Recently, what psychology greeted is big " earthquake " .
Intermediary explodes outside piece: The famous Stanford jail experiment on the world (SPF) it is actually " fraud " .
This at a draught scamper opened boiler, caused discuss extensively while also drag in is worn the mood of people.
Somebody is straight expiratory to be no good, say oneself also do not believe schoolbook again; Somebody is right this fleer, state disappointed to psychology in the extreme is waited a moment.
Very fast, experimental architect poors ferry of benefit general · cling to make more refute, think its can change the conclusion of this experiment without sufficient evidence.
Namely, human behavior depends on greatly social part and located condition, anybody because the likelihood is located environment and become sadism or be by cruel mad.
Actually, stanford jail experiment suffers doubt since come out.
Besides set out from human relations morality, besides critical SPF experiment, many psychologist also point out the place with this impertinent experiment.
However, comment is taken when these equipment suffer the place of controversy to cite in schoolbook rarely however, not by us place is hep.
So, do they have after all how old was ferry affected on degree cling to much conclusion? Let us review this one test at the same time, taking the place that its controversy needs in light of the manner of existing doubt at the same time.
Go up century 70 time, american naval place administer in a few jails, convict and the concern issue between superintendency personnel are heavy.
For this, the force that American navy studies to the office wants to use psychologist will decode the human relation in the jail.
They are trying to offer funds to let ferry of · of phenanthrene benefit general cling to will design hand-in-hand travel more a series of experiments.
This psychologist that Stanford university took to be taught personally eventually when 38 years old, how does as it happens change the relevant topic for discussion such as the person to be interested quite to the environment.
Very fast, he devised the test of environment of jail of an almost complete imitate, the mankind that got Stanford university studies project office is approved.
Next, ferry cling to the many Craig Haney with the student, william Curtis Banks, david Jaffe and jail adviser Carlo Prescott, developed this great test that changes people acknowledge.
They built prison of a simulative in Stanford university basement.
Over, their installation is photographed like head, monitor, return the take out window or clock thing that can judge time, look as true jail general.
Later, they use the way such as newspaper to release information, called together 24 volunteers, pay everybody daily the pay of 15 dollars.
These volunteers all are the man with after the course checks, be to be healthy normal certainly, the majority is an undergraduate.
The recruit enlightenment at that time
They were become 3 groups by random cent: 9 9 jailer, convict and 6 reserves personnel, will have by a definite date two weeks imitate experiment.
To convenient managing, ferry cling to much him decision holds the position of allusion jail to grow, david Jeff joins his student to act as among them a senior administrator.
What differ with common experiment is, this experiment contrasts without the setting not only group will analyse quite, and researcher also participated in an experiment directly.
Look now, this can reduce the rigorous sex of experimental result and reliability undoubtedly.
Later, ferry the person shows Baduoben clearly also experiment from not quite rigorous at the beginning, oneself should not act two kinds of parts at the same time more.
The ferry among the experiment cling to much
Nevertheless, at that time ferry cling to be close to real effect to let imitate jail more, still make great efforts sufficient.
A day before the experiment, ferry cling to much specially opened a lecture for the volunteer of appropriative jailer.
Carelessness is the right that they are possessed to run a prison, enough freedom undertakes superintendency to convict.
But the point of one big dispute that this one act made this test however.
Ferry cling to the many original intention at that time is to let a volunteer enter a part better, look and do not have what misgivings.
But look in us, unavoidable meeting generates question, whether is this process in clear directive jailer can become more " crude " ? And this is right " jailer " next act effect degree has how old we also were judged hard.
9 undergraduates that act convict are in the home by the patron wagon of arise suddenly urgent arrest, record dactylogram, film case according to, be cheated the eye sends toward " subterranean jail " .
Subsequently, ferry cling to meet this batch of prisoner more by additionally 9 Xin Jinyu soldier is in charge of.
Each convict is ransacked systematically and strip off the dress, jailer people clear for them with sparge bacterium or pedicular.
And this each pace according to the flow of put in prison of American prison system is undertaking at that time, a part acted an experiment to be pulled open formally prelusive.
Though convict and jailer were put on respective " exclusive " uniform, but at the beginning they are basic mergence makes fun of, return a pair to have say to have laugh look.
As the David Jeff of senior administrator, will among them one did not take the place of to cry into part jailer aside, blame him the manner is insufficient " strong " .
But jailer people did not show due pattern as before. However, the following day in the morning, when convict people begin to reject obedient order, still prison guard deridingly aloud even. Jailer people the right that begins use oneself, undertake was suppressinged forcibly to convict.
After be pacified, a lot of jailer become really more " strong " rise.
They begin " education " see the person that seems not obedient convict, coerce they make the push-up, clothing that strips off them, make them empty begin to clean closestool.
Besides physical punishment, jailer people still prohibit the toilet on them, want their pail relieve oneself in prison house, what accumulate ceaselessly is fecal fume the room very quickly effluvially.
Partial jailer will be mistreated more later had upgraded into pure for make merry. They are press convict people the process with copulatory imitate; Or it is them hands or feet is bound rise, calling his greatly is convict.
See here, hair of the back after we can't help is cool, jailer people just do not enter sport too deep, how to still abuse the right that has oneself to undertake hitting pressing to innocent person?
Are these clammy behavior of the generation inside short time prison guard by what have power of initiative organization?
Facing a series of this hair people's soul-searching closely question, the exposure of experimental detail also let us have new knowledge.
Most before behavior is from Jeff the imitate jail that designs before this works in copy those who come.
Recollect according to him Jeff, he is guard really at that time people offerred those who look for convict trouble all sorts of ideas.
Because he feels he was gifted responsibility, need goes guiding piece " strong guard " behavior.
Nevertheless, as to how many having is jailer initiative behavior is an unknown as before, but their occurrence follows jailer itself from beginning to end was not to take off implication.
The office outside the jail
The jailer that one calls Aisheman at that time not only imitate south accent will show strong attitude, still behave atrociously all the more.
But Aisheman says frankly to the public however nowadays, oneself just regard it the practice that is a kind of extemporaneous performance.
He thinks he is doing student people the thing that him hope does, will shape this contemptible guard image with this.
Though coming is him since after-thought,do too overdo, but he thinks at that time ferry cling to appearing to this with etc researcher more is praise.
To ferry cling to whether ever spoke favorably of more and had urged these clammy action, we cannot leave final conclusion by right of character absurd.
But OK and affirmative is, ferry cling to whole journey of much research group is observing aside, record data, did not check from beginning to end.
Calculate convict people begin to be gotten to break down by these ferocious act do sth over and over again, ferry cling to study a group more or continueing experiment.
Actually, go in the experiment only after 36 hours, a code name is exclaiming to ask to put him ceaselessly for the convict division skin of 8612, appear hysterical the appearance that break down.
He cries in the jail ceaselessly: "I cannot go out they won't let; we leave! "And this one message produced intense cold cicada effect to all convict.
Still convict is recollected later, they feel they are true by captivity, feel very helpless, although resemble him painful in that way also cannot leave.
Communicating with all possible means invalid under, ferry Ba Duocai will agree with division skin to exit an experiment.
Of division skin short time break down appeared to prison guard at that time people reflect with bloodcurdling bloodily.
However, kepiru is interviewing the fear that saying his dramatic expression in Stanford jail experiment is not is pair of outrageous beefeater however today, fear oneself are not taken an examination of however on grind.
In other words, he is so called breaking down is to want to escape the performance of a jail stops only, be not those who come from jailer out of control to hit pressure.
What can make a person indissoluble is, in a few years when end in the experiment, the view of division skin also is changing repeatedly.
Say oneself are to want to take an examination of a little while grind, saying again a little while is to need to adjust a mood.
Prison house environment
Be worth what carry is, still having a kind of view is division skin thinking is to guide an uprise to liberate other prisoner.
At that time, the ferry as the warden cling to much hear this message when believed.
Another when he still tries to turn the jail to the building, lest division skin robs,jail succeeds. Wait till suffering without if really, ferry Ba Duocai easy tone.
Visible, right now ferry cling to it is more regarding his as is true " warden " , and forgetting his gradually is to undertaking science studies.
Of afterwards division skin after breaking down, additionally a few convict also appeared hysterical symptom.
Just, the cause that causes these symptoms more resembling is regarded oneself as true convict.
At that time, a jail priest that is in charge of listening to prayer does psychological dredge for all convict.
Have a number 819 rejected to communicate, he is crying hysterically all the time.
Be in right now, a jailer pulls other prisoner together, orderly cry delimitingly ten times greatly: "819 are a bad convict! "819 are a bad convict!!
819 after hearing voice, cry more fiercely, but still insist to return prison house in, because do not think,be become to become bad prisoner.
Another number because the convict of 419 does not know rule, and those who sufferred other prisoner is isolated.
Later, he gives a prison because of fearing not to escape again and undertake fast protests, still be prisonned guard finally coop in little black room.
Number 819 convict
When when the experiment undertakes the 5th day, the person that participates in an experiment appears by the experiment thoroughly domestic, became " oneself " another person beyond.
Worse is, ferry cling to still recording data seriously more, did not feel inappropriate part.
Till ferry cling to much cummer overcomes Si Lan of Ma of Li Siting graceful · to be arranged in the 6th day call in, just ended this experiment.
After Masilan witnessed the situation of the jail, she and ferry cling to said a lot of words more, carelessness is: These people are not convict, they are our students; They are having a rough time, and you should be in charge of for this.
Masilan and ferry cling to much postnuptial photograph
Masilan's word lets ferry cling to much instant sleeps lightly, farewell remembers the experiment is medium a variety of, jailer people mad, convict people acedia, what he just realizes a problem is serious.
The following day early in the morning, he announces to stop this originally two weeks experiment.
To make sure the experiment won't affect the life of participator, ferry cling to the psychological interpose that studies the group undertakes be spendinged energetically to everybody more.
They still dog the case that investigated all participator to return to the life, those who rejoice is, the person that the person that no matter be,apply cruel still suffers cruel did not discover what is unusual finally.
And the experiment is temporarily of break down, cannot write into paper, ferry cling to much compose research report is released in " naval research reports " be different from the periodical that discusses all right this.
Because this experiment is American navy,this action is lab offers funds to aid financially, not be to resemble the person that criticize thinking ferry cling to it is to be in what intended escape travels together to discuss more.
Later, ferry cling to also publish the follow-up research to Stanford experiment in relevant academic periodical and newspaper to be read for people more.
Not come singly but in pairs, in the experiment the report published around United States to happen a few meet with about jail convict or hostage the news of cause sb's death by maltreating him, media take advantage of an opportunity turns the result of this experiment to altar.
A few meet with about jail convict or hostage the news of cause sb's death by maltreating him
From this later, world of sensation of Stanford jail experiment, write into a lot of psychological schoolbook as classic case.
Guard of out of control and terrified convict people the reason emergency that breaks down one after another gets publicity, became numerous the culture touchstone of the book that gives priority to a problem with this, newsreel, film, undertake breaking up patting to its ceaselessly.
And Stanford jail experiment also by commonly used it teachs us external environment is easy and ecbolic evil.
Ferry Baduoben the person also arranged a lot of plan to drive favorable jail environment to reform after the experiment, was adopted one by one.
Adapt the stage photo of Stanford jail experiment of the film
Nevertheless, come for years the result of Stanford jail experiment is being examined repeatedly all the time, become 20 centuries to have the psychological test of controversy most.
And in June 2018, outside the newest exposure of intermediary, another aroused 1000 billow.
American writer Ben Blum claimed to interview many party (include ferry cling to much) , before discovering partial fact and this, tell about conflict somewhat.
Mention according to above paragraphs " convict " breaking down is installed, "Jailer " castigatory measure may be experimenter clear directive and rather than is waited a moment initiatively, show this is a fraud continuously.
He published virulent expression in the light of the authenticity of Stanford jail experiment and value, caused people for a time to ferry cling to much indignation.
But ferry the person is opposite Baduoben very quickly this was made refute, say these evidence are early be oppugned by psychologist, but the verdict that can't reverse an experiment to reach finally.
Ferry cling to publicize later the name is " become a hero " activity, hope more person can be brave in to become a hero that helps a person
The proponent thinks, these evidence also proved ferry from another kind of angle cling to much conclusion is correct.
Temporarily between, we judge what very hard also is what blame. But can affirmatory is ferry check has Baduoshi really a lot of impertinent, the experiment that oppugns the past afresh also is another kind of scientific progress.
Just whenever, when those easy and rapid drag the message of our mood emerges uptodate, we need not be worn urgently stand in line.
Come down to be examined seriously calmly, have probably other significant new discovery.
* reference material
Medium, the Lifespan Of A Lie. Ben Blum
Vox, the Stanford Prison Experiment Was Massively Influential. We Just Learned It Was A Fraud. Brian Resnick
Philip Zimbardo: The Psychology Of Evil, TED Talk.
Stanford Prison Experiment, prisonexp.org.
Maria Konniakova, the Real Lesson Of The Stanford Prison Experiment, the New Yorker.
Maria Konniakova, the Real Lesson Of The Stanford Prison Experiment, the New Yorker.
Ent Calo, special report of fruit carapace network: Ferry of · of phenanthrene benefit general cling to much.
Ferry of · of phenanthrene benefit general the person is in Baduoben know response: How ferry of · of general of benefit of look upon humble cling to is much Stanford jail experimentation announced to make a holiday?
_____________
