Civil / Qing Dynasty is joyous
The grave that closes 2 father was dug, is knife of month of green dragon cease really inside? How to still have two kinds of weapons?
Read historical novel occasionally, can help us know the history really, this is the advantage of this kind of novel. But novel this thing is not schoolbook after all, the author can contain his affection and viewpoint, read much may not is meddlesome. That is to say when historical novel is depicting the history impossibly, accomplish absolutely accurate with justice, we still meet a lot of time by misdirect, understand the historical knowledge of a few mistakes.
If read novel of so much history, had not read the word of the the Three Kingdoms, do not be the lover of historical novel. But we also know, novel of this historical novel adulterated too much him author affection. What do this calculate nevertheless, the most serious is the knowledge that we had a few mistakes to the history, resemble actually Guan Yu's weapon is knife of month of green dragon cease far from, only him author fabricates this.
The name of cease month knife originates the appearance of this kind of enginery, its form is like half moon, fall on his back namely month. Close the Chinese face last years of a dynasty or reign of a place actually, do not have this kind of enginery, according to archaeology data, it appears till Song Chaocai. Song Dai has there is the account to it in a book, there still is its plot in the book.
And the knife of period of the Three Kingdoms is straight commonly, and knife range is narrow, a meter or so long, the knife of Sichuan country should grow again a bit, in 1.2 meters of above. Sichuan knife is odd side edge commonly, and the back of a knife blade firm thick, without keen aiguille, but have annulus head, go to the lavatory to tangle with cloth in the artifice, the knife when avoiding to fighting falls off from inside the hand.
But, before long before, circulate Guan Yu's grave is dug on the net, knife of month of green dragon cease also was come to by gouge. Is this message true? Is there cease month knife really inside?
It is false apparently very, pass the time of a place, that moment makes the standard of enginery, it is not to build knife of month giving cease so of high-end enginery. So this Qing Long on the net falls on his back the message that lunar knife comes to from the gouge in closing a grave, it is somebody at all to acclaim flimflam. Archaeology personnel and expert of a few histories also had said, the weapon that involves a place to use in those days is not cease month knife, the message that goes up to the net so, we also do not want to believe blindly.
" annals of the Three Kingdoms " in, in Guan Yu's part, write him to be when big Zhan Yanliang, it is used " prick " and 2 words of " behead " . From the method of these two aggression, we can figure giving the weapon that he uses is what kind of roughly. "Pricking " to show his movement is sharp attack, entered the enemy's body when sharp puncture, yan Liangcai falls horse. And the enginery that can complete such actions, probable it is thorn arms, straight perhaps arms, if use cease month knife, a bit far-fetched.
Analyse a the Three Kingdoms again the enginery at that time is phyletic, we can discover the weapon that can use on the horse is medium, lance or Bing is what he uses when killing Yan Liang likely most, so bolo is the enginery that cannot be him absolutely.
After he is being killed by Lv Meng, chopped-off head is sent in Cao Cao hand. When Cao Cao sees this head, was frightened jump, because be too horrible really. Then Cao Cao let a person prepare pretty sacred, this chopped-off head well consecrate, and the ceremony thick bury with Wang Hou, besides, he still is getting 100 officials to go hold a memorial ceremony for is done obeisance to. Nevertheless Cao holds sweat from every pore sweat from every pore is not true for certain, the hyperbole view that is later generations only just, cao Cao does Liu Bei to look nevertheless.
Actually Guan Yu's grave has two place, henan Luoyang bury is worn his head, and Hubei is worn when in relief bury his body. Since he had not used cease month knife, so what is his enginery after all? In light of the clue that seeks from inside history, should be a gun or lance.
As to cease month knife, both hands of the need when using is held it is good to grasp ability break off chop, do not suit to fight immediately use. Use weapon on the horse in the novel of do a job with skill and ease that closes 2 father, not be taken cease month knife for certain, do not let him be opposite in He Yanliang war, because sit,should be him flabby and throw get down from a horse.
We saw many martial achievement that close 2 father fight the enemy from the novel, in our memory, bare hare horse is him sit ride, knife of month of green dragon cease is his enginery, such figure has been in our brain confirmed. So, abrupt a weapon that knows cease month knife is not him, still be not accepted a bit in the heart.
