The incident of paper of Han rain during springtime that lasts more than two years ends eventually. Reported on August 31 according to daily of science and technology, the reporter learns 31 days from website of government of university of Heibei science and technology late, this school was sent in its website print " the investigation that the school announces group of Han rain during springtime to remove draft paper and processing result " (the following abbreviation " investigation and processing result " ) , " investigation and processing result " say, committee of this school learning establishs board of inquiry, act on " depend on compasses, rigorous standard, be practical and realistic, objective justice lawfully " principle, checked the data of all and primitive test that this paper involves seriously, entrust key laboratory of tripartite state to begin repeat test of test and verify, think the paper that remove draft already had the base that publishs afresh no longer, did not discover group of Han rain during springtime has the subjective case that make a holiday.
" investigation and processing result " still say, after this paper is published, pay of individual housing of Han Chunyu, title, pay all did not produce change. In investigating a process, award of the scientific research project that Han Chunyu asks go back is based on institute of the paper that remove draft to obtain actively, performance, honorary title, society holds a post etc. Concerned respect already cancelled the honorary title that Han Chunyu wins according to the regulation, the scientific research project that ended group of Han rain during springtime to assume called in scientific research funds, called in place of group of Han rain during springtime wins award of performance of school scientific research. Individual society holds a post to be being dealt with by legal process.
?
This is a public awaits long already findings. To findings, still a few netizens indissoluble, since cannot undertake repetition a test, the paper of cancel cannot be published afresh, that makes clear group of Han rain during springtime and did not obtain revolutionary scientific research positive result truly, why does that say Han Chunyu is nonexistent subjective make a holiday? Study from learning angle looks, think oneself have major discovery by accident next compose paper publishs, be not an exemple, normal processing, remove draft namely. This is not involved build dishonourable of false, learning, but need error correction. And the findings that the netizen oppugns the school, announce with the school " investigation and processing result " right " did not discover the subjective circumstance that make a holiday " concern without farther expatiation, this needs the school to make explain, in order to give the public the findings that a be convinced making a person, withstand examines.
Review event of Han rain during springtime, the expression of university of Heibei science and technology, make netizen and bound of science and technology malcontent all the time. On May 2, 2016, han Chunyu is in as newsletter writer " technology of natural · biology " published " NgAgo-gDNA edits a technology for oriented gene " paper. This paper, be known as " Nuo award class " discovery, your " 3 without " associate professor Han Chunyu gains fame. But subsequently, paper experience cannot repeat experimental doubt. Original, face doubt, the blame gain that Han Chunyu uploads plasmid information to plasmid of scientist of a whole world to share is organized -- Addgene, in assist extend with the lecture plasmid, express, "To oneself experimental repeatability still has bravery to enrage very much " . But before long hind, han Chunyu makes a return to doubt no longer, and say according to him the reason is, "The school tells me not to make any responses " . University of Heibei science and technology expresses to media, it is in a month, han Chunyu will adopt proper form to make public test and verify, at the appointed time will authoritative tripartite attest, but the school does not have further action however, be in instead the new student termed begins 2016 on celebration, president Sun Hexu returns this school to mention in the speech: "(the school) have a batch to be on education the serious and responsible, teacher team that is brave in to innovate on scientific research, especially a batch of young teachers like Han Chunyu. " the paper that disregards Han Chunyu completely is encountering doubt. This kind of manner of the school, also make scientific group malcontent, in October 2016, in 13 scientists real name phonates, the lab that states they are in publicly fails to repeat a Han Chunyu and its group to claim to grind after a kind of when give out new gene edits a technology and the appeal starts tripartite to investigate, more scientist stations come out, the university of Heibei science and technology that asks Han Chunyu is in starts investigation. But university of Heibei science and technology still is done not have " receive action " , however all the time when after a year on August 3, 2017, group of Han rain during springtime recalls actively after this paper, university of Heibei science and technology just makes a statement say " already removed draft in view of this paper, the school decides to start pair of Han Chunyu this academic appraise sth through discussion that studies positive result and relevant program. The school decides to start pair of Han Chunyu this academic appraise sth through discussion that studies positive result and relevant program..
?
Announce from the school " investigation and processing result " look, investigation had acknowledged the fact that cannot repeat a test, but to why judging Han Chunyu to do not have subjective make a holiday, lack specific details to prop up however. Before the netizen is based on the manner of the school, afraid school will build a holiday to color to discover by accident (experimental design has drawback, research is not rigorous wait) , be not blankety-blank. The investigation of the school has objective justice only, ability has public letter power. Notable is, going up somehow in view of scholar and school had been interest community, accordingly, in recent years the college makes a holiday in the learning that treats a learned man, borrowed when waiting for academic dishonourable behavior, existence harbors, the problem that color. To this, public opinion appeal should undertake tripartite is investigated, but the author thinks all the time, the university handles academic dishonourable issue of the teacher, still should produce the effect of school learning committee, of course, this needs what academic committee can become independent completely to undertake academic investigation, processing, and rather than undertakes by administrative instruction so called learning is investigated.
Accordingly, cannot repeat point of view from cognizance experiment, incident of Han rain during springtime has ended, the lesson that this one incident leaves university and group of science and technology also is very deep. Because Han Chunyu publishs a paper, with respect to all sorts of honor, project thick as hail, original, his " 3 without " the identity (honor of anonymous school setting, nescient art, without administrative post) , those who refract a scientist of our country youth to begin learning to consider is not easy, but, he is in after obtaining to be thought to major breakthrough delivers positive result, not only honor had, honor, post also came. Resource of this kind of learning configures means, substantial guiding scholar chases after a name to pursue interest, very easy also ecbolic practise fraud. Now, be in " between one night " all sorts of obtained honor, project, award, it is a dream to Han Chunyu, those are not willing to need the young scholar provide timely help that aid financially, and the academic administration that total love perfects also should wake woke.
?
But investigate an aspect from the account that why publishs the paper that cannot repeat a test to Han Chunyu, investigate and did not end. This need school publishs more detailed investigation information, these information are not to involve national secret and commercial secret, should make public completely to the public. The school is in " investigation and processing result " in say, the school will be chance with this, promote scientific spirit further, hold to pair of academic dishonourable behavior " 0 patient " . This must try hard carry out goes, and cannot be an empty talk only.
