Had you seen accuser is carrying what sue to the court on the back by the accused? Hu Lin 97 years old of old people tell 4 children the court! She rears 6 children all one's life, old age encounters such difficult problem however!
[the spot] the goal that I sue 2 daughter-in-law finally, not be to want money, it is to let him know he still has an old Mom, he must be served. I am a heart too soft, should not take care of old lady fetch, as a result I become personal enemy. Do I pursue a what? The disease of my a suit, brush boiler to must sit a bench brush. First time came, the old lady does not give me good look.
Accuser is one already 97 years old of senile old people, be called Yu Shuchun. The old person has 6 children, among them big daughter lives in Shandong with 3 sons, 4 sons produce an accident to die before New Year more, say the old person has so much child normally, should not anxious provide for the aged, because the child is too much,can be, everybody this steelyard is lopsided in the heart.
[the corresponding period] 2 sons (do they take money? ) did not take money, buy soap, washing powder usually these homely things, it is I give buy, did not want her money, see a doctor to did not want, as a result the money of old lady assemble gives them.
The time that the old person is entered in 2 sons king and lived near one year in the home, what 2 sons feel he are assumed is more, the mother ought not to come by him only provide for, then 2 sons king is entered and carrying maternal Yu Shuchun on the back to come to the court, the old person will include 2 sons inside other a few children told a court together.
Consider old person age is tall already, advocate careful the Sha Yunkai of dean of Hu Lin court of this case, special option is in the 2 sons of the old person " Wang Jin and " the home is sessional, current, the old person also lives here. Children alls present, big daughter person is in Shandong, the body is not quite good, did not come back, but old son attended front courtyard careful as legal support person.
The old person is 97 years old, ear has bit of back, but mental head is quite full, those who consider the age of the old person and expressive ability is insufficient, the court invited law to help a lawyer for old person of accuser Yu Shuchun, replace old person read out by him indictment.
[the spot] legal aid attorney replaces indictment of old person read out 4 the accused give Fu Yuan every months to accuse solatium, medical treatment each cost, nurse expend 800 yuan, the case accepts cost to be assumed by 4 the accused.
Fact and reason: Accuser lifetime bears 6 children, cornstalk Teng Xuebin is not had without female, department 5 protect door, old, weak and sick, the others children has steady economy income. Accuser is 97 years old, old is weak and sick, lose labor ability, daily life needs to person specially assigned for a task nurses, attend. Show 4 the accused to did not use up obligation of support old person, reject to pay solatium, medical treatment fee, nurse cost, the old person takes medicine every months give or take an injection the medical treatment expenses with need certain cost, although new farming close can submit an expense account cost of partial medical treatment, but still have cannot submit an expense account part. Accuser lifetime endure all kinds of hardships raises children the adult to come to get married severally establish line of business, old age lives unmanned however attend, accuser wants vexedder more, have no alternative, according to " rights and interests of old people of People's Republic of China guarantees a standard " the court that relevant provision tells, the request adjudicates 4 the accused give lawfully pay solatium, medical treatment fee, nurse cost, appeal to adjure a court to support accuser lawsuit to request lawfully to the court.
A few children surround what in sitting in this to be in the home, hold water temporarily court, listening to the indictment of old mother, all sorts of feelings well up in one's heart, they think to raise old person respect in provide for oneself, oneself do not have neglect one's duty and misgivings, but the 2 sons Wang Jin of the old person and however not so feel. He says, old Mom should go to Shandong living with 3 sons originally some of day, can want to invite the eldest son that the person cares, the old person goes back on his word not to think again.
This eldest son is other child's uterine elder brother, there is drawback in intellective respect, this year him many years old 70, without without female, lean low the relief that protects gold and brotherly sister lives. In old person heart most remember with concern this eldest son, want not to go with 3 sons after all with respect to hesitation so, as a result this hesitates, 3 sons answered Shandong with respect to oneself, did not get old Mom to go. Wang Jin and express even if because of this small episode, with the solatium that did not reach the designated position, let brother contradiction arose between the sister. But if someone else is mixed to Wang Jin, not be very self-identity.
[the spot] 3 sons Wang Jin connects me what write above this not to feed my Mom, I do not admit, I am annual money of take along sth to sb. (how many money to take? ) 1000 money. (give your mother every year 1000 money, is this decided before? ) this is Wang Jin is mixed decide.
The main central issue that argues between brotherly sister is: 2 sons feel its sister does not have provide for obligation, and someone else thinks again, use at the money of provide for the aged to the old lady, wang Jin is mixed and did not give an old person really.
800 yuan solatium is old person original idea after all, also became the central issue that sister of a few brother argues, when the judge asks an old person, the old person gives out however an unexpected answer.
[the spot] my money also does not have the old person, (is this money you want? ) I did not want.
Old person after all already advanced age of 97 years old, say child of grown-ups and children of child of grown-ups and children, conversation relapses instead answer, antilogy is understandable, calculate this money to did not arrive in old person bag, whose provide for old person, solatium is kept by who and control, excusable also.
No matter the truth is like why, the problem of provide for the aged of the old person must get settlement. Judge Sha Yunkai says, the main purpose of front courtyard careful, not be to want to criticize certain person, however for the old person can better how to enjoy old age, in do not hurt amiable circumstance to fall, the problem of provide for the aged of discussion old person. Final authority is in after consulting an old person, took out a solution, old person and 3 sons Wang Jin are connected go to Shandong living, every month takes other brother sister 800 yuan of money, serve as solatium to the old person.
Pass the judge's effort, result everyone is happy. Home Laowang these a few children, quite filial to the old person, their contradiction, between sister of consist in brother, of their dispute is only " who is taken more, who is taken less; Whose contribution is large, whose contribution is small " , did not make old person aspic move, hungry wear. Still can have a bit, do not know they think of, besides eat fully, wear warmly, the old person pursues even a heart in at ease, still hope to see young man and woman people amiable.
Say the honest and upright official decides household issue hard, dean Sha Yunkai of court of Dan Hulin's people decides this housework issue quite well, his judgement gives this is the in-house contradiction between children, the old person also does not have suffering sufferring what, with respect to Xiao Zhi with affection, move in order to manage, dissolved their contradiction, found settle way. Open the court in farmhouse courtyard, more ground connection is angry, this kind of assizes, it is to execute the law more for civilian, human nature is changed those who execute the law reflect.
Old people besides eat fully, wear warmly,
Still pursue a heart in at ease,
Want to see young man and woman people amiable,
Hope the everyone that becomes young man and woman is bit more active,
Must not be before the old person mutual buy is angry!
