Should cancel.
If say to exercise a volition, actually sports drills completely OK and contented demand, and more scientific more continuously. Able-bodied physique nature is the helper with best volition, short-term military training can not satisfy this, military training can be fostered exercise a habit, this is afraid without enough dependency.
If say,be to be national defence to lay in a talent, but the war when making an undergraduate large-scale arouse is afraid early failed, unless be,be antagonism extraterrestrial. And, the content of military training in fact height is onefold, it is alignment training. A lot of people care the origin that alignment trains far from, this is the training that the latter-day army that 17-18 century begins undertakes to organize discipline, this is at that time the foundation of dogface linear tactics. And now it is discipline sex, this also is the foundation of relevant tactical training, it is the group that should cooperate with photograph of many tactical training and stabilizes adjust ability significant, importance is inferior to going far. So, short-term alignment trains perhaps school leadership can see square group, but short-term alignment won't have any tactical value, do not have a help actually to national defence. Want tactical training? Do you know so that how many money spend army trains?
Still a few leaders always think military training can help discipline sex, but only long-term, ability meets group of arms of taxi of at least 1 year of above to have such discipline truly gender and constituent capacity, and even if is such, still hold to army of the sort of work and rest veteran how many can you have? Want to form the habit of lifetime to the training of a month, this is far from likely. Even if to compulsory arms, discipline function is maintained how to long also be a problem. Arms of obligation of Korea the whole people, is Korean discipline sex very strong? I look also not likely, be inferior to the Japanese that only a few personnel are enlisting in army even. Additional, discipline sex is helpful perhaps to should trying education, it is not certain also that to the college education is afraid appropriate, college education is so multivariate, impossible that with onefold discipline the gender can improve the result, professional to the part it is to have ruinous effect even.
Because military training does not have the value of materiality this now, even if is to make army off actually unqualified also, because soldiers give a person training actually not as relaxed as daily training, at least voice calls dumb situation particularly much. A lot of v/arc drillmaster had said, military training is tiredder than training, at least this is not the work with relaxed what.
Want to improve national defence efficiency and college education efficiency, we are afraid need has new thinking.
=====================================
Look a lot of people read capability very finite really, when do I say centrally.
1, cancel military training to differ to be taught at cancelling national defence, means of national defence education is too much, the military training that flows at the form is among them a the worst kind, national defence teachs a form to be able to change, technical ability of visiting barback, study is more important than alignment phalanx much, not necessary do large concentration to train.
2, the efficiency of military training is very low, without the action of what essence, be in more impossibly 2 considerate form in the time of a month alleged discipline feels or group spirit. If this goes, recruit battalion needs 3 months for what, just promote 6 months again? The opportunity of harden oneself volition is more, the to person volition go through the mill when I want that I cannot find the job is far exceed military training.
3, when the so-called gain of military training just appears in enter a school fitly just, the hindering move of year of half ability military training after enter a school group? The effect was not distinguished.
4, the military training that flows generally now at the form does not have a help at all to national defence, only experienced alignment was not to hit those who battle, now is not 17 or 18 centuries, are you to want to establish Ma Jidu phalanx or Qin Zhen? Want to help really, train fire, tactics to cooperate at least, the dogface that urgent medical treatment waits field operations a moment is basic mastery of a skill or technique is much mainer than alignment, but which school Fu Deqi's so huge pay wages or salaries to have again so?
5, do not hold what illusion to this kind of military training, him person of the line on a lot of raise to the higher plane of principle presses a root to did not accept military training to pass in the university, this looks to come out.
6, change a thinking just, as to look utterly wretched? The day does not collapse to come down again.
===================================
Thank the crosscurrent of cogency of the part in the comment, regretting is valuable crosscurrent is too little really, as to put a label on sb wash wash sleep cough up. Here responds to crosscurrent again.
1, student constitution not beautiful is a problem, but the military training that this is not less than of a month can change, most the education of daily still sports of core. Sports education has at least two main reasons infirmly relatively, it is high strenth to should try educational mode to issue a large number of squeezing to take the time of sports education firstly, it is the risk of sports education itself on the other hand. Cooperate to what latter needs a society and consensus, the school and need of door of Ministry of Education have enough safe mechanism, the accident should assume collective responsibility and encountering is not to swing responsibility to give at will when thing teacher individual; On the other hand the parent also needs to realize to there is a risk from beginning to end in teaching a course normally. It is easy that this says, should do breathe out breathe out Da. Because of the constitution not beautiful is about military training, this is both between did not answer like that logistic connection. The Chinese lacks exercising habit and culture, realize to existing to contact the thing that also is special in recent years between the body and volition, promotion sports education (of course, should not bring into again should try educational system to fall, existing high strenth should try education the system is already saturated) be necessary completely, first step is far on military training.
2, national defence teachs far more than military training a kind, want to strive for social support in fact, what army should do is more, for instance barback opens day is very important way, the effect is better also. As to military training, if only stand in line lists that to still had cancelled, waste man power and money does not have meaning of a bit essence. Do not cancel that should the form is more bit more diversiform, show emergency treatment of tactics of arms of ride instead of walk, modern CQB, fire, field operations, not only to national defence, also nod vanity to have very good help then to field activity and even contented youth, this is gotten more actually than station alignment much, useful also much, expensive also of course much. Station a few weeks alignment, cannot arouse the person's enthusiasm at all, won't have real knowledge to national defence more.
3, uniform collective force is very powerful, but not be the power source with modern real society, the society of diversity of incommensurate also height. Individual with need has a balance between collective.
4, a lot of people to that " when need arouses the war when the undergraduate is early failed " be troubled Yu Huai, I think those who say is, modern war destroys truly between the country greatly country the war is very few, and the presence that increases nuke, foreground is afraid early the miserable situation that surmounts battlefield of Sude of World War II. The warlike core between big country is defy in the system, extensive ground force action is actually limited with each passing day. Very unfortunate is, in recent years asymmetry war also makes clear, the level that opposes bushfighting is rising greatly, bushfighting is essential when facing the army with truly well-trained excellent equipment cannot get victory, cannot see exception at present, if not be big country,casualties of civilian of legionary and common fear brings political influence, kill a guerrilla actually not difficult. In contemporary world order, make undergraduates true develop a strong point, get used to the society of diversity and market demand, obtain obtain employment, devote into research and development to realize pay taxes and technology to upgrade thereby, more appropriative than letting them go the dogface of a robot type to comprehensive national power rise useful much, useful also to peace much. This just also is military training cannot push the account that takes too much time.
If this world follows the world in sprayer brain euqally simple, that it may not be a bad idea.
