holiday in what problem is that group put after all?
"Be in without demonstrative fault completely inside investigation conclusion which link, which one pace, when, han says before can reduplicative is what to repeat, these were not mentioned, this does not talk to go up is an investigation. " before narrate Zhejiang university to teach speak bluntly.
Another academia personage expresses to insurgent news, regard scientific research as the unit, the verdict that university of Heibei science and technology issues this " too not rigorous " , "You say a verdict only, say to do not have subjective make a holiday, so specious conclusion is very unscientific. " similar learning builds referenced international the investigation processing of false doubt case, scientific method is the place that oppugns in the light of the person of the same trade make investigation process description and final cognizance one by one.
Actually, except at present this outer bound looks as before besides the conclusion in Yun Li mist, school interior still is circulating before this another version. News of Pai of Xiang Peng of the personage inside an officer of university of Heibei science and technology that approachs group of Han rain during springtime (Www.thepaper.cn) discloses, "The conclusion that passes between the teacher before this and what come out now is not quite same, saying before is to be able to be done, but efficiency is very low. " this personage earlies childhood, "Investigation gives verdict early, do not reach recently. Do not reach recently..
Nevertheless, afore-mentioned views still cannot get confirming from Hu Yongqi or academic committee secretariat at present.
Not only this processing technique lets the outside cannot be convinced, a few practices of the Han Chunyu before this and university of Heibei science and technology or acceptance also let the outside wait to come to nothing again and again.
With respect to the work efficiency of NgAgo, han Chunyu is going when the Zhejiang university to make a speech that paper co-worker Shen Xiao is in, ever spoke say, "In our lab, this successful rate is in 90% above, 10 dishes have a dish pollution also calculated, because of us there misty haze " .
And came on June 22, 2016 this short on October 14, 2016 inadequacy in 4 months, han Chunyu alleges external the lab that can repeat its test successfully reachs 1 from 20 drop off. Although have 1 only, also have no a lab to make public claim to pass, han Chunyu also with wishing the other side is annoyed for, reject to make public all the time.
Occupy xinhua net additionally to reported in August 2016, to on international a few scientists the requirement announces the requirement of primitive data, university of Heibei science and technology expresses at that time, after a month influences time, han Chunyu will adopt proper form to publish result of test and verify, at the appointed time will authoritative tripartite attest.
Nevertheless, school just did not cash up to now the acceptance at that time.
National nature fund appoint Ceng Shao opens a hearing, han Chunyu is attended
Besides the investigation that except school learning committee the organization launchs, because after the paper is published, Han Chunyu applies for a project to obtain national science foundation to aid financially, still enter national nature fund appoint hearing of witnesses rejoins.
Ceng Yu in October 2016, will participate in real name to oppugn shunt-wound name in November compose article " Questions About NgAgo " (" the doubt about NgaAgo " ) a researcher is right recently insurgent news (Www.thepaper.cn) expresses, "Before national nature fund appoint special organization expert has opened a hearing, han Chunyu attended to rejoin. Han Chunyu attended to rejoin..
September 2016, government-owned net shows committee of national science foundation, han Chunyu regards a project as chief " what NgAgo-gDNA gene edits a technology is perfect reach applied dug " the project is obtained approve 1 million yuan, days stops to came in January 2017 since the project in December 2018.
Be based on afore-mentioned projects to obtain wholesale after be born in paper of Han rain during springtime, the NgAgo-gDNA gene editor that its invent before this is aided financially technical authenticity and this sum whether to establish direct link up with. " precaution of colleges and universities and method of behavior of processing learning dishonourable " specific provision, ought to maintain include namely to make the case of academic dishonourable behavior " false learning information is provided in declaring the process such as task, achievement, award and functionary evaluation assess " .
In addition, or the additional brushstroke that in still mattering to Han Chunyu to remove draft paper, involves is aided financially. Paper " express one's thanks to " in mention, this paper got number of national science foundation is " 31270950 " project support. This project name is " evaluation blood-vessel is nervous element changeover is enzymatic the influence to submission of antigen of sex of the source outside the cell and its physiology meaning " , approval amount is 800 thousand yuan, rely on an unit to be Zhejiang university, time stopping since is to came 2016 months in January 2013 December. Shen Xiao of researcher of college of medicine of university of the 2nd author that project controller is the paper that remove draft, Zhejiang.
Nevertheless, shen Xiao ever expressed to media, "I tagged my fund, han Chunyu does not have fund. But basically Han Chunyu prepares this research oneself through each channel, my capital did not throw experimental share. My capital did not throw experimental share..
At present mail contacted insurgent news 2 experts that participate in a hearing, up to distribute news dispatches to all did not get a response.
The professor that Zhejiang university narrates before expresses, "If the country is natural fund appoint hold such hearing, normally should wide and those who accuse, make clear should investigate learning the manner of sincere letter. Make clear should investigate learning the manner of sincere letter..
According to the verdict that at present university of Heibei science and technology announces, concerned respect " the scientific research project that ended group of Han rain during springtime to assume called in scientific research funds " . But specific " concerned respect " who to point to, call in scientific research funds (part or already used) how to carry out all unidentified clear.
Uncertain " learning makes a holiday " , but processing is accorded with " learning makes a holiday " relevant provision
Divide outside recalling to let outside impeach by the findings of text body, university of Heibei science and technology this processing result to him Han Chunyu is very ambiguous also.
Processing says as a result: After this paper is published, pay of individual housing of Han Chunyu, title, pay all did not produce change. In investigating a process, award of the scientific research project that Han Chunyu asks go back is based on institute of the paper that remove draft to obtain actively, performance, honorary title, society holds a post etc. Concerned respect already cancelled the honorary title that Han Chunyu wins according to the regulation, the scientific research project that ended group of Han rain during springtime to assume called in scientific research funds, called in place of group of Han rain during springtime wins award of performance of school scientific research. Individual society holds a post to be being dealt with by legal process.
Handle a result according to this, him Han Chunyu is acclaimed more 2 years in experience, what be oppugned is big after falling greatly, was to return origin nevertheless, was not punished additionally.
In the meantime, if not subjective make a holiday, where is the honorary title that cancels Han Chunyu to obtain, basis that stops scientific research project to wait again? This is afraid need school explains further, group of Han rain during springtime is in maintain " not subjective make a holiday " besides, in what problem to put after all?
And contrast " precaution of colleges and universities and method of behavior of processing learning dishonourable " the 5th chapter treats a share, "Stop or the scientific research project related cancel, cancel learning award, honorary title " it is one of processing that make to person of responsibility of academic dishonourable behavior. The others still includes notice of criticism; Warning, record a demerit; Reduce technical position of major of grade of professional technical position, cancel or administrative duty; Discharge or dismiss; Law, code and the other processing measure that regulations provides.
If be put in academic dishonourable behavior to still cause what affect badly, ought to be maintained to be a clue serious. Processing should give reduce technical position of major of grade of professional technical position, cancel or administrative duty; Discharge or dismiss.
Additional, han Chunyu is divided after the paper is published obtain national science fund 1 million yuan outside aiding financially, most the nothing is more... than that gets attention, august 2016, heibei province hair changes appoint " the principle agrees " the Heibei division big gene that total investment is 224 million yuan edits project of project of technical research center, capital is arranged by capital of province finance sex. This gigantic endowment also let the outside think university of Heibei science and technology and the interest between Han Chunyu and reputation all are bound cheek by jowl was in one case.
On September 21, 2016, research center of technology of editor of gene of university of Heibei science and technology purchases project of entrance instrument equipment to be in Shijiazhuang open sealed tenders, among them budgetary amount is 19.58 million.
Current, this most is those who get attention gigantic endowment how wind up? University of Heibei science and technology and Heibei province hair change appoint all did not announce clear version.
Be worth what carry is, this conclusion of university of Heibei science and technology lets academia be full of doubt besides, also times feeling is disappointed. Researcher expresses, "This findings has those who be contrary to to come on stage at ministry of science and technology to concern learning sincere letter 0 tolerant mind. It is not clear to be done now still still can continue to pursue academic job for what what makes a holiday, academia should be accomplished truly ' 0 patient ' " .
What baffle to domestic academia is more than one person. According to date of small letter public " intellectual " reported a few days ago, before leaving Beijing University on August 26, teach toward American Masschusetts Institute of Technology " 80 hind " mathematician Xu Chen is in relief bound of science and technology of home of the refer when interviewing is accepted to exist before before leaving 3 big questions, include among them " learning builds a holiday to cannot get penalty " .
This world that make morning says, "Those who make a person amazed is, the thing that is suspected of making a holiday by exposure a long time, do not have the message of processing all the time, more do not talk to go up to punish measure specificly. More do not talk to go up to punish measure specificly..
"If ' 0 patient ' become finally ' 0 as ' or ' nonfeasance ' , can let a lot of person mistake be: Our system is not punished or cannot punish learning to make a holiday. If so, I feel the influence is very bad. " this world that make morning is mentioned.
Look at present, the school announced to start investigation in August 2017 up to now, the truth did not leave the public closer one pace.
