Judge anger rips Shanghai Dishini: 10 years old exceed 1.4 meters, why to calculate the child?_News

Recently, a Shanghai the message of the court on the accused causes Dishini the friend encircles heat to discuss.

Because be in the beginning of the year, the child that Liu Demin of a judge is bringing Guangdong to just spent birthday 10 years old goes Shanghai Dishinile garden amuse oneself, be asked to buy adult ticket to the child by the staff member however, because child height exceeded 1.4 meters.

According to Shanghai standard of Dishini that buy a ticket, height is the upper limit that buys children ticket 1.4 meters.

Buying the accused of children ticket spot to know height ahead of schedule is a standard

Liu Demin goes to Shanghai Dishinile before garden

Already bought on the net 499 yuan " close child cover a bill " .

When into garden he changed paper entrance ticket that day,

The staff member says child height exceeded children ticket to buy bill level.

Delimit in wicket mouth before the gage of quarter,

Think the child is less than 1.4 meters after staff member observation,

But a staff member that is in charge of checking held to 1.4 meters to think.

To do not affect other visitor,

Liu Demin asked to buy adult ticket for the child by the other side,

With the friend of his person of the same trade,

The child has 9 years old only,

Also because of " freeboard " ticket of the adult that be bought by the requirement.

Make work in a famous network on ticket platform,

Every other period of time,

can the client buys a standard to raise a question in the light of children ticket.

The answer that they get is normally,

If child height exceeds 1.4 meters,

Want to play to be able to buy adult ticket only,

If 1.4 meters are controlled,

Can buy children ticket to have a try luck.

Children ticket is to sell true children after all,

Can you still sell height 1.4 meters of the following people only?

Liu Demin thinks 1.4 meters children bill level is early should be washed out,

Will limit children ticket with the age ability science is reasonable and equal and maneuverable,

Also can reflect the estimation to the person.

The judge sues Dishini to ask to revise a criterion

Shanghai enlighten person Buddhist nun Eden

Holiday adult ticket is ticket of 575 yuan of children 431 yuan

Ferial adult ticket ticket of 399 yuan of children 299 yuan

That is to say

Children ticket is in holiday is OK and favourable 144 yuan

Ferial privilege 100 yuan

Then, liu Demin Shanghai Dishinile " of limited company of Eden of theme of " Shanghai international tells one of owner of garden court.

Dishini responds to: Considering safe element

When with Dishini the respect is communicated, the reporter also understands, at the outset Dishinile opens Shanghai field before garden, the decision does not use foreign Eden to use a level for children ticket with the age, basically be based on the consideration of two respects.

It is children does not have Id commonly, actually border age is maintained intuitionisticly not easily quickly;

2 it is public to generous of stream of people facilities and scene area, if use the age to regard the use of children ticket as the standard, the staff member checks need check ticket one by one check the booklet of registered residence of children or the identity document such as student proof, such take time are arduous, can affect a crowd to pass through quickly greatly, cause have a safe even hidden trouble.

Current, besides Shanghai enlighten person Buddhist nun Eden, the children bill level of the scene area such as marine aquaria of television tower of Shanghai Oriental bright phearl, Shanghai, it is likewise do not exceed 1.4 meters of in the limit of with height. The thematic Eden of domestic much ground, like Shenzhen joy cereal and Zhuhai grow Long Haiyang kingdom to wait, already all was children bill level 1.5 meters surely the following, in addition still sell student bill.

Our country " minor protects a law " regulation, the place such as museum, zoo, ought to be opposite according to concerned regulation minor is free favourable perhaps and open. Although " minor " belong to strict legal concept, it is the citizen that shows 18 one full year of life are the following, but each law was not mixed directly the establish that sets children bill standard clearly is a standard with the age.

The setting of children ticket

By height? By the age?

Station " the age " the viewpoint of one party:

① 1.4 meters children bill level is early should be washed out, will limit children ticket with the age just is science, reasonable, equal and maneuverable, also can reflect the estimation to the person.

Liu Demin also consulted the Dishinile of much ground of Hong Kong, Tokyo, Paris and North America level of garden children bill, discover besides Shanghai Dishini, these Dishinile is ticket of standard sale children with the age field.

Again for instance, dishinile sets Tokyo field, 4 one full year of life (do not contain) free of charge of the following children, one full year of life of 4 years old of ~11 buys children ticket, 12 years old of ~17 year old the student buys student ticket, 18 years old of above just need to buy adult ticket; Dishinile sets Paris and Hong Kong field, 2 years old of the following free of charge, 3 years old of ~11 year old buy children ticket, 12 years old of above buy total value ticket; The California of American mainland and Aolanduodishini Eden also is it is a standard with the age, the regulation can buy children ticket 3 years old to 9 years old.

② China children is already opposite " long tall " , measure a children to whether can buy children ticket simply with height for the standard, actually not reasonable. Data makes clear, the average height of Chinese child is broken through ceaselessly new tall. Newest of one edition " standard of children height weight is expressed " show, at present China 6 years old male child height is 111.2 centimeters of ～ about 121 centimeters, female Tong Wei 109.7 centimeters of ～ 119.6 centimeters, 11 years old of male Tong Wei 132.1 centimeters of ～ 152.1 centimeters, female Tong Wei 133.4 centimeters of ～ 153.3 centimeters.

Station " height " the viewpoint of one party:

① is convenient, look after children at least go out the certificate that need not carry proof identity age. Resemble taking train car to buy a ticket, some children had not handled id card, have to take registered permanent residence of this and so on will prove the age. And with height very convenient, it is OK that station or scene area doorway set a slotted line.

② to the scene area that a few have You Le establishment, project of some amuse oneself has certain limitation to ask to children height, will assure the safety when children amuse oneself. Consider cost of scene district operation so, more of the meeting on the consideration that entrance ticket installs makes a standard from height and not be the age. Because of China " children " height look is already long to old standard tall.

③ resembles Dishini such belonging to of company property, can set the favourable policy of children entrance ticket according to his management state. Can provide a certain time completely also like area of a scene paragraph perhaps hit freely to a certain specific group fold, this does not mean favourable to doing not have method to enjoy or free crowd is a kind of discrimination.

Children buys a ticket

What standard should press after all?

According to the report, similar children bill buys bill level to argue, ever also happened in the railway station.

Be in early 2010, former railway ministry was revised " regulations of railroad passenger transportation " , the height that stipulates be accompanying adult travels the children of rice of 1.2 meters of ~1.5, ought to buy children ticket; Total value ticket should be bought when exceeding 1.5 meters. The regulation before this is height 1.4 meters children should buy 1.1 meters of ～ children ticket.

2017 the whole nation on two meetings, moustache of assistant dean of courtyard of division of committee member of countrywide the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference, Shanghai teaching defends farther to table a proposal, hope railway system revises children to buy bill level as soon as possible, level of train free of charge promotion reachs 1.3 meters, full standard rises reach 1.6 meters.

Children buys a ticket, in Zhejiang scene area be according to what standard?

Wall bulletin reporter sought advice from each opinion such as the personage inside travel management department and scene area tourism:

Zhejiang saves tourism bureau:

" travel mode " and " Zhejiang saves travel rules " the specific provision that waits for the legal laws and regulations of travel field to do not have this respect.

Carry on encourages chief of some amusement park:

The enterprise decides this level, the level with different different company, decide commonly according to height, our scene area is 1.1- - 1.4 meters enjoy children price, 1.1 meters are avoided below, full of 1.4 meters of above. And the You Le establishment to scene area, to assure the safety of children, there is strict restriction on height.

Hold post at Zhejiang some lawyer goes Tang Lv division:

At present our country did not install a standard to one arrives accurately to be returned by the age to children fare is by height such law sets. But the corresponding byelaw that also does not eliminate each district travel or traffic department to come on stage or regulation. Related basis has these roughly:

The U.N. that signs according to multilateral combination " children right convention " , always the incident of interest of drag in children, should implement children increase the biggest change a standard.

Our country " minor protects a law " regulation, the place such as museum, zoo, ought to be opposite according to concerned regulation minor is free favourable perhaps and open. But " minor " it is a strict legal concept, point to the citizen under 18 one full year of life, but each law was not mixed directly the establish that sets children bill standard clearly is a standard with the age.

Incident is newest progress:

Liu Demin is accepting Chinese blueness when black online reporter is interviewed in annals · , express, this year after his to lodge a complaint, april, ever staff member of limited company of Eden of Shanghai international theme contacts him actively, the practice that asks to be below the case that did not decide child height he buys adult ticket expresses regret, put forward to be willing to return the ticket money of his overpay, hope he is accepted reconcile and nolle prosequi.

But, liu Demin reiterated his position in the indictment to the other side: Dishinile revises hope Shanghai field active children bill level, the Hong Kong that consults to be in China together enlighten person Buddhist nun Eden, it is children bill level 3 years old of ~11 surely year old, free of charge of 3 years old of the following children. The other side accepts his condition, he just is willing to nolle prosequi. At present the other side has not replied.

In the indictment, a request that Liu Demin puts forward is, hope court is sentenced make return the ticket money that returns him overpay.

This case will by people of Shanghai Pudong new developed area at the near future open a court session of forensic plain sanded court is tried.