Collect taste era to sell a company high price of intended empty appraise, cankered diddle sells the home to pay a service fee! On September 21 afternoon, first instance of court of the Milky way adjudges area of the Milky way first contract bilk records that use cultural relic to auction diddle to serve cost.
Net Tibetan the home finds appraisal company
Fall into the service to expend trap
Appraisal of ancestral porcelain vase 1 ten million
Yang Laoxian of 60 years old is unripe this year have an ancestral porcelain vase, want to seek person appraisal a particular year all the time. Remember oneself find Guangzhou art at the outset auction of appraisal of limited company of some culture development, yang Laoxian is unripe regret unceasingly. Yang Laoxian is unripe express, "2014, I search an input on Baidu " cultural relic china " , discovered Guangzhou art the website of limited company of some culture development, the dot enters this website, communicate via, 3 pieces of pictures that took a vase give the other side adviser. And company staff member expresses, want to see the picture to the expert. That day afternoon, adviser says, the vase is first-rate, it is to the Tibet of time is tasted, can take Tibet to taste a company to look, it is free that the company makes identification. After a few days, I was taking a vase to go to this company, or before has contacted adviser is in charge of recieving, introduce Yu Mou to give me understanding solely. After Yu Mou looked solely, tell me this history that the vase has more than 900 years, be kiln of official of the Southern Song Dynasty, can be worth 889, but must look to be auctioned where. After this, the executive general manager of the company I play all sorts of go about selling an idea auction, still say to press appraisal 1 ten million will auction, auction cost is pressed 1% will close, but should hand in auction cost to be auctioned again first. I am told with them at that time, without so much money, be not patted. The other side expresses to be able to be hit immediately fold, it is OK also to hand in the auction of 60 thousand to expend. I did not promise to come home at that time. After returning the home, I keep receiving Guangzhou art again the go canvassing phone of staff member of limited company of some culture development. I keep receiving Guangzhou art again the go canvassing phone of staff member of limited company of some culture development..
After a few days, yang Laoxian is born to come again art some company. Yang Laoxian gives birth to memory to, "At that time, they say sea of company boss Ding Mou can give me get ready again fold, it is OK that fourth boss says to hand in the auction of 30 thousand to expend, also can hand in a bit subscription first, qi Yu money is made inside 3 months. I handed in 1000 at that time, still signed contract of autumn on sale. After this, they urge me to pay more than ceaselessly. I made 29 thousand yuan of ready money again later, after which know to make this money, the company also was not contacted again, become me to want to contact them actively. And the sale of autumn Hong Kong that they and I had said can be pushed push again, my vase also was not auctioned in autumn Hong Kong later can sell go out. The end of the year when, they want me to take away a vase, say to have private should buy contact again, again later, art some company manages without anybody I. Art some company manages without anybody I..
In an instant the 2nd year, yang Laoxian is unripe very furious, "I arrive for many times art some company looks for Ding Mou sea to want to withdraw fund, but they are not retreated, still saying to do not have an auction to go out is star-crossed. After a few months, my recapture vase. After coming home, I want to jump over incorrect head more, feeling is was cheated by this group of person. The company says Yu Mou is appraisal expert solely, still say he has written a book, I just know he does not have appraisal aptitude later, deceive people. Deceive people..
Two censer total value 8.6 million
Mr Li is one collects lover, also be decieved be duped. Mr Li expresses, "2015 when, limited company of some culture development collects Guangzhou art department manager phones me, ask I have Tibet to taste, the other side says company actual strength is abundant the kind that a lot of abroad clients can pass an auction to perhaps trade under the counter tastes my Tibet skill. Urge in many their below, I was taking my 5 mammon censer to go to this company, after going, the staff member boasted with me the appraisal expert Yu Mou of the company is world famous expert solely, still gave work, still can check on the net. They tell me to want to hand in appraisal cost to ask expert appraisal again first, I handed in 500. Later, the large family other people that what Yu Mou says my censer is clear generation solely is deal ability some, it is good thing. After appraisal is over, give me appraisal estimate 4.8 million yuan of RMBs, say to be able to be popularized on the net or search to me under the counter buy the home, still can help me auction, through side of these 3 kinds of forms I sell a censer by the market price of 4.8 million, service fee presses the 1% pay of 4.8 million, hand in 48 thousand yuan namely, include to hold an exhibition, carry a plan collection, attend an auction to meet. I handed in 5000 that day, handed in 15 thousand yuan again later. Handed in 15 thousand yuan again later..
The first time contact this company, mr Li feels pretty good still, think move general another censer also auction of go off with, "After making money, I signed " Hong Kong collects monograph to serve conventional book " , they call me to come home wait for an announcement. Later, I took another censer to want to sell again, be appraisal of more than some light, he is oral saying is the cultural relic at the beginning of Ming Moqing, this censer by appraise 3.8 million yuan. Company staff member tells me, yu Mou is the appraisal division that has aptitude very much solely, of the whole world buy the home to believe him very much, had his letter, tibet tastes very easy skill. I handed in 10 thousand yuan to made Yu Mou smooth give a letter, money is handed in, evidence has done, there is a message later. There is a message later..
Mr Li is right the case remain fresh in one's memory at that time, "I had hit a phone a few times to give a company the staff member, they call me not anxious, antique is to want to sell slowly. After 3 months, the telephone call that makes before is hit was illogical. The person before I go to a company searching, company someone else says to be able to think method looks for those who buy the thing that the home will come to buy me. I wait for a message in the home all the time, but do not have a message all the time. I want to return the money that I make later to the company, discover the firm has closed, I discover is was cheated, conclude the case with respect to the newspaper later. Conclude the case with respect to the newspaper later..
Bilk gang " artful " knit a net, 25 the injured party are cheated
This bilk gang is not cheated Yang Laoxian to be born only with Mr Li, more than 20 clients Tibetan the home express to be deceived in succession. Via the court cognizance is found out, in Feburary 2014, some sea is in the accused population the road opens highway of yellow Bu of area of Guangzhou city the Milky way on the west some culture develops Guangzhou art limited company, hold the position of company legal representative. The accused population some sea is change of this company legal representative dragon of Song Mou of the accused person subsequently, continue to be managed actually art some company. Dragon of Song Mou of the accused person helps the accused number of people in a family some sea participates in administrative art some company, yu Mou holds the position of the accused person solely art the appraisal division of some company, he Mou of the accused person flies to hold the position of the clerk of the company and vise general manager early or late.
The accused population the person such as some sea alleges external with company name the business such as management artwork promotion, exhibition, auction, attract the injured party to sell to this company generation collect article, by the accused person Yu Mou is hidden to the injured party solely article have identification, pretend to hide strain rare treasure, by the accused person He Mou flies wait for the injured party of business personnel trick to taste the empty high price that makes hundred thousands of yuan differ to 10 thousand yuan thousands of to Tibet, pretend this company can be met through holding exhibition, sale, publish the form such as the magazine to taste Tibet of the injured party costly auction, diddle the injured party and company sign service contract, with this diddle so called service is expended. Some sea does not have population of the accused of after the event one group to auction a Tibet of the injured party successfully to taste. Classics audit, 25 the injured party such as Gao Mou by diddle RMB 644800 yuan.
Juridical result
Day net extensive, 4 the accused are sentenced set term of imprisonment
The court thinks, dragon of some sea, Song Mou, more than some light, He Mou flies to the accused population to be a purpose with detinue, gang is in sign, in fulfilling contract process, property of diddle the opposing party, amount is huge, its behavior already all constituted contract crime of fraud. In this case, the accused population some sea is company real operator and get together and service other people participate in crime, main effect has in collective crime, it is prime culprit, perhaps ought to organize according to what what its participate in lawfully, all crime punishs commanding. Some dragon, more than some light, He Mou flies to the Song Dynasty of the accused person suffer get together and employ to participate in crime, less important, auxiliary effect has in collective crime, it is accessary criminal, ought to reduce punishment lawfully, the position that considers person of each the accused to be in a company, hold a post the circumstance photograph union such as time distinguishs measurement of penalty.
Forensic court decision, some sea makes the accused population contract crime of fraud, sentence a set term of imprisonment 3 years 3 months, punish golden RMB 60 thousand yuan; Ding Mou sea ever absorbed public deposit blame illegally to be sentenced because of making in January 2015 set term of imprisonment 3 years, probation 3 years, punish golden RMB 60 thousand yuan, its in probation new pain of the recommit inside test period, the court counts a blame and punish, the decision carries out a set term of imprisonment 4 years 6 months, punish golden RMB twenty thousand and ten yuan.
Dragon of Song Mou of the accused person commits contract crime of fraud, sentence a set term of imprisonment one year 7 months, punish golden RMB 30 thousand yuan. Yu Mou of the accused person commits contract crime of fraud solely, sentence a set term of imprisonment one year 5 months, punish golden RMB 10 thousand yuan. He Mou of the accused person flies commit contract crime of fraud, sentence a set term of imprisonment one year 4 months, punish golden RMB 10 thousand yuan. Population of the accused of pursue and wipe out the illegal earning RMB of some sea 456300 yuan, give back gives each the injured party.
Judge view
In this case, the accused person falls in the circumstance that does not have appraisal aptitude, fix a price high to hiding a goods that collect to have theory, make Tibetan home right the vendibility of own article is immersed in wrong understanding, cheat so that the other side serves cost then.
According to report of this record proof material, station of appraisal of Guangdong province cultural relic is the unit of the appraisal aptitude that at present my province has aptitude of examine and verify of condition of pass in and out of national cultural relic and experience text content, cultural relic exclusively to auction mark. Via saving prices department approval, appraisal of province cultural relic stands but the appraisal expenses with certain collection, issue appraisal opinion book, in principle is incorrect cultural relic has appraised price. Namely station of appraisal of Guangdong province cultural relic is current provincial and exclusive the unit that has appraisal aptitude, other unit does not have a qualification, the company of the banner deal that making identification or the individual is flicker person.
According to the country concerned cultural relic auctions administrative regulation, the cultural relic of battalion of already of auction look forward to that establishs lawfully auctions business, the cultural relic that ought to obtain service of cultural relic of the State Council or service of provincial cultural relic to issue auctions licence. The unit that has cultural relic to auction aptitude is before auction cultural relic, ought to examine and verify of service of cultural relic of government of people of classics province, municipality, municipality directly under the Central Government, sign up for service of cultural relic of the State Council to put on record.
In the meantime, auction the relevant provision of the law according to our country, entrust on sale cultural relic, before the auction ought to the department of cultural relic administration of classics auctioneer seat lawfully appraisal, license. I save cultural relic to auction cultural relic of company on sale, all save appraisal of station of cultural relic appraisal, Guangdong to save license of cultural relic bureau by Guangdong.
The judge reminds
Raise vigilance, beware be decieved
In recent years, "Treasure of ancient bronze mirror " program conflagration, civilian antique trades the market is very hot. The judge reminds collect in the home have " baby " broad citizen, should raise vigilance, beware be decieved. Remind collect lover people do not believe division of so called appraisal, also do not exist " with small gain big " psychology, the sky won't drop pasty. Once discover when to be being cheated to want to reach, call the police, secure testimony, redeem or reduce a loss.
Reporter | Han Qian
Edit ｜ Dan Dan
Wonderful reviewing
