Square boatman oppugns Pan Jianwei to teach is not things any more.
Square boatman basically oppugns Pan Jianwei's quanta to add close communication to have exaggerated suspicion, and be the experiment of crave for greatness and success.
In fact, the core of scientific spirit is doubt, this boatman does not have a fault. But doubt spirit needs to have evidence, have the doubt of the bottom line. is not general its talk, debase Pan Jianwei blindly, even assault and battery.
There is how old effect in adding close communication to be carried out in application after all as to quanta, I want those who take out authentic evidence to refute to netizens are OK without the level, include square him boatman. Difference in profession makes one feel worlds apart, if do not have solid quanta mechanical foundation, and corresponding scientific research experience. Debase Pan Jianwei blindly, this is completely inappropriate.
How should be we oppugned then?
That believes the person of the same trade's appraise sth through discussion namely. Pan Jianwei does not offer the security that quanta increases close communication.
1993 when, beineite takes the lead in advancing the idea that quanta corresponds, after this wants numerous scientist to pass from theoretic strict analysis again, think quanta communication can achieve absolutely security in in principle consistently.
And square boatman atttacks Pan Jianwei, oppugn the absolute safety that the quanta that Pan Jianwei says corresponds. Actually he is not in doubt Pan builds Wei, more the expert that resembling is communication of quanta of doubt of doctor of a biochemistry.
Be like, expert of computer of pharmaceutics home doubt is same.
Above all Professor Pan Jianwei is in 2013 when his research the paper sent international authority physics periodical " physics comments on wall bulletin " on.
2015, be in new research paper hair again " natural " on periodical. His research achievement also got academia approbate. Of course, the person of the same trade's opposition sound also has, but the mainstream still approbates.
Actually any scientific papers can suffer doubt more or less, progress scientificly in oppugning sound just about. Special relativity just expressed time, object not only by the academia, still by inhospitality several years. But what this also cannot prevent the theory of relativity is great.
Scientific theory is in namely progress in trial and error ceaselessly come out.
Previously, we lagged behind in domain of fundamental scientific research, the doubt tone of scientific research domain is so little also, because consider those who remain to is the west plays, forefathers has been done, it is practicable so.
We are in now certain domain not only pull up to the west, still be in even surmount, on the road that this asks ourselves is being explored without forefathers alone before row.
The logic of square boatman depends on: Hesperian is done do not know quanta communication, can the Chinese go?
In fact, the Chinese also should assume the responsibility of trial and error that has pair of sealed and scientific fields.
Once western scientist took a government a large number of allowance search aether, discover aether is nonexistent finally, but this does not prove these money are spent in vain. Instead this " failure " the experiment proved velocity of light is changeless, this also laid experimental foundation for relativistic birth.
The scientist always exerts all his strength in some domain occasionally truer. Proof quanta is for instance mechanical the shellfish Er experiment of completeness. Although the scientist thinks quanta is mechanical generally,be complete, but shellfish Er experiment still suffers flaw, the scientist always wants to find the completeness that the Bell experiment that does not have flaw completely proves quanta is mechanical.
Be this kind of truer spirit, just be the mankind's most precious fortune.
According to the logic of square boatman: The Chinese is explored a little in uncharted territory go, if do not have,effect should collect a hand.
According to this kind of logic, searching gravitation wave is the project of waste man power and money. Because the mankind was spent full centenary ability was confirmed the existence of gravitation wave, this did not know to spend how many money among them.
I think, we want to be explored ceaselessly in uncharted territory not only, do not be afraid of a fault even. Only such ability let our country hold position in background science domain.
