Last year on June 9, the Xiaoli that just takes an examination of an university takes K1301 second train (Beijing stands to Tianjin station) , smelled inside railroad car thorn snuff flavour. Although the passenger is,smoke in smoking area, but whole railroad car is smoke flavour. City railroad bureau accuses square Harbin of operation of Xiaoli general train court. This case is called " home is public smokeless lawsuit the first case " .
On June 25, 2018 afternoon, this case carries forensic first instance to adjudge in Beijing railroad, the behavior that the court thinks Harbin railroad bureau sets smoking area on train breaks the law, adjudicate Harbin railroad bureau cancels smoking area to remove smoking set on second train of 30 days of immanent K1301.
Last year in December, this case first instance is sessional. In the front courtyard careful at that time, harbin breaths out railroad bureau to say, railroad does not make break a promise, also do not undertake responsibility of breach of contract. According to ticket, the accused already accuser on time service destination, did not cause body unwell consequence already, also do not have the proof of be in hospital of accuser, explain the accused had fulfilled relevant obligation, and area of smoking of the accused setting is not lawbreaking prohibit sexual regulation, setting smoking area accords with national condition, accord with actual.
The court thinks, setting smoking area brings about diminution of quality of the environment inside the car necessarily, although the setting is in ventilated place, but smoke still can wave come loose train is other place. In addition, train is whole vehicle ban on opium-smoking and the opium trade, the action that sets smoking area breaks the law, the court requests to give to Xiaoli's lawsuit support, bureau of adjudicative Harbin railroad cancels smoking area to remove smoking set on the train, but be opposite considering demolished cost and likelihood the influence of train, bureau of railroad of forensic proposal Harbin is right smoking set and smoking area undertake keep out.
