The paper photograph that Li Feng uncle published 2018 is on, leave the paper picture that published 2016 for Sun Yubing, both exactly like. Interview an object to offer a plan
Many college pole teachs office staff to be pointed to individually " collective learning makes a holiday " be related caused attention recently. University of electric power of afterwards China north makes known his position " take this matter seriously and give investigation " hind, institute of Xiamen technical institute, yellow hill accepted the response when insurgent news is interviewed on April 15, already noticed relevant public feelings, "Investigating " .
Insurgent news reported on April 14, dedicated the For Better Science of foreign language website that learns art dishonourable scandal at the report is close daily newspaper article, showed drag in much person one case " doubt is like a paper to make a holiday " incident, involve science of environment of environment of university of China north electric power and Sun Yubing of engineering courtyard professor, Xiamen technical institute and engineering courtyard test master institute of Huang Xiaoming and associate professor Pan Min, yellow hill.
Reports of afore-mentioned For Better Science are published before long, netizen of a few China is its interpreter Chinese. "This article disclosed the data that exists between these scientific research groups to make false, one plan a gleam of is multi-purpose, multi-purpose and cite to bring dosage in order to rise to wait for a problem each other. " among them Zhang Cheng of a translator (alias) tell insurgent news, oneself and two friends " specially spent a few days of time to seek a paper textual " , checked afore-mentioned article accuracy.
According to the clue that provides in report of For Better Science of foreign language website, the person such as Zhang Cheng discovers, a when Pan Min published 2018 about " material science " paper, be suspected of " common " Sun Yubing published the data in the paper 2015; And approaching time paragraph inside, in 3 papers that 3 people publish Yao Ting, Sun Yubing and yellow Xiao Ming severally " appeared to study data identically " ; Infra-red spectrogram and Sun Yubing of the same age publish a paper that Yao Ting published 2016 the infra-red and spectral data in the paper " completely consistent " ; The data in the paper that the place in a paper that Li Feng uncle published 2018 uses data chart and Sun Yubing to was published 2016 pursues also just the same; Another papers that Li Feng uncle published 2018 are suspected of data making a holiday, and its are mid the data in dividing data to also published a paper 2017 with Sun Yubing is same, although there also is Sun Yubing in this article author, but the research data of two papers is different, shared a result however.
Make public information to show, pan Min, Huang Xiaoming holds a post Xiamen technical institute, and be in early 2006 ～ 2009, two people are in institute of project of environment of Hefei industry university to read a Master together. Of coincidence is, 2004 ～ between 2007, sun Yubing ever also was in institute of project of environment of Hefei industry university to read a Master, after this reads aloud a doctor 3 years in this school.
In addition, afore-mentioned papers that Yao Ting published 2016, newsletter writer is Li Feng uncle namely, and Li Feng uncle also had had a paper to cooperate with Sun Yubing 2018. In the meantime, 3 people exist " cite each other the paper brings dosage with raising a paper " problem. For instance, in 51 bibliographical reference in a paper that Yao Ting published 2016, 27 cited Sun Yubing's paper, in 44 bibliographical reference in another paper, 26 cited Sun Yubing paper.
Zhang Cheng says, sun Yubing " be suspected of paper data making a holiday not only, and share oneself data others, the data reappearance paper that lets others use his " .
Be aimed at afore-mentioned circumstances, party committee of university of China north electric power publicizes ministry undersecretary Wu Suhua to responded to insurgent news to say on April 12: "Our school values this thing very much, in be being investigated at present, the expert of academic committee is in arraign, because this involves the cognizance of paper, the likelihood still has a process. If have a result, we are met release in open platform for a short while. We are met release in open platform for a short while..
On April 15 afternoon, a staff member weighs department of propaganda of Party committee of Xiamen technical institute, "Before two days had noticed the net is photogenic pass information, also saw insurgent news yesterday (14 days) report " . "The school takes this second incident seriously very much, we had enjoined relevant section is being investigated, the section that concerns with academic standard can be involved, after we have preliminary result, can announce particular case. " this staff member says.
With day, party committee of yellow hill academy publicizes a response of a staff member, noticed the net is photogenic close public feelings, investigating at present. "The school is considering to treat an opinion, still cannot make conclusions now. This should come according to the program, sign up for academic committee to unite first have academic identification, discuss a decision to treat an opinion by school leadership again. " this staff member says, if the circumstance is belonged to solid, should meet make castigatory processing. "The school also has the processing idea that is aimed at academic dishonourable behavior. "The school also has the processing idea that is aimed at academic dishonourable behavior..
