All logistic metropolises of bubble period are after bubble is undone by card bogus, the look back on after a few years can feel he is how foolish with ignorance. Nevertheless, relatively other country, although Japanese ending is agonized, but still not be disaster, because be in 1990 when, japan already overseas is reconstructive an abroad Japan offers blood for oneself. Do we have so good lot?
96 the beginning of the year, the first day when go to Japan, the neighbour that lives in a building needs a cane to carrying tea with good make tea to come to my room with tea tray, this may be he is particular " the first time meet, each other are known " expressive means. The language communicates the obstacle that go up also can be simple only ten minutes " greet " , beard cane gave me the telephone call in his room, let me tell the telephone call that the family member can pass him and me connection.
In the time of nearly two months that did not hold a phone in me, go receiving a telephone call a few times over there beard cane, receive a telephone call every time I take bit of thing to was thanked in the past. Come so, every week is smoked 1, 2 hours sit to chatted to become a kind of custom a little.
Need a cane 48 years old, it is an administrator that is engaged in commercial establishment management, every monthly wages 40 much yen. I am very strange at that time, his salary does not calculate low, it is celibate, why can you still live in hire of such a month to have 30 thousand much yen, one house only (12 ㎡) one hutch (4 ㎡) defend (3 ㎡) , are 5 people operable in the building of a bathroom?
Beard cane to me this kind of doubt shows special understanding, he tells me to say, be in Japan 88 years of economic bubble period, he spent 60 million yen to buy a 2 layer villa. This villatic price has fallen to 30 million yen now. He has rented villa went out. He lives such house is to save next Qian Laihe's villatic hire to close together to return the loan of the bank now. Loan can be paid off when waiting for him 65 years old, go out house guaranty to get the money of attend upon a dying relative of provide for the aged again next. Nevertheless, his wife does not want and he lives together such house, divorced.
97 years, the doctoral student Xiaodong that does metallic stuff research was known after entering university courtyard (Chinese) , one day he drives take me to pick persimmon to a very desolate place. I ask him why the persimmon here can be picked casually, he says, this is the land that his adviser buys in bubble economy period, press the development program of that period, here should be OK delimit Tokyo opens the range that encircles frequently, very regretful, you look now, so desolate still, the professor head that also only this does a metal to consider just so " hard " , ability can believe Tokyo circle can enlarge here.
Small Dong You says: The test is done in lab when, teach be favored with of total be favored with of have nothing to do this ground, look this ground lets him hold out irritated heart. The professor is in 89 years with 50 thousand yen / ㎡ bought this land, altogether is 150 million yen. If someone goes 1 now,the professor says 100 million, he sells. 93 years somebody bids 25 thousand yen / ㎡, the professor is hated to part with, now, 20 thousand cannot find buyer. Planted these persimmon trees still do not have time to attend, we pick persimmon to eat to help him namely to this.
I notice to see this ground, besides tree of a few persimmon, other is barren grass. The glad interest that comes at that time air one most.
Shop optional location is done in 2 years later when investigation transient here, the feeling still is the old pattern previously. I was checked to local public library by the way, this ground belongs to city market to change adjust area, the land inside this kind of area belongs to construction not completely to use the land, if want melt into construction to use the land, local government sector must invest the infrastructure construction such as the way that has breadth of 5.2 meters of catchment, liquid gas, above.
The professor buys the land here, it is the urban progress speed that is based on bubble economy period probably, otherwise a few years, the government sector can invest a construction of here melt into to use the land. If be like professor place to expect really, price should rise at least 100 thousand 1 smooth rice, in if changed construction,using the land again business the ground, 300 thousand / ㎡ is completely likely also. Very regrettablly, teach this " ante " do not have detain to be opposite.
99 years, plain Lai was known in inaugural company, he and I like mountain-climbing, I joined their mountain-climbing club, the morning that is on Saturday commonly assembled below hill at 6 o'clock, after much at 10 o'clock mountain-climbing ends, bathe to hot spring come home.
Once 3 rest repeatedly, the club organizes solar mountain-climbing, sunlight is Japan's famous travel sightseeing ground, many members took his family or friend.
After we come down from hill, the person that did not go mountaineering had waited in hot spring hotel, this has the wife of plain Lai among them, plain Lai introduces me to her, invite I and them to have dinner together. Since the wife that saw plain Lai, when I see plain Lai again, always feel he is a very mysterious figure.
Plain Lai already 50 years old, but it is a very common engineer in the company only, but his wife grows beautiful and bearing of the way one speaks or what he says is completely not only is figure of a house. In sunlight, what the wife of plain Lai wears is kimono, when Japanese woman wears kimono walk pose, sitting position, look is to have cultured etc, the person outfit that had not gotten specialized training does not come out. Those who accept this kind of training is commonly " everybody " girl, perhaps prepare to become " everybody daughter-in-law " the student of woman homemaking university. In university courtyard I had encountered the graduate student that comes from woman homemaking university, under photograph comparing, the wife of plain Lai can do these " everybody daughter-in-law " teacher.
The time that has mountain-climbing with Chuanlaiyi is more, want to know he is a what person after all the more, but inconvenience asks directly, concern asks bad to guard a pass likely still the department does deadlocked.
Spent period of time, organic meeting and col go together construction site, he comes to this company already 9 years, I and his private concern is pretty good, on the road with respect to us two people, this is an opportunity, I say: "The wife of plain Lai saw in sunlight, the look that she wears kimono and I see at ordinary times its her person is really different, glamour is very, it is certainly " everybody " one's previous experience " , col says: "Do not know, nevertheless, the president can be before plain Lai, the wife is certain wrong not " , when I ask why plain Lai became a common staff member again, see col reply not quite gladly, I am bad also to ask again.
Time grew, from inside a few words of people, had a basic knowledge to plain Lai. Plain Lai is versed in this company that I assume office comes after old finish school from Tokyo manage, did not become the core technology personnel of the company to 40 years old, taste in Tokyo all the time plain, company headquarters works. Very big to company development contribution, base pay is close 1 million yen.
85 years, namely bubble economy forms initial stage, plain Lai abdication established a residence designs a plant. Start to develop very successful, arrive 88 years, plain Lai borrows money not only enlarged scale of production, the one and other places that is in Tokyo at the same time still bought the high-grade boarding house of a nearly 200 million yen.
Cannot think of, after 90 years, phasic take a sudden turn and become worse rapidly, the order of the factory is almost 0. The apartment guaranty of 100 million 2 ten million Tokyo gave plain Lai the bank, the hope spends difficulty, keep a plant. Still can go bankrupt finally in 97 years. The high level of this company reads aloud the ability of plain Lai and old friendship to let him return a company again again, nevertheless headquarters is to answer did not go, salary hears of have 400 thousand only.
Because be beside oneself, often hear bubble economy period to concern buy the ground, thing that buys a house, begin to consider: A of Japan ordinary common people says a word to want to pass from brain casually, do the thing that does not know to won't be done, so, why can price of Japanese price, house rise? Be what reason lets them be certain price of price, house still can rise? Their salary is not high, pay ability what house price had exceeded them normally, the living standard that why can you still lower other respect will buy the land, buy a house?
Why can house price of Japan rise? Many people consider as result from September 1985 " square agreement " . so can the agreement of exchange rate of a concerned money bring about Japanese insanity does loan buy a house? If doesn't common people have money bank to by what loan give you? By what is Japanese common people certain price of price, house still can rise again? Say so, "Square agreement " at best can say only is " fuse " , so " bomb " be how form? That is to say does the money buying a house of Japanese common people come from He Fang? To these doubt, 2000 the company forgets annual meeting to go up, I got a result.
By 2000, the company delivers premium eventually, had not delivered premium 3 years continuously. The company is to hope to do good person after all probably, of the end of the year forget annual meeting also appears personally by the company will organize, this and before a few years of employees are initiative of the organization forget annual meeting photograph is compared, class is high also many.
On the weekend arrived at 6 o'clock afternoon at 9 o'clock, everybody drank the first wine that forgets annual meeting, will to card pull OK to include a house then. Drinks drunkly Ji Tian asks I had come to this kind of place.
I say: "Had come, but can do not have so high-grade " , auspicious Tian Yiting bursts out laughing: "This cultivate land also just calculates high-grade, foamy moment, of the company forget annual meeting is to want silver go " .
"Be, forget annual meeting can arrive silver-colored, our company is too rich " ,
"It is our company not just, the company of complete Japan is same, the silver at that time the person is completely suffer from, should shift to an earlier date at least half an year books ability to have place " ,
"Be too good really, how was I caught up with, really regretful, how to meet at a draught stagnant? How to meet at a draught stagnant??
"This you want blamed word, you blame China, we were given to cheat by China " ,
Ji Tian's answer lets me do not have reaction to come over at that time, think Ji Tian is malty.
At this moment, col been pullinging voice to leave sang, ji Tian also begins busy move to tick off the smell that him add likes with all sorts of wine on the desk. Although be happy life, ji Tian should drown worried in dring again probably, he and the case that need a cane are very similar, what what differ is beard cane what buy when bubble is villatic, what Ji Tian buys is the apartment of Tokyo, two people are living now similar house.
In university courtyard when the prosperous picture that often listens to Xiaodong to mention period of Japanese bubble economy. Xiaodong is the Japan that comes 90 years, he says: When he just came, receive the car that the student studying abroad goes to working everyday to the school, average 2 hours time, salary of 1 hour is commonly 1200, 1500 yen, some are OK still that day settle accounts, earning money is too easy really, and very different now.
Because labour force is lacked badly, japanese government is mixed to a lot of South America other the stowaway of a few countries, and the person that visa expires not to go back to the motherland also is to open an eye to close a key point. Bubble economy breaks down meeting, the management board of Japan that enter a country just begins to drive these people.
Nevertheless, as to why can Japan flourish so at that time, everybody feels original is such, few also in the student studying abroad comment these problems, won't think what this and China have to concern more.
Since the bubble that forgets to Ji Tian listens to say Japan on annual meeting because,prosperity is China, no matter be drunk word, I still want to do clear.
When mountaineering, I ask plain Lai, what do Japanese bubble economy and China have to concern?
Plain Lai says: "After China is opened, japanese electric equipment, car begins large quantities of quantities to export China, the Japanese that has gone to China says, photograph comparing of China and Japan differs 30 years at least, china has 1.2 billion person, if we give China to make a thing, achieve Japan present level must want to build how many years then. So a lot of Japanese are certain there is year of unripe Japan economy to be able to flourish all the time in his " .
"As expected such, remember my neighbour to buy washing machine of double crock of a Toshiba, queued up early greatly at 4 o'clock " a few things that the word of plain Lai allowed me to remember Chinese reforming and opening is earlier. Our country still waits the product line of this kind of home appliance a moment without color television, videocorder, freezer, washing machine at that time, no matter the Japanese electric equipment on the market is illegal smuggling goods or lawful import, want the shop of out Japan finally. This says to day this Chinese market is too big really originally.
I say then: "Most propbably at that time, everybody's income is very regular tall " .
"Be! The most stagnant company, the salary that annual premium also has half an year " .
"Make so much money, also can buy the ground to buy a house only probably " .
"Be! Annual premium still can buy a room to mortgage, who can think of to be able to produce the thing later " .
Japan is in 85 years before, residential market is not the market that commercializes completely, what the family of firewood of average worker worker of 80% above lives is barracks of public round house, county, city barracks, company wait housing of sex of this kind of commonweal a moment curtilage. In this among them, the Japanese residence state-owned group that Japanese government created 1955 is the person that the biggest house is offerred.
Last centuries 70 time end, japanese car, home appliance makes a technology not only can with Euramerican contend, some had been in international lead position, the product begins a large number of exit abroad. 1981, "Japanese house industry is round " more the name is " state-owned group of reorganize and outfit of the residence, city " , working core by offer residential transition to be living infrastructure of construction and improved city directly.
The working transition of Japanese residence state-owned group is Japanese government hopes to lend Japanese product a large number of exit abroad the opportunity that brings prosperity to Japanese economy, for the preparation that residential commercialization makes, satisfy requirement of domestic house individuation through residential commercialization, raise the living requirement of Japanese countryman from this.
85 years " square agreement " let the money in Japanese pocket increase at a draught at least 20% , make Japanese government begin to carry out residential commercialization in the round quickly, the commercial bank begins to buy a room to extend for the dweller in great quantities loan, loan interest rate is reduced considerably. House price of Japan also began to be climbed at high speed from this litre.
In Japanese economy one flourishs, house price arrived 90 years in ceaseless Pansheng, japan each are big the bank balks not only the loan that buy a house, raise interest rate of customary the loan that buy a house considerably. Begin 92 years to impose land tax (collect the forehead to spend for belongings successive duty assesses a value 0.3% ) .
Why should Japanese government publish such economic policy? Why did the prosperous picture of the other industry such as Japanese car, home appliance disappear suddenly also? Do this mean Japanese economy to begin to enter from this " lair " ? How economy of look upon Japan " blank " 10 years?
Upsurge all the way in house price, share price, 90 years when Japanese economy booms one piece on March 27, japanese bank came on stage " the announcement that controls praedial financing gross " , this one " announcement " by what call Japanese bubble economy to break down later " draw well is nodded " , house price, share price turns around drop.
In those days in August, japanese bank goes to the attune on interest rate of short term loan again 6% . Have more very is 92 years big Tibet province published land tax again, let already the praedial course of study of cannot recover after a setback is one disaster after another more, course of study of high-end general merchandise is located in a sector of an area with the most bustling town because of its inn location, annual 20% what the land tax of 0.3% exceeds merchandise profit actually, the land tax inhibition to house price force sees one spot.
Why should Japanese government publish such financial policy, it is they did not think of these policy to be able to bring about building city, stock market to drop greatly. So, had begun 92 years when steep fall in building city, stock market, why does big Tibet province publish land tax even, let a bit of praedial course of study cannot get the opportunity that breath?
Many people think: A few years after 90 years, the economic policy of Japanese government in succession pushs Japanese economy cannot of extricate oneself " lair " , let whole Japan economy appear " blank " 10 years (90 years of metaphase - 2000) .
Say well and truly: Not be policy of 90 years has a problem, however 85 years Japan opens praedial market in the round, send a hope to pass praedial the policy that will let Japanese economy continue to maintain high speed to develop has a problem. 85 years when open in the round in praedial market - 89 years, the saw 85 years place makes mistake of this one policy seriousness that the change of Japan and world lets Japanese government is clear. 90 years the following policy is urgent to what what make a mistake 85 years nevertheless correct.
Let me pay close attention to a lot of exposition and argumentation of economy of concerned Japan bubble, approbate this kind of judgment above, still must chat from of He Jitian speak of.
Go together with Ji Tian every time construction site, he is met with " early in the morning, drank a little bit " for excuse, lie to see caricature on board. This, the car on him sat to drive on, I feel quite strange, guess he has what thing certainly. Still be really, before long he left Gang Jindong capital high speed, circle on narrow inside Tokyo urban district path will be circled, be not what often be familiar with to park the car by a 30 multilayer apartment, let me wait for him a bit.
I get off in all around turn, consider in the heart: This may be the boarding house that Ji Tian buys, the house of this kind of a sector of an area won't be cheap, look Ji Tian delivered many premium really in bubble period.
Passed ten minutes, ji Tian come back to say to me: "Come here I with respect to be perturbed, safety first, requested " . He this is to plan to lie again on the side see caricature, he is very informal, with him conversation also goes continuously quite continuously.
I drive to ask him at the same time at the same time: "Is this the boarding house that you buy? " " be. " " here is the residence with pretty good Tokyo really special ground, very close from subway station and very quiet still. " auspicious Tian Yiting is very complacent: "That of course, handed in deposit to come at that time 20 times the person of ballot is total a cycle of songs in a traditional opera, " " you are really enough lucky. " " lucky do not talk to go up, I do not have ballot, our company is one of investor of this apartment. " I am startled a bit really: "How, does our company also invest in bubble period praedial? " " it what this has is strange that what this has, if not be all trades and professions,invest praedial, how is praedial bubble met so big. " " look it is good that you should play lot, perhaps do not smoke on, wait for a circumstance two years disparate. " " impossible, do not buy get on this building dish, buy other building even dish, anyhow, it is that year resolved must buy. " " look, your bubble irritated anxiety is fated. " " ha, yes, the signal that makes me vexed is not blast off from this building come over, blast off in wherefrom ridgepole building namely come over, anyhow, this kind of trouble is to want some certainly. " " ha, be in Japan, have you this kind of confused person is too much, should the person that choose can let everybody remove trouble becomes a prime minister chancellery. " " my dead day of that absurd birthday that is this premier minister. " " ha, since you live all one's life in the boarding house that does not buy into oneself, why to sell? " " joking, I was handed in head pay, return those who paid 10 years to mortgage, how can you sell? " " when if house price just began,dropping, you sell, also won't have present trouble. " " be! But I am not a god, who can think of bubble had died 10 years, house price not only do not go up, still be in drop all the time. " " when bubble just died, also person of it doesn't matter is anxious sell a house, everybody believes house price still has the possibility that rise. " " be, it is at least those who be certain house price won't drop is so fierce. " " since such, should also have a reason that believes house price won't drop? " Ji Tian wanted to say: "Believed ground is very much, everybody also has his idea, but still basically be the commonsensible sex judgement with general basis. Japanese economy basically is support exit, yen appreciates to be formed to product exit hamper badly, the government should add hair money to make yen devalues for certain, if gain hair currency every year continuously, on the exchange rate level that restores to convert a dollar to original yen, house price won't fall. " " why doesn't that gain hair currency? " " right! Went 10 years, price of price, house drops all the time, praedial value of Japan with annual the speed of 100 million, 100 million decreases, this premier minister changed several, a bit also cannot see the government wants to add the meaning that sends a money, do really do not know this side what thinking in blamed brain. " " since the government insists not to add hair money to also should have do not gain the ground of hair, how do you look? " " this I can not know, this is money! ! ! Everybody can look understanding is not money. " " look, auspicious cropland mulberry should disencumber to be able to wait for next answering to saw not clear bubble come only. " auspicious cropland deep sigh: "Had impossibly again, come again bubble, japanese connects commissariat be unable to get something to eat. " " Japanese industry so develop, can import food. " " joking, didn't that Japan become the slave of agricultural country? " " according to you so say, is because,the government defeats landed bubble disclose hastily also farming ground? " " not be all certainly, but this affirmation is a very main reason, the landlord of these countries most be fed up with, foamy moment, of like a swarm of bees should be in farming ground upper cover house, do this differ to let everybody do not have commissariat to eat then. " " illuminate this for, if from farming ground this angle looks, the government does not gain hair currency also is reasonable. " " right! Also should warn a warning this side landlord, must not make the decision of farm. But let me,also have bad luck accordingly together. But let me,also have bad luck accordingly together..
Since after listening to Ji Tian to say this word, because policy of Japanese government banking is undeserved,to 90 years building city, stock market steeps fall is the view that creates emerged suspicion, I begin to believe Japanese government flings caution to the winds bubble of disclose broken estate is purposeful, I hope to get a result. Place comes later, concern the news of this respect, begin to remember things alertly quite all the time.
Estate has bubble is with entity economy is consult content, estate value broke away from hypostatic economy prop up be considered as bubble.
But, estate bubble can break down certainly, the way that perhaps says estate bubble must steep fall with house price will end, this is finding a basis on economics. Broke away from the estate bubble that hypostatic economy props up to must be defeated by disclose? The answer also is not certain.
The point of view that compares the main trend in the Japanese academia that experienced estate bubble to break down is: Estate bubble needs to be defeated by disclose basically be decided by social element. So, why does Japan want disclose to defeat bubble?
Enter last centuries 80 time, the entrance door that accompanies China is open, the Japanese economy that flourishs continuously all the time also entered period of at the height of power and splendour.
But, china reachs the put into production of the product line such as the color television of other developing country, freezer, let what Japanese government is clear about see, the low price of the developing country very be about to form a deathblow to Japanese manufacturing industry. Before simple price competition, japan has blind lane only. The industry with Japanese advanced support makes the technology, way that drives Japanese economy prosperity through product of industry of supplied materials treatment, export, had seen an end.
The dilemma that Japanese place faces realized in Japanese government, but and had not found when answering a method, "Square agreement " was to give Japanese pawn one club more. Make the manufacturing industry that brings prosperity to Japanese economy, was immersed in want the low case make a stand against with the developing country already, should bear again yen appreciates the condition of be in a dilemma of weigh. Should maintain Japanese economy to continue high speed grows, must seek new economic point of growth.
Be praedial! Let Japanese had roused bosomy pocket to invest praedial, it is to let Japanese economy solve undoubtedly " an extremely urgency " effective passageway. The praedial market that open commercializes, it is a the biggest profit to the landlord of Japanese country good, be in office at that time party (from civilian party) the biggest proponent is core with the landlord namely farming assist.
85 years September " square agreement " after signing, had worried about the Japanese countryman that yen devalues originally, to the praedial favourable policy with a lot of government, can let as finding soft the port that keeps a cost, invest a good deal of capital praedial market.
The capital when your writing swarms into praedial market and immobilize produces the moment that begins to appreciate, a Pandora's box -- retain demand was opened. Praedial attribute of Japan began sadly change, change direction by use demand retain demand, consequence also canned be imagined. Add the money that is as high as 2 digit 86 years to increase hair amount again, arrived 87 years, in majority Japanese in the eye, land had become the asset that is worth to retain most.
Face such big market demand, japan each are big the bank spread out intense contention to land. Normally the circumstance falls, the bank mortgages to land financing is to press land to evaluate a value 70% borrow piece, hokkaido develop is worth a bank with 120% offer financing, this shows land had become golden mine in bank eye.
As Japan the quickness of praedial price is climbed litre, cast to praedial capital increasing also, praedial development project of the whole nation a be better than big, whole Japan " a scene of prosperity " , connect silver it is OK that highest grade red-light district also became Everyman the place of patronage.
But another, building the 2nd east renown high speed upsurges because of price, plan to be hard to advance. The management state of Japanese road state-owned group is exceeding and exasperate. Each local public investment construction also upsurges because of price and difficult and heavy.
88 years, the leading sheep that the profit of high specified number that praedial profession persists several years lets abundant cropland car, Fuji weigh labour, day to establish electric machinery to wait these Japanese substance economy a moment also is pressed again be unable to bear, begin to enter praedial line of business in a large-scale.
The future that praedial high speed developed to affect Japanese economy already badly develops way. Accordingly, the debate that how should develop around Japan is more and more intense. If induce these controversies, the controversy basically is spread out around 3 respects:
1, the basic national policy that whether promotes the development of praedial course of study to accord with Japan? 2, the develops to whether you can maintain Japanese economy abidance of praedial course of study flourishs? 3, if to above the answer of two problems is " NO " , so what kind of economy mode more agree with Japan?
Japanese bubble economy broke down 1990, apparently looking is the economic policy be caused by with Japanese a chain of government, its policy essence is a when Japanese government argues to above clear answer.
After World War II, japan has two to be called changeless basic national policy, one is basic farm system, one is science and technology the strategy that allow a country.
So called basic farm is made even if basic farm of Japan retains quantity must the commissariat autarky that can satisfy Japan, cannot go up in grain issue be enslaved to be enslaved to his country. The abidance of praedial development is rising, direct menace went to Japan of basic farm retain quantity.
So-called science and technology allows a country the strategy, it is hind of World War II, japanese government has been a ravages of war to, 100 useless wait for the Japan that promote to answer to had done long demonstration to what direction development. Ever thought Holand of follow the lead of is become for a time Asia and Euramerican the commerce distribution centre between. But consideration Japan and Holand differ in the respect such as population amount and located and external environment very far, the conception of commerce distribution centre is denied thoroughly, final decision walks along industrial science and technology to start national way.
Support is praedial will help the development that moves Japanese economy, was to had deviated from apparently very industrial science and technology allows a country this changeless national policy.
Japan is the state that a resource counts an import badly. Want to get resource, japan must want the goods that with him the country needs to have trade. If cast to praedial capital increasing, structure of Japanese whole industry and obtain employment structure can tilt to praedial course of study. Exit achieves the manufacturing industry that collect to be met atrophic, the resource that can get from his country is less and less also.
10 years, after 20 years, as the rise of the developing country, the Japanese product that does not have price advantage originally also will lose even technical dominant position. Did not have the goods that can exchange with exotic nation again, japanese is contended for to praedial contention as poor villager without report, without warm, without the gas, adobe that does not have oil thatched cottage.
So, although enterprise and person cannot leave land, how many what should the value of land take company profit? How many what should take individual income? This also does not have a standard on the world. But, japanese resource deficient must be exchanged with the product of hi-tech content, this is in Japan the society is a kind of consensus. Residential market value of Japan, establishing Japanese residence state-owned group to arrive 85 years from 55 years is all the time by governmental dominant. So, japanese government defeats bubble disclose have enough social base.
Still want to repeat a specification again is: Talk about estate to have bubble, should limitting estate above all is to be treated as " tool " will use or be treated as " antique " will collect. Be treated as only " tool " when, house price ability and hypostatic economy are contacted together directly. If be treated as " antique " , house price and hypostatic economy did not have direct connection. If do not have such limitting, estate has also cannot mention without bubble, the result can be to say each word each only.
