Confucius asks the story of ceremony and father, it is to originate of minister change " history write down " , this thing has appeared a lot of times in the document of the Warring States, in " The Book of Rites " and " village " in also have account. From the birth date, father is older than Confucius 20 years old (Confucius is born in BC 551 years, father is born in BC 571 years) , and the national library curator that father is at that time, confucius consults going up from the truth is justifiable to father.
What Dan Ji blames is, in the Confucianist classical " the analects of confucius " in, ask a ceremony to week whereaboutldirection father to Confucius this thing had never been carried however. Still have, document of according to the Warring States, confucius sees father this thing, when happening in Confucius 50 years old, but " · of the analects of confucius is politics " in an account in one's own words that recorded Confucius: I 10 5 and annals at learning, 30 and stand, 40 and not be puzzled, 50 and know destiny, 60 and ear is suitable, 70 and do not be about to even more from heart institute quadrature. 50 years old know destiny, how to because be opposite,meet " of the path should " feel bemused and go asking for advice at father? This feeling has bit of odd.
And in minister change " history write down " in, still mention a figure, it is old Lai child, and think father is old Lai child. According to history record, old Lai child with Confucius it is coetaneous person. Sima Qianshui " or say: Old Lai child Yi Chu's person also, write a book 15, of character Taoist school with, with Confucius at the same time the cloud. " means: Also someone says (the data is recorded) father is old Lai child, also be Hunan person, written book is not fluctuation piece " moral classics " , however 15 another composing; Also did not compare Confucius old, mix however Confucius about at the same time, take the place of together.
If we imagine the honest manner of minister change, he has seen having father additionally is old Lai child the historical data of this one view, more important is, he antedates to father Confucius, confucius once asked a gift at father this thing, do not have sufficient assurance actually. Of course the impeach manner of minister change, the part should come from him to be opposite " the analects of confucius " , the understanding to Confucius, because " the analects of confucius " in never had mentioned this thing.
Why can minister change fabricate this story then? Also do not fabricate actually, it is minister change basis " the analects of confucius " speculation of medium a few material comes out. Be in " the analects of confucius " on some, be " small child " a paragraph of story in.
Child road thereby hind, encounter wife's father, with San of bastinado carry on one's shoulder. Child the road asks: "Child see a master? " wife's father says: "4 body are not diligent, food crops is not divided. Is what a master? " establish its bastinado and Yun. Child road arch and stand. Stop child the way is old, kill chicken to be fed for millet, see secondly child Yan. Tomorrow, child the route goes in order to accuse. Child say: "Anchoret also. " make child the road sees instead. Come to go. Child the way says: "Not Shi Moyi. Long young section, cannot abandon also; Of Jun Chen justice, is the how that be like useless? Desire clean its body, and chaos is big human relations. The be an official of gentleman also, row its justice also. Of the path be no good, foregone. " child the route goes along with Confucius row, lagged behind to cannot find Confucius, the road meets an old man, choosing weeding tool with crutch, child the road asks: "Had you seen my teacher goes by? " old man response: "Your this individual works rarely it seems that, limb is underdeveloped, most probably also not know food crops is long what kind of, rash ground asks, who knows who your teacher is? " wear with respect to lean on a stick then crutch goes weeding. Child the road was scolded, know be in the wrong oneself, respectfully submissively is in for the ceremony stand by. Old man let wander away with the teacher child the road stays in him to live in one evening, still kill chicken to cook child the road eats, two sons that also invite him and child the road meets. The following day, child the road caught up with a teacher, this paragraph experience tells Confucius, confucius says: "This is not common redneck, it is an anchoret. " should child the route looks for old man later. Child the road goes back, old man has gone out left. Child does the way say (is the likelihood the son that tells old man) : ? How to still finish hair on the neck of a pig makes an appointment with drought copy of joyous predestined relationship of dispatch of Ji of Yu of プ of which θ ancienting name for a water catltrop does crock of 3 び go to live in the household of one's in-laws on getting married have does grave impossible block barren Qian rare to knock paddy of impossible of grave of busy of shipboard of avoid of of Ci example calumniate of boundless and indistinct of courtyard of Chen of Ai of beat of the Se below Tu Sao center does second ケ sink?The key of this paragraph of story depends on old man " with San of bastinado carry on one's shoulder " , and " old Lai child " among this name this " Lai " word, the meaning that weeds namely. Apparent, sima Qianren weeds to be being carried this the old man of the tool is old Lai likely very child, later ages speaks Confucius and this anchoretic encountering to ask the story of the ceremony to father for Confucius perfunctorily then. In other words, sima Qianming is white " the analects of confucius " in the deed that recorded a lot of Confucius to errant process encounters anchoret and be sneered at by doubt, think Confucius asks a ceremony the view at father, the likelihood is hold in the palm from inside these achievement change come out, not likely has Confucius to run to Zhou Qu to look for this painstakingly really " of the room that defend Tibet history " the accident that suffers example.
Weir Durante ever said distinguished historian " majority history is to guess, the part of the others is bias " .
Actually on the history a lot of unsettled case via removing deliberate, then you can ask the likelihood, why does Sima Qianhui apt believe Confucius once asked the ceremony crosses father? Be in actually the ideologist that Sima Qianye is school of a Taoist school, in him " discuss 6 main idea " in Sima Tanru this say home: Taoist school makes person mind concentrated, move close aeriform, provide for sufficient everythings on earth. Its are art also, because of yin and yang arrange greatly, collect Confucianism of law of name of Mo Zhishan, gather should, with when migratory, should content changes.
That is to say, sima Qianren assembled for Taoist school the yin-yang School, Confucianist, Mohist School, a person of academic or artistic distinction, Legalists these 5 elite advantage, smooth this word, minister the thought footing that talked to had made clear him himself, he is a Taoist school, and it is the footing from Taoist school sets out will arrange, judge " 6 argument " .
Say further, be in minister on the 6 headstream analysis that talk, conclude this is planted apparently " make person mind concentrated, move close aeriform, provide for sufficient everythings on earth " Taoist school thought is opposite of people of talent, can assemble so in front other each advantage. However this position that minister change did not accept father, in " history Han of the father that write down · is not biographies " in, he keeps the mind of father into 6 in most first, the earliest. So, minister change deflection the view at Taoist school did not have a reason, still be that word, majority history is to guess, the part of the others is bias, perhaps be really such.
But nevertheless, after all, no matter whether Confucius asks at father, without giving thought to old Lai child it is father, but these detail a bit do not affect father and thought of its Taoist school the position in the history.
Good, today's content is these, if like my article, pay close attention to please " small sow read " or the friend that shares you, thank.
