Annals of the Three Kingdoms and historical novel of the Three Kingdoms have what distinction after all, the answer is very actually simple, one is official history, one is a novel, originally so simple thing need not take greetings and gifts to the troops move numerous hair post to explain, nevertheless I think those who say is the meaning of this problem backside more.
Everybody reads other novel, do not regard it as at all true, know that is dummy, but why what the person of the world feels historical novel of the Three Kingdoms says is, where is historical incident?
Everybody is mentioned come, be like Kong Ming to borrow east wind, horse of Mu Niu shedding is actual person and event, say to get enraptured. The key is I feel historical novel of the Three Kingdoms is written too lifelike, and follow official history to go, can reach the state of this kind of mix the false with the genuine so. Because annals of past the Three Kingdoms is too abstruse, circulate only so at brownstone advanced intellectual in, if do not have historical novel of the Three Kingdoms, bewitch young is afraid those who do obeisance to is not to close now fair, however other expression Buddha.
More god-given is, inside accumulate containing a lot of ruse, for example plan of the ruse of inflicting an injury on oneself to win the confidence of the enemy, interlink plan, badger game, sow distrust or dissension among one's enemies is waited a moment. In those days Qing Bing is entered close those who lean is historical novel of a the Three Kingdoms, chairman Mao is in warlike time, what taking also is historical novel of the Three Kingdoms, those who see its reference value is tall! Japanese studies now China, also be from the the Three Kingdoms historical novel begins. Authority is very much had appreciated mark of glorious the Three Kingdoms, to the assurance of the the Three Kingdoms I feel more accurate than a lot of Chinese, let ~~~ of synthetic perspiration colour really.
Nevertheless historical novel is historical novel after all, not be official history, we also do not want too superstitious. So the thing inside annals of the Three Kingdoms should be true, I can tell everybody, also not be completely. Everybody must not too superstitious the thing that writes above history, because these are by person basis the data writes its accuracy that come out,achieve impossibly 100% , if history is completely correct, that even what does the historian do? The historian analyses the validity of historical record from inside the data namely, correct the history and research history.
For example too history company horse change is malcontent to Qin Shi king, write his mother into a coquettish hooter, not objective. Now also act according to these descriptions above TV, everybody sees this also do not feel what, because of Qin Shi king coquettish of his mother wind has had nothing to do difficulties.
About peach garden 3 knots justice -- " annals of the Three Kingdoms " go up to did not close at Liu Bei, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei's 3 people the account of knot justice, just say their favour is like brother; Cloth of Lv of 3 flower battle -- a surname Zan did not attend denounce Dong Lian alliance, so Liu, close, Zhang San's person also have not attends, also won't tiger prison closes cloth of Lv of 3 flower battle;
About Guan Yu's saga:
Hua Xiong of lukewarm wine behead -- this is Jiang Dongmeng Hu Sunjian is;
Helmet of Xuzhou kill car -- this is Liu Bei place to be;
Behead colour fine, kill article is ugly -- historicity of behead Yan Liang, kill article is ugly is what Cao Cao is however.
Patience, behead 6 will -- after Guan Yu leaves Cao Cao, fall to have toward Liu of the go to somewhere for shelter austral you from Xu Changna directly, did not produce patience, behead 6 will thing; Cai of ancient city behead is in relief -- this Yi Nailiu is fully;
Hua Rong puts Cao -- what in Hua Rong path intercept Cao holds is Liu Bei, but he goes late, be run by Cao Cao so.
Battle Changsha -- chaste tree Na Sijun is asked for south Liu Bei, 4 county defend keep watch and fall, huang Zhong follows Changsha viceregal Han Xuan falls together, guan Yu did not fight with Huang Zhong happening.
Short-hilted broadsword is gone to meeting -- take the branch for the root namely at all, solid it is Lu Su short-hilted broadsword to meet Guan Yu, "Short-hilted broadsword " the admire knife that is sergeant;
Water wides 7 army -- this is natural and man-made disaster, impersonal seek;
The cure that blow bone is hurt -- right now Hua Tuo had died two years, because this is not Hua Tuo place to be, it is what general surgeon is only it seems that;
Refus of wheat city stern falls -- Sun Quan makes person induce to capitulate, close a pretend to surrender, banners and flags is inserted in empty of on top of the city wall, from the backtrack that fasten the door, be calculated by Lv Meng, on the way cut kills.
As to, the Lv that seek an order is unconscious, jade spring make its presence or power felt, need not saying to also know is fictitiousing zero, make feudal fetish in disorder. . Do not say more.
Make a comprehensive view " historical novel of the Three Kingdoms " Guan Yu's feat, also with respect to behead Yan Liang is a historical fact, other all be graft one twig on another or fiction.
Zhu Geliang
If resort to arms is magical -- the Zhu Geliang on the history is good at municipal processing, resort to arms is not its director, can pass below the fact explains:
Rich of baked wheaten cake looks at slope -- this is Liu Bei place to be, happen in build install 7 years, and build install 12 years, zhu Geliang just gives mountain.
Careless boat borrows an arrow -- this is place of father and son of Sun Jian, Sun Quan to be, happen in respectively cross river the battle that beats Liubiao and immerse beard;
Borrow east wind -- solstitial time, have southeast wind more, this is Cao Cao's natural disaster, blame is factitious;
The battle of Chibi -- only Zhi Jisun counterpoises is a historical fact,
3 gas Zhou Yu -- two years when the war end from Chibi dies of illness to Zhou Yu, zhu Geliang is being taken in 0 hill do logistics to work, had met without He Zhouyu at all.
After dying of illness as to Zhou Yu, the delegate that Sichuan country condoles is Pang Tong, is not Zhu Geliang;
Ask for Chinese in -- proof Chinese in the front commander in chief when is Liu Bei, zhu Geliang stays behind to do logistics to work;
7 capture Meng Huo -- the thing that there is Zhu Geliang Nazheng truly on the history, also truly the first month catchs its person.
But 7 capture Meng Huo " annals of the Three Kingdoms " on without account.
In Sichuan the country holds the post of the assist in drive history after Meng Huo, it is civilian be not fierce general;
6 Qi Shan -- Zhuge shines a cut down Wei Wu second, arrived with the 4th for the first time only Qi Shan;
Presenting a bold front to conceal a weak defence -- Zhu Geliang is stationed in at that time today Shaanxi installs health county, si Mayi collect today Henan Nanyang, such distant, why to talk about presenting a bold front to conceal a weak defence?
" hind give a person of exemplary virtue " -- be later generations do, be not Zhu Geliang place to make;
Mu Niu sheds a horse -- actually, mu Niu is wheelbarrow, shedding a horse is today very common four-wheel small pull a cart. Say Mu Niu is four-wheeler, shedding a horse is the boat with a kind of more pointed head;
Dead all arrowroot are frightened run vivid Zhong Da -- have this matter truly, but be not Zhu Geliang plan of involuntary discharge of urine, however Si Mayi is guilty;
Make a comprehensive view " historical novel of the Three Kingdoms " Zhu Geliang's achievement, only ask ab. to take up a resposible post repeatedly is a historical fact, other all be graft one twig on another or fiction. But the great achievement that we cannot deny Zhuge shines because of this, zhu Geliang is the greatest politician on Chinese history and militarist.
Xu Shu enters Cao Ying -- Cao Cao Nazheng, liu Bei and Zhu Geliang, Xu Shu south escape, in chaos army, xu mother is captured, then Xu Shu leaves Liu Bei, enter Cao Ying. See and do or attributed to a wrong author without Cao plan with Xu Shu ' trot along on horseback Jian all arrowroot ' thing.
Zhang Song displays a map -- Liu Bei enters Sichuan, hook in law with Zhang Song, enquire the circumstance such as the money of military forces food in Sichuan, then Zhang Song scale " Xi Shu relief map " ; And the map is displayed before be not phoenix cheeper to die.
Vacate about the horse -- Ma Teng and Dong Zhuo is one passerby horse, not only did not attend denounce Dong Lian alliance, and still help Chang'an of Dong Zhuo guard. What vacate as to the horse is dead, be not Ma Tengmou to put to death Cao Cao is killed, the arms since Ma Chao revenges, however the arms since Ma Chao turns over Cao, so Ma Teng is killed. It is the seeing of a person who achieves high position by unscrupulous scheming that to lend this depict Cao holds in Luoguan it is thus clear that.
Saying from the weapon: Knife of month of green dragon cease -- Guan Yu's Bing Ren is pike, actually Lv Bu's Bing Ren also is pike, zhang Fei's Bing Ren is not a unit of length 8 snakes lance, however general lance.
