" a good fun " placard
New network client carries Beijing in on August 14 report (Yuan Xiuyue) late on August 12, an author that is called Yu Mengyuan is in small gain dispatch, weigh Huang Bo " a good fun " borrowed the play that drew lessons from her " man crisis " , there is similar place on story subject matter and character role. To this, " a good fun " piece just express not to grant to respond to, think this action is to be in " touch porcelain " . Yu Mengyuan tells in new network reporter, oneself still have other evidence, but not quite convenient before official put on record put, because taking legal course, she still emphasizes saying, the evidence that did not put more " real hammer into shape " .
Webpage cut pursues: Say at dream Yuan dispatch " a good fun " rather the play 2013 " man crisis " duplicate
" a good fun " be pointed to to borrowed, playwrite: Still have other evidence
On August 10, " a good fun " show in the whole nation, box-office success goes tall continuously, had exceeded 500 million at present, fabaceous valve gives a mark 7.4 minutes.
12 days of evening, say at dream Yuan dispatch, 2013, her creation finished a play " man crisis " , film at was being obtained on September 29, 2013 licence. Because admire Huang Bo, after the play is finished, passed a relation to hand the play for a short while Huang Bo square.
But very fast, huang Bo square with " story subject matter and character role suit not quite " for, rejected her invitation. But later a few years, she tries to pass yellow Bo of all sorts of relation go canvassing to go out all the time perform leading role " Qian Jin " , contacted fast of good friend king even, perform a tourist guide with inviting Wang Xun to go out the means of one horn has go about selling an idea.
And having seeinging Huang Bo " a good fun " hind, yu Mengyuan thinks, " a good fun " borrowed drew lessons from " man crisis " the story originality in the play and frame, for avoid tort risk, still undertook having the new-model of specific aim to many details. She still says, collecting actively at present arrange evidential data.
Webpage cut pursues: The likeness that Yu Mengyuan lists spends contrast
Yu Mengyuan was arranged " a good fun " and " man crisis " likeness spends contrast, include place of core originality, main character, story happening and frame to wait.
Look in her, " a good fun " the close-up of story outline, character play with her " man crisis " unusual appearance resembles, the name that acts the leading role repeatedly is duplicate, for instance " Qian Jin " , "Ma Jin " , "Laoshi " , "Laoshi " .
New network reporter browsed in the film 2013 puts on record, in August the film of the last ten-day of a month puts on record in saw really " man crisis " information, one column also fastens playwrite at dream Yuan truly.
New network reporter contacted Yu Mengyuan in, her response says, oneself still have other evidence, but not quite convenient before official put on record put, because of her there taking legal course, she still emphasizes saying, the evidence that did not put more " real hammer into shape " .
" man crisis " the film puts on record
Huang Bo, Xu Zheng, bridge is static: There was this story 2010
To this, " a good fun " piece just express not to grant to respond to, think this action is to be in " touch porcelain " . Current, this Bo Wen of Yu Mengyuan has had the interactive number of tens of thousands of, but the doubt that sufferred many netizens however.
The biggest simple doubtful point depends on, of Huang Bo " a good fun " begin to prepare from 2010, and Yu Mengyuan's play just was created 2013 finish.
At the beginning of August, when accepting media to interview, huang Bo ever expressed, the original inspiration of this film is the film " 2012 " , get rescued from inside doomsday when people when, he is curious however, safety of this group of people escapes to the thing that produces after shelter, was born from this the model with first story.
Webpage cut pursues: Huang Bo ever said, film inspiration originates " 2012 "
This one view also flank got Xu Zheng and bridge confirm staticly. On August 5 " a good fun " Beijing meets on the meeting, xu Zheng ever expressed, he hears Huang Bo wants to take an allegorical motion picture for the first time, be in Beijing blue harbour, it is almost 2009, 2010 when.
Liang Jing also says, huang Bo was heard to say this film 2010, huang Bo ever still offerred to let Guan Hu guide at that time, he acts together with Xu Zheng, Wang Baojiang.
In know on, also a playwrite says, ever was in 2010 " a good fun " playwrite is participated in when newly established, he still basks in the picture that gave play documentation, the photograph shows, play name is " adventurous duck " , time is in September 2010. Nevertheless, this view did not get confirming. The reporter contacted this playwrite, had not gotten a response.
Webpage cut pursues: Netizen comment
How is play of movie and TV limitted borrowed?
" a good fun " related an allegorical story, a company forms a delegation go maritime group is built, encounter the shipwreck however, everybody is stranded on barren island, think the world outside was done not have. In lose regulation, lose a rank, after losing money, they begin to present a human nature 100 condition.
Actually, such movie theme is not new. Be in early 1954, golding of · of British writer Williams ever had written a novel " fly king " , told about a flock of children to be stranded barren island, at first still can get along well, the story of mutual however later carnage. This work ever was adapted twice the film, also have person, " a good fun " the story is aberrant from " fly king " .
So, to play of movie and TV, what is draw lessons from, how to define again borrowed?
Shanghai becomes attorney office Li Weihua's lawyer to say greatly, what copyright law protects is " expression " , is not " thought " , be in so decide when case of tort of drama of similar movie and TV, need to do clear He Wei above all " thought " , he Wei " expression " .
If the author is of pair of other work merely,draw lessons from, the originality that draws lessons from this work for instance, inspirational, stylistic conceive even etc, belong to basically " reasonable draw lessons from " the category of the thought, won't form copyright tort.
And if the author uses other work,clue of specific character setting and figure relationship, story, logic is pushed act etc, fall possibly " expression " protective category, it is reasonable no longer at this moment draw lessons from, and the likelihood is formed adapt.
Adapt other work to must obtain primitive copyright the person's license, form tort namely otherwise.
Nevertheless, to the content of communal material domain, general authority all can be used into exercise, adapt reach create again etc. (Be over)
